well ur list isnt good, ill reread it during school and fix everything

isn't good? why do you say it isn't good?XD And I don't think you'll be able to check for everything at school... you'll need the episodes in front of you :s.

"isn't good? why do you say it isn't good?XD And I don't think you'll be able to check for everything at school... you'll need the episodes in front of you :s."

after skimming thru ive seen mistakes i can correct, and i have watched each episode at least 10 times so i dont need them in front of me

oh, it was you XD I already replied to your answers to that episodes ^^ anyways, those are the ones I care the least, what I find more important is in the second half of the anime.. specially reaching the ending. I had to watch all the episodes to make sure and check that what I was going to say was true, even making exact quotes and translations directly from japanese.

? it was me? i only created this thread havent even seen u before this thread

i also read some of the 27-51 episode mistakes and u basiaclly keep repeating the same mistakes over and over again, but i can counter most of them

I repeat them if they repeat themselfs (Note that I took all the ones I could find per episode, and not anime itself. I posted some concerning to anime itself in the ending though, as the 7 year gap and all). And yeah, there was someone in this thread who said he had read 6 mistakes and that they weren't mistakes and that he was going to fix the list and that he didn't need to see the episodes to do that. So I thought it was you XD

Anyways, I'll wait 'till you post your ideas towards it ^^

k well lets end this conv. cuz the mods might close this, i might have the list done by friday

Reika,i can't see anything.

>.< odd... I can e-mail them to you, PM me if you want ^^

@Maes Hughes: How's the list fixing going?

i just finished the list last night (friday) and i posted it on the front page.

Okay, I'll start reading them now. So far, I read the first one, and you'll understand why I said that you need to check for what you are going to say before posting it.

ya i understood everything, im not trying to make fun of you or anything, that list must have taken a while

Well, I found something "interesting", and it's that you changed some of my writings. I found one now and I hope you didn't change any other. I'm currently at episode 41, point 4. Hopefully, I'll be able to finish answering you today.

i only changed ur spelling errors.


like, explaint to explained, and others like that

Note: im pretty sure i didnt change your writting except for the errors because if i did then that would be rude, and others wouldnt get the "real" copy.

Tell me what's the correction from "Abortion" to "Orphan". Because they are two very different things. (Thanks for the ortography changes, though XD) I was like "Why the hell did I write that? It doesn't make sense :s" And then it hit me, I compared with the original document and I discovered the difference.

I have read both documents...

oh come on, you just explained anything with "probably"s and "maybe"s... with theories, no proofs... I don't think you answered them... you said your theories (and you may be right... or may not)

Brat'ja: lala lalalaaaaaaaaaa lala lala... (8)

oh please XDDDDDDDD what's this? "Let's see if I can make up what I don't know and Bones does not explain" ?

As Stuart said, some of your theories (few of them, in my opinion) are good, but they are no proofs, so you can't "answer" the "unanswered question", you only can figure out how they could be...

most of these theroies are 80% correct, Bones didnt leave them unanswered he left them for you to find out. or and srry about the abortation and orphan thing i read it with abortation and was spacing and said that should be orphan ill fix that soon

The Theroys are atleast 80% correct tho as stated above, they have all been driven from my knowledge of the show. and bones could have left some unanswered for the viewers to figure it out.

i will fix the orphan abortion soon

EDIT: my theroys are the best probably any one could have answered those questions and the only theroys basically are the questions about the homunculi and the door

oh my oh my oh my XDDDDDDDD


That's what you think, why are you SURE you are correct? so, Bones left things without answer and you can explain all with "probably" and "maybe", and then you think they are correct?! XDDDDDDD oh please.


maybe are the best, but the best option is not allways the correct, an anime can be a bad anime and have worse answer... there is no official answers, there is no official theories, so... your opinion is as good as my own... as good as nothing because they are only theories and BONES didn't spend time to answer... I know there is times when the anime left things without answer to the viewer to think... but no so much, and no so much fails XD, there ARE fails, there ARE script fails, contradictions... you can't explain a contradiction XD

DANTE: Homunculus are weak in front of their creator's bones

later

GREED: We are are weak in front of our own bones

Brat'ja: lala lalaaaaaaa lalaaaaaaaaaa lala (8)

explain that with a "bones left to us to figure it out" please ^^

oh, please! I can't really believe my eyes!! XDDDDD

oh, I almost forget, Reika is spending time to fix your theories, and she is even searching for pictures, maybe you'll see that you need to check the caps so you can discuss properly ^^

...greed said homunculi are weakened if front of their creators bones, and Dante said homunculi are weakened in front of their own bones. also

explain that with a "bones left to us to figure it out" please ^^

...you really are a b**** arnt you. and what did i get wrong in my therory? my therory was solid in the homunculi weakened part.

bones probably just made a mistake since ALL the homunculi that were destroyed where infront of their OWN bones


EDIT: if Bones spent time answering ALL of the questions than it would add like another 20 episodes or so which would make the anime longer and 51 is a REALLY good number for episodes g2g brb soon

first of all, if you are going to quote something, do it properly so we can understand what you say.


Who the hell do you think you are?! you f****** piece of f****! I really hate to came in this kind of conversation! but you ended pushing me hard with that post! Listen! ok? you are not BONEs, you are not the script writer, you are NOTHING and NOONE to say that there is no mistakes without a proof. If you can't stand the truth and you think you are some kind of super heroe just because you make up all the answer, that's no a reason for insult, you know? I really don't care if I recieve a warning 'cause of this, but I'm not going to stand and see how a 10 years mind-old boy is insulting me without reason. You can be WRONG, you know? we can too! but you haven't a proof for what you say, admit it and maybe we'll be able continue with our lifes!


MISTAKE, see? MISTAKE, wiiiiiiii yohooooo, mistake XD hurray! XD



oh.. wow, so 51 is a magic number of something? if the series need 20 caps more, maybe it worth it. And... if they didn't had commited all the fails, in first place, they didn't have need 20 caps more to explain it.

please lets try to stay on topic, and i never said there were no mistakes, and 51 is a good number because inuyasha=way too long, cowboy bebop= a little too short, and FMA=51 good amount for 2 seasons, even 60 would be a bit too much, they ended it fairly well. because the movie is next.

Gods, I've never seen Dai this way...

Ok, I answered you, everyone of them Maes Hughes, and if you are willing to still answer me, do it checking the episodes, and giving reasons which can't be answered with a "prove it", you know, I could have been doing better things. And you didn't need to call "B****" to Dai. I won't do this again, I'll answer only to those that can give real reasons as to say "no, this can be answered because of this this and this, stated here here and there". If you have theories, put them as "My theory on this" and not "it's easy, because this this and this" <-- Prove it.

I have to say that it was rather easy, it "just" took 10 hours of my life, even taking pictures to prove what I say and checking for the episodes and dialogues, when the actual document took me a whole week.

I think there was another one saying he was going to fix it too. I think he/she should read this document first, and think if what he is going to state, or the way, is going to be the same. If it is, I'm warning you since now, I won't answer you.

Now, here you have the document:
http://es.geocities.com/aahboba/hello.pdf

EDIT: You should add this document to your front post too, where you so eagerly announced this UQ were Answered.

Look, there is NEVER any reason to call anyone a b*** no matter what. If someone is getting you mad, or you think they're insulting you, that's what mods and admins are for. Dai was being pretty polite, I think, he didn't call YOU any names, Maes-Hughes, and he didn't insult you. If you were on YS, I'd get the admin to freeze your account for saying something like that.

EDIT- I just thought of this. How did Scar just 'know' how to create the Philosopher's Stone Transmutation circle? Did a magical little fairy just fly up and tell him how? (note extreme sarcasm)

quick note: the ouroboros is EITHER!! a snake or a dragon according to ALL alchemy books.


reply

First of all, if you are going to quote something, do it properly so we can understand what you say.

QUOTE(Maes-Hughes @ Sep 4 2005, 12:33 AM)
...you really are a b**** arnt you. and what did i get wrong in my therory? my therory was solid in the homunculi weakened part.

Who the hell do you think you are?! you f****** piece of f****! I really hate to came in this kind of conversation! but you ended pushing me hard with that post! Listen! ok? you are not BONEs, you are not the script writer, you are NOTHING and NOONE to say that there is no mistakes without a proof. If you can't stand the truth and you think you are some kind of super heroe just because you make up all the answer, that's no a reason for insult, you know? I really don't care if I recieve a warning 'cause of this, but I'm not going to stand and see how a 10 years mind-old boy is insulting me without reason. You can be WRONG, you know? we can too! but you haven't a proof for what you say, admit it and maybe we'll be able continue with our lifes!


Nothing + No one? i know more about FMA than you do according to ur first post, Reika said for any opinions/answers to her/hist list, so i did that and know you are rediculing me for putting my opinions out. Also i will edit Reika's new list.

QUOTE
bones probably just made a mistake since ALL the homunculi that were destroyed where infront of their OWN bones

MISTAKE, see? MISTAKE, wiiiiiiii yohooooo, mistake XD hurray! XD

...hes teasing me there


QUOTE
EDIT: if Bones spent time answering ALL of the questions than it would add like another 20 episodes or so which would make the anime longer and 51 is a REALLY good number for episodes g2g brb soon

oh.. wow, so 51 is a magic number of something? if the series need 20 caps more, maybe it worth it. And... if they didn't had commited all the fails, in first place, they didn't have need 20 caps more to explain it.


Also: i spent more than 5 hours explaining to him everything, i didnt do ALL that just to be ridiculed.
My Therorys ALL have backing to them, i just dont pull them out of a hat. I dont lie, so if i think you are a ***** i will say it. Ask anyone here



REVISED: Here Please Pm me for any questions as this board is getting out of hand with the rude comments about my answers that i believe are the best, i also would like more people to put their opinions. There are some i didnt reply to because i forgot to scroll back up and fix them. and i dont have any more time to fix it.

Am I the only one that feels someone should stop those two? They went too far.



I have to point out something about this. This post didn't lose control by any chance because of your opinions, it was because when Dai told you something about your opinions, you went and called him B****. The one who started it was you, and don't deny it, it's all posted here.

I'll quote it for you:


He was being polite, and what did you do? Call him B****. He answered to your opinions, he said "I don't think a maybe and a perhaps can give a real answer to them", and that is HIS opinion, as it is yours that they can. So I don't think you had any right to insult him, and less to say that this was going out of control because of rude comments towards your comments and opinions.

I think you spected everyone to have the same opinion as you, and you hit the floor. And I'm not trying to say your theories are bad, or that I know more about FMA than you as you are saying all over this topic to me, actually, I agree with some of your theories, I'm just stating that the 90% of them or more CAN'T be proved, and because of that, they can't give an answer to the questions. Guessing never gave a real answer to anything.



I'll read your document, but if they are theories I won't answer them. 1)They are your theories (and so I respect them)
2)They can't prove anything.

Also, please, stop using the word "fix", it's more suitable "change" or "answer with my theories"

oh, you people posted a lot XD I love this forum.


Thanks Seventh_sky, I know I crossed the line in my last post, but I can't stand people like him, as I said, I'm ready to recieve any warn or message from a mod, but I think both of us should recieve one XD

About Scar knowing the transmutation circle, according to Maes Hughes (the user, of course XD), he did it... by chance.

XDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD
DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD
DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD
DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD

cof cof, sorry XD. yeah, of course, you know? just yesterday I succeeded to make a transmutation just by chance! in real world! so cool I am! oh please.


I know, and you are the person which knows me better, so you can say how hard this guy (see, guy, not b**** ^^) push me out from my nerves XD (sorry if this sentence make no so much sense).


you know? there is alchemy books where Ouroboros appears like an eagle head (well, it is a bird, but I think it looks like an eagle), with serpent tail... maybe you must document yourself all you can before you post so emphatically ^^ Alchemy just took Mythology and Astrology elements (like astral glyphs, or the chimeras) just to make up an empirical science.


(first: you think you are more importand or you are more right just because you write in red? ^^)

Well, I have watched FMA anime five times, I have read the manga twice (and I'm in my 3rd time), I can assure I know a lot about Greek Mythology and I know a lot about real alchemy (well, real, you know, I mean the alchemy in our world)

but, you know? The important thing is Alchemy in FMA world, no in our world... and in FMA, they see the ouroboros like a serpent... and Reika even post for you a lot of pictures about it... so, if we just see the Alchemy terms in FMA, Ouroboros is a serpent. And if YOU know more than anyone here about FMA world, you should have realized about this, shouldn't you?

Well, let's see, my first post in this topic was:


and my second:


and my first post in this forum was:


so... can you tell me wich one is telling you I know less about FMA than you, please?

and, I think the post about the manga says that I bother to document myself before posting ^^


noooooo, I'm just celebrating you can admit a fail ^^.

hey, a typo! "hes", and it is not your first one... and you are the one which dare to correct Reika's typos? uy pero qué valor XD


don't worry, I'm not going to spent any more second with this guy... yeah, I think guy suits now, I don't want to strech this XD

i already contacted a mod asking him to close my thread, also i corrected reika's typos like explaint and mispellings not hes to he's because that is all too common of a mistake, and half the time i do forget the ' because i dont usually type correct. i jususe alot of wut, w/e, w/o, u, r, 2, y, hes, cuz, nm, just im slang.



(first: you think you are more importand or you are more right just because you write in red? ^^)

i wrote in red to distingish the difference so its not hard to findmy replys. also i was referring to your first post in THIS thread.

but, you know? The important thing is Alchemy in FMA world, no in our world... and in FMA, they see the ouroboros like a serpent... and Reika even post for you a lot of pictures about it... so, if we just see the Alchemy terms in FMA, Ouroboros is a serpent. And if YOU know more than anyone here about FMA world, you should have realized about this, shouldn't you?


already answered the ouroboros question. Serpent is a general term. whenever i think about serpent i think of a half dragon/half snake. and the ouroboros that envy turns into is definetly a serpent.


Serpent: limbless scaly elongate reptile; some are venomous

I'm only going to answer this, because I'm really tired to argue with someone like you. Serpent is a specie, like cats, or dogs, it is not like "feline" or "canine"... are you telling that a dragon is a kind of serpent? oh please

Maes, I respect you and all but... read well what they write, he wrote his first post in this thread and then the first one of the forum.

oh, so you start this discussion and when they answer you, you hide your tail and run away?

If you hadn't started to insult, there would no facts to close the post.

Well, I'm with Reika, what did he write to tell you that he didn't know about FMA? I'm a little confussed here.

reason for closing: its becoming a riot.


Well, I'm with Reika, what did he write to tell you that he didn't know about FMA? I'm a little confussed here.

I was talking about Dai, HERE
DANTE: Homunculus are weak in front of their creator's bones

later

GREED: We are are weak in front of our own bones



Dante said that they are weakened in front of their own bones
Greed said that they are weakened in front of their creators bones

*BIG SIGH*, watch the episode, Maes... you are wrong... I checked in the videos I have, and I can assure you it is the way Dai said. Also I stated that this way in my document and you didn't say anything. So it seems Dai is more aware about what's said in the episodes than you.

Man, you are confussing everyone XD

sigh

thanks Reika, I have nothing to add ^^

Greed says right when he is about to die, the secret to the homunculi is that they are weakened if front of their CREATORS BONES

helloooooooooo? that's not right, Sloth was weak in front of Ed's mother rests, Envy was weak in front of Scar's brother's wife's hair, and Pride was weak in front of his own skull... did you really see the anime?

...they are weakened by their own bones
Sloth is weakened in front of HER bones, she was weakened not in front of her CREATORS bones which would be Ed + Al's

Lust=Scar's Brother wife

They were all weakened in front of their bones!!

Well, you kids had your warning.