Ok!I want to know if anyone is writing an Edward Elric Romance! I want to read it!I'll rate good!

No way.

I bet nobody writes romance about Edward Elric EVER!

Writing Edward Elric in a romance makes him look feminine, goddamit! >O

You know what would be the craziest most outrageous thing EVER?

If someone wrote a story about Ed bumping into a seemingly normal girl, but she really has a tragic past involving alchemy and she's super special, and then, they fall in LOVE.

Wouldn't that be something else? I bet nobody's done anything like it before!

NEVA! That'd go against the laws of Toby-ism! << *shakes fist*

I hereby temporarily revoke the laws of Toby-ism in order to dare you to come up with something as original as that! (For those of you who are new to the cult- by the laws of Toby-ism, nobody in fanfics are ever allowed to find Edward Elric attractive, because Toby does not find Edward Elric attractive.)

The only romance fanfics with Ed I do are EdxWinry and I got positive comments on them ^^. But random romance for Ed is *shudders* I can't even think a word.

I prefer RoyxRiza romance and EdxWinry romance are okay but random Ed romance... it always seems to be the same plot like this:

Ed is traveling, meets this girl who so cool and pretty and they fall in love!

That just doesn't interest me -____-;

OMG, I had a dream about that, and I was like, where did that come from? I was going to write about it, but it was to out there.

Maybe I'll try Ed and Rose because they are meant to be together because Dante said he loves her and Rose was waiting for him and he rescured her from the blah blah blah...

You should do it! With your talent, you could achieve it! Be ORIGINAL!



No no no, Rose loves Ed, because Ed is her baby's daddy! Durrrrr~

O M G, you are so totally right, I mean if you look at the baby its like a lil Edo.

Serious note: What would be an original romance BUT would please the masses? Is there no such thing?

No idea. Maybe if someone one day succeeds to create an OC that is human, with both fair qualities and defaults...but I bet some would still call it a Sue/Stue. Of course, Sues are annoying, but people who call every OCs sues/stues are also. Oh, btw! Take a look at this: http://sled-moose.net/hagaren/index.php?link=suecross

Doesn't it seem interesting?

She needs to drag his arse onto Maury for a paternity test.

(>.>... In all seriousness, I did write a fic on that premise. It's been in my beta's hands for three months now)



Densha Otoko!!!

Seriously, I have no idea. Some people just don't like romance, which is something to factor in.




I hate you. I'm a mess of old unused challenges, and this looks really interesting! :<

(I already did write an OC-involved with a canon character and a serious Utena crossover, if that counts for anything.)

They weren't meant for eachother! Dante` only said that so brainwash her. Rose was waitng for him because she was brainwashed and Ed danced with her because umm...........................................thats how the damn directers of the anime wanted it. >.>;;

Chi was kidding, ya know... I thought it was obvious... AND DON'T EVER DO THE ELLIPSE ORGY THING AGAIN KTHX!


>P

I myself have an OC in mind but...I don't even know if she's a Sue. <<; She doesn't even have shinyyyy eyes and hair~ though I know it's not the only thing that makes a Sue...I should just steal an OC from CMO~

The people who wrote the first comments...you guys are so mean...seriously, there are a lot of people who are writing storys like that, i've read them all, but then when you say writing those kinds of things is insane...It kind of makes them feel bad. I'm making my own series myself and I just needed new ideas...why don't you people go on quizilla, there's thousands of them...

...sorry...




...*erases all the storys*

...But what are your thoughts on yaoi?

Huh? I could have sworn that I wrote that as 'baby daddy'.

IS SOME SLIMEY MOD INTERFERING WITH MY INTENTIONALLY GRAMMATICALLY VOID POSTS? How dare they? >:C




I've never really understood myself why there are fanfics on quizilla. I thought it was a quiz site.

I doubt you've read them all. Reading all of the Ed/Mary-Sue romances out there would be a bigger task than reading all the horrible Roy/Ed out there. There are too many, and they're all the same.

We were being sarcastic, honey. At the fact that there are literally thousands of fangirls who all write these stories, all pretty much the same, all to fulfill their romantic fantasies about a fictional character. Usually the stories are very unoriginal, and make little sense, or defy the laws of logic. Thus our facecious banter of "omg that would be insanely original!"

Lighten up a little. We were having a bit of fun. <3




I'm sorry. You have the better answer.

*grins* Well, if you find any good romances involving Edward, let me know. I can't seem to find them anywhere!


....O WINRLY, Toby? XD

Well there is quizilla. go look up AlchemyRomance. I think she is really good writer. She has really good stories about Edward Elric. She's made 49 of them. (I've read them all. If you dont think its possible, it is. I just have a lot of free time. ) you can also check out KittenAngel59. I read all of those too. They are really good. please check them out.

All of this seriously made me wanna crack up. Thanks for making my day! XD

XD I hate sue stories but I find myself reading them constantly for reasons unknown.

Not EVERY OC is a marysue (I'm sure yours isn't, Toby) just a good chunk of them are XD and this thread is funny...