I've searched that in the entire volume 15 and I can say it isn't there. Given that it is the long Ishval flashblack volume, I doubt the scene can be found somewhere else... but how to know?

Anyway, either you're a bit mistaken about the scene details or it just doesn't exist, that's what I think. ^^U

No, there's a short Ishbal flashback scene before that- only a few pages. Roy's remembering. It might be there.

Maybe you're talking about this?
http://www.onemanga.com/Full_Metal_Alchemist/34/26/
I've checked that searching for Forsaken's scene but I don't think that is the one that he's searching.

Can anyone please help me with a scene? I'm serching for the part where Mustang and Madam Christmas were down in a bassement for all I remember. I think it was somewhere before Bradley set off the train that exploded.Thanks

http://www.onemanga.com/Full_Metal_Alchemist/87/08/
Right?

thank you very much XD

Does anyone know in which chapter Winry noticed that Ed is taller then her?

Well, I don't think she actually noticed because they were too busy arguing, but in chapter 84 it's clear that Ed is taller than her

http://www.onemanga.com/Full_Metal_Alchemist/84/16/

^maybe they're referring to the 'back' part, where she sees him walk down the corridoor? *yawn oooh its so late* I'd find it but im too sleepy...*daze daze*

^Oh, well if that's the case, it's in chapter 44: http://www.onemanga.com/Full_Metal_Alchemist/44/37/

Hey if anyone knows the scenes where Scar and Miles interact with each other in anyway, that'd be great. I mean if they do at all. Ive missed a lot of the scenes where Scar meets other Ishvallians. I'm interested to see his reaction to an Ishvallian in the military.

JELEE- I think it was from V.18, on this page that they first meet and start to have a conversation.

Yap, and.. I recommend reading that whole chapter, as that chapter has some deep stuff. ^^
But.... the scanlation for that particular chapter on Onemanga.com is just... so... bad. >.<
If you can, try to locate the better scanlation.. I know much better scanlation is out there for that particular chapter. ^^ Or, read the official scanlation, like, if you can find the volume book for that chapter (Vol. 18) in your local library. IMO it's worth doing that for that chapter.

Yeah, I know there are better scans, but I just wanted to located and link the page for JELEE quickly so she would know that there was indeed a chapter where they met. Sorry. DX

^ Oh, no no, thank you for answering JELEE's question and showing the chapter and page! Much appreciated! ^^ You guys are awesome! And, oops, if my last post gave out any negative vibe for your fine post, sorry! That was not my intention at all. ^^
(ETA: I edited my last post. Hope it would sound little better now. ^^ )

Where's that scene where Olivia and Alex are fighting against Sloth?

Where's that scene where Olivia and Alex are fighting against Sloth?

It's spread through quite many chapters, but it begins in chapter 91 and ends in chapter 96.

Thanks much!

Does anyone know where the scene is from when Ed was little and was ma d at his mom, and hohenheim gave him that bucket of water to hold?
I'm looking for it but I don't know where to start.

The part you're looking for is called "The Elric Family Omake" (from volume 14).

Try this link:
http://www.fullmetal-alchemist.com/forums/...showtopic=11168

^ Thanks Kuura!!!

Can anyone locate the scene in which it's stated that Mustang can't become Fuhrer due to the actions he's taking in trying to overthrow the military (i.e. kidnapping the Fuhrer's wife, etc.) because they don't/won't want a rebel at the top of the ranks?

(Unless I am imagining this scene, which is perfectly possible.)

Thanks!

EDIT: Or is that possibly a scene from the first anime?

<Program Note>

@GRINcoorge - Your post was taken out. Please stop making spam-offtopic postings.

--------------

Back on-topic:

BTW, I don't off-hand have the answer to temmy's scene search question above.. If anyone has the info/answer, please kindly post. ^^

Edit: Thought I knew it, nevermind. I think that may be anime only.

Antone remeber which chapter they introduce the armstrongs siblings?
To be specific, Im talking about this pic:

Ok, I've tried searching, with little success (I'm probably not looking in exactly the right place). I looked in the omake thread to see if I could find the omake where Riza gets Black Hayate, but the only scan I see is the final page, where she names the pup. Does anyone have the location of the full "Dog In The Military" omake (where Hayate shows up, and the various members of the Roy tachi explain why they can't take him?). Also, if there's a scan of the scene where Riza "potty trains" Hayate, that would be awesome.<3 Thanks!

@mersaydee: You can find the Dog of the Military gaiden here:
http://www.fullmetal-alchemist.com/forums/...showtopic=11168

I can't say any specific chapter, but I'm pretty sure it was a single omake (one and only which introduced all Armstrong siblings).

^ This Armstrong siblings omake was in Vol. 17.

Thanks Sneaky and Michiyo!

Ah - thank you so much, my friend! You've made me a happy girl. Much appreciated.

Can anyone point me to the scene in the manga where Scar says he wants to work to change Amestris. I remember him saying this but I can't seem to find it.

Thanks!

Chapter 84.

Thank You

Hmm so the anime for some reason added this scene a bit earlier.

Would anyone happen to know where it mentions that Grumman is Riza's grandpa and Christmas is Roy's foster mother? I have a friend who wants to read those particular scenes.

@angelofsarcasm89 - They are stated so in the Guidebooks (separate entries in separate Guidebooks.)

* Madam Christmas' entry is in the recently published Character Guide, and you can read more on this on this post. (also scroll down to my post there for the translation of the scanned entry ^^)

* General Grumman's entry is in Perfect Guidebook 2, and you can read more on this on this post (or on several other posts, but this is the one I just found XD)

BTW, we will be moving this Q&A to FMA Character Q&A thread in a while.

Sadly what can be read in manga is only mentioning Madam Christmas is Roy's foster mother. (here is the place in manga, if your friend watches Brotherhood, it should be in episode 48 this Sunday)

But the other facts are said in Character Guideboks. In Character Guidbook 2 in Grumman's profile is stated he's Riza's grandfather (again, we don't even know whether or not she's aware of it) and in Character Guidebook 3 we get to know Madam Christmas is Roy's father's sister. (side 105, here's the picture)

Oh, too late I see . Tombow, please feel free to delete my post.

@SneakyRuler - No problem. Thank you for posting the help. ^^ ~ Tombow

Searching for the mention that Major Miles is married! I just found out about it and can't believe I overlooked this. Was this mentioned in the manga, or one of the guidebooks? Any help is appreciated!

Now that I went digging for the right chapter in my manga collection, I'm not sure he's married.


Anyway, according to the translation used for this scanlation of 65 he's married. While Viz's translation mentions his mother, not wife.

The scanlation was put out by ZomgFTA, who I trust.

Any translators that read the raw willing to help us sort this out?

@Causmicfire - I can't find the raw for that chapter at the moment. If you can find the raw, please post the raw page, and I can tell you what the raw says.

Thanks Tombow!

Click to view attachment

It should say in the bottom right panel.

Whoops - causmicfire beat me to it! I was just about to post the RAW.

Thank you for posting the raw page. ^^

Yes, he says WIFE in that bubble, and CSakuras' translation in that ZOMGFTA scanlation page posted above is "right on." (as usual ^^) That was my vague memory of reading that chapter in raw also, but I did not want to post and confirm that until I double checked with the raw page.

Good to know I hadn't been giving out wrong information...

Thanks you guys, for the help! I appreciate it.

I was wondering which scene in the manga do we find out that Grumman is Riza's grandfather?

Welcome to our board, omitertul!

There is no scene in FMA manga that has General Grumman directly saying that Riza is his granddaughter. although there are some scenes in which he mentions his granddaughter. (If you're interested, we had several related discussions on this, including a discussion on whether Roy/Riza knew about this, etc., such as one here. ^^)

The information that Riza is Grumman's grandchildren is coming form FMA Perfect Guidebook 2. I think we talked about this in several places in our forums, and you can read one of those here.

Oh I see! Thanks a lot (: