Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Fanfiction Section In The Forum
Fullmetal Alchemist Discussion Board > Site Support Center > Member Requests and Suggestions
Pages: 1, 2
Ghost
Where have I been? 'Tis a long tale, full of intrigue and betrayal. Adventure and peril! Darkness...and the coming light. It begins...

I've been playing World of Warcraft. I guess that wasn't such a long story after all.
unsure.gif ...aheh. Hm.

Omakase, you are just too sweet. Thank you very much for your perpetually kind words. Truth is, I kinda forgot that I'd actually have check the forums if I wanted to keep abreast of things. I was used to just responding when I found replies in my e-mail, but obviously that doesn't keep one informed of new topics and such.

So my absence is largely due to my being silly. I'll try to be more active (or else my rank is never gonna climb).
Omakase Shimasu
laugh.gif I can see [the makings of] a great writer in you~ And Warlords of Warcraft, eh? Everybody seems infatuated with that game, is it really that good? smile.gif

-^^- You make me blush, 'perpetually kind words'? I've already shown my darker side in another section of the forum, you know~ X3

Oooh, that's not silly at all! biggrin.gif I thought you were being drafted away by the sudden flood of newbies and didn't want to brave the forums anymore because of it. T__T I'm glad you've returned though! Although the Fanfiction section hasn't been added by bryantq yet... XD He's also really into WoW, you see.
Ghost
QUOTE(Omakase Shimasu @ Jan 14 2005, 05:33 PM)
laugh.gif I can see [the makings of] a great writer in you~ And Warlords of Warcraft, eh? Everybody seems infatuated with that game, is it really that good?

Haha where'd you get "Warlords" from? It's World of Warcraft and it owns my soul. Yes it is that good. Try it. Heheheh. Trrryyyyyyyy iiiit; joooiiiiin...uuuuuusssssss....

lol

The only reason you think you see a good writer in me is because I write essays instead of posts. Hahahahaha. Well anyway...back to WoW! Aaahahahahhaha!

(P.S. If anyone's curious, I play the Horde side of the Dragonblight server, by the name of Keis. Heh.)
Omakase Shimasu
biggrin.gif;; My bad, I was thinking about something else at the time (Warlords Battlecry ^^;;). I'm sleepy, I shouldn't even be answering you now~ Past 2 AM. @.@

Oooh, I just might. cool.gif It seems intrigueing(sp? @.@ can't write) enough. Horde side of the Dragonblide?

laugh.gif Essays are always great to read and write [on occasion]. I was talking about your use of fancy words and adjectives. Not to mention flawless grammar. ^^ If you can master it all as well as you can that has to say something about your skills, right? smile.gif
Ghost
It's not as impressive as you might think.
Spoiler: (Click here to Display)
And that's how I ended up marrying a squid.
alchemistgirl zero
I'm writing an Inu-Yasha fanfic about the future children of Kagome and Inu-Yasha. With a bittersweet twist of drama, teen angst, teen rebellion, and slight shonen ai...>=)
telepika
QUOTE
telepika's one of the greatest though.


Oh, Thanks Kase. laugh.gif
Ghost
I've come to respect Kase's opinion, so I'll have to check out telepika's fanfiction (if I ever decide that I have time in between graphic novels, manga, an eclectic assortment of literature, writing, and WoW).

Need to figure out how to get paid for all this crap I do.
bryantq
Alright guys, for all of you who've been waiting. I think ill open up the section soon, however i will require a fanfiction moderator to review and approve posts. These fanfictions will be posted via way of the forums, however will have full ability to post html within them, as well as be displayed on the main site through our forum sdk (you'll see)

We're also going to need to laydown a few guidelines and hope you guys will discuss that amongst yourself smile.gif
Omakase Shimasu
Our patience has finally paid off! tongue.gif Thank you so much, bryantq. smile.gif

Oh, fanfiction moderator. I wouldn't dare take on that job myself, but again I think Ghost and/or Tokage would be perfect for the job. wink.gif


@Ghost: -^^-
Ghost
One thing we should discuss is how to deal with unfinished work. Reading unfinished work can be annoying, but it's also a big part of the fanfiction community experience. Works in progress, or abandoned works which can be resumed can be fun to read and comment on. Even just begging the author to work faster can be fun, and it's a real inspiration to the authors themselves.

But you probably won't want to lend bandwidth to stories which remain perpetually unfinished or abandoned. So maybe there should be a maximum time limit on how long an abandoned story can be displayed. Or something like that.
Omakase Shimasu
Oh good one. mellow.gif I myself hate it when authors give up on their work halfway. (Yes, meaning I hate myself for never finishing anything multi-part -.-) Mediaminer.org has a limit to those stories as well. I think it's going to be deleted from the archives after two years not having been updated.

Also, about the rating. Can't exceed the R rating, right? Or is R already too much? ^^;;
alchemistgirl zero
I doubt NC-17 will be allowed here, but as for R, it probably depends on the ratio of sex to violence. Some things are rated R because they don't want younger people to see them; only a certain age group. You could do what Viz and the others do with their manga and anime and do the 'family', 'kid', 'teen', 'older teen', 'mature', and 'adult/18+' thing. happy.gif
I dunno; just a suggestion.
Ghost
Now, I really like reading mature fanfiction (and I'm not talking porn, which is, in my opinion, the opposite of "mature"), and am staunchly opposed to censorship so I'm not sure about the rating limit we should impose.
There's a difference between porn and a sex scene (or even multiple sex scenes). The guidelines should definitely say "no porn" because porn is boring and dumb. And if people really want to imagine their favorite characters having sex, they can do so without aid, or they can solicit some other source.

But I'm a big fan of brutal violence, and I've read many fanfictions which treated their (usually only one) sex scene with taste and maturity. So I'd hate to exclude such fanfics.

Maybe we could just segment the potentially "offensive" fics in a section with very large and noticeable disclaimers which would prevent our getting in trouble when mom finds out that little billy's been reading tasteful "smut" that has like, one explicit reference to sex.
Omakase Shimasu
Indeed. I know exactly what you mean about lemons and the like. Although I do enjoy the occasional lemon scene or even something hinted at it, but that's only in a multi-part fic where the plot revolves around something other than porn... NC-17 PWPs. Short, pointless and all about sex. Nope.

Hard R rated because of violence. I've never seen such a fic before, at least not rated because of it. I'd have liked to read such fics though. ohmy.gif

Oov, I hope it won't come to those entrances-hidden-within-the-disclaimers kinda thing you sometimes see with NC-17 sites. It might be efficient when dealing with people who don't read disclaimers, enter a site and then starts flaming, but for people who already know and are mature enough to handle the content... Or wasn't that what you meant? ^^;;;
alchemistgirl zero
Maybe you should have something like:

Hey moron! Before you read this fanfic, it has two people having sex, a guy getting his head lopped off and blood spilling everywhere, and other things that shall haunt your children in thier sleep! If you wanna go on, okay, but if you don't: turn back because thsi fic is rated 'R'.

...happy.gif just a thought
Ghost
Yeah that's pretty much what I'm saying, Zero. But let me describe what I was imagining in slightly more detail.

I'm imagining something with different categories for ease of navigation, like... 'Romance' 'Action' 'Drama' 'Comedy' and then have one that's like 'Mature' or some such synonym - and when it's clicked it takes you to an interim page that says "Adult Material beyond this point, continue at parental discretion if under 18." And a [Continue] button.

Now maybe this thing could stick you with a cookie so you don't have that extra step each time you want to visit the restricted section or something, I really don't know much about the programming angle.

OR, now that I'm thinking about it, you could skip the extra step by having a brief genre description under each category link. For the restricted section, the genre description would be the disclaimer and would be in red text.

The potential problem I see with this method, is that many fics can (and should) be categorized with multiple genres, and relegating things exclusively into the 'Mature' section, may make the fics more, instead of less, difficult.

Or maybe there's a simpler solution to it all, but that's all I can think of for now.
alchemistgirl zero
@Ghost: Hey! What's they used to do on fanfiction.net before they got flooded with all the NC-17 fics and put them on a different site. happy.gif;; There are some real pervets out there...

Mediaminer.org does the thing where it tells you if the fic is completed or not. Personally, I don't like seeing incomplete parts of fics. It enraged me. happy.gif
Ghost
The reason this site won't suffer the same fate as fanfiction.net is because this won't won't accept smut.

(If it's exceptionally written, compelling smut, then maybe it can be hosted but with an extra disclaimer on the fic itself. This would be in rare cases and would in no way represent the major content of the 'Mature' section, let alone the rest of the archive.)

Is this a good idea? I don't know site administration/traffic management stuff.
Celestial Shadow
<Merged "A General Writers' Section, I know this has been asked, but..." thread with the following 2 pages of posts here. 04/04/07 ~Tombow>

Well, I know similar things have been asked but why not have a General Writers' forum? People could post original fiction, poetry, and non-FMA stories there.
foolmetal alchemist
I always thought you were allowed to post non-FMA stories and poetry in the Fanworks section. I remember seeing a couple of Naruto fics and such in there. huh.gif
Celestial Shadow
Maybe but a totally different forum for that seems like it'd be good...
Elderberry
Hm....Celestial-san has a point. There are a few non-Hagaren fanfics posted occasionally, but the entire catagory is still in the Hagaren sub-forum...it *would* be pretty nice to create a seperate little area for fan/original works. happy.gif
Ailuro
Like a General "Works" section? So that it could be for artwork as well.

I can't think at the moment. What would that be called? huh.gif
foolmetal alchemist
I guess it could be something like "General Fanworks" or "Non-FMA Fanworks"...? huh.gif
xrninja
we have so many forums already....it takes quite awhile to scroll from the top of the forum homepage to the bottom, especially with the new video forum. x__x
Celestial Shadow
Maybe tongue.gif But it's only one more forum, and it's kind of needed...
Ronaldo Rodregez
I beg you for this forum. I'm surprised I didn't make this topic.
Celestial Shadow
See??? Others agree with me too!
bryantq
Actually, there is a plan to incorporate your new community blog ability for this in the future wink.gif hint hint wink wink ahhh it all comes together. smile.gif
foolmetal alchemist
That's an even better idea! This way we won't have extra down-scroll. laugh.gif
Celestial Shadow
QUOTE(bryantq @ Aug 14 2005, 03:48 PM)
Actually, there is a plan to incorporate your new community blog ability for this in the future wink.gif hint hint wink wink ahhh it all comes together. smile.gif
[snapback]251452[/snapback]


Heehee, awesome! You're best bryantq happy.gif
Ronaldo Rodregez
QUOTE(bryantq @ Aug 14 2005, 03:48 PM)
Actually, there is a plan to incorporate your new community blog ability for this in the future wink.gif hint hint wink wink ahhh it all comes together. smile.gif
[snapback]251452[/snapback]


What about people who'd rather have a topic?
Celestial Shadow
*Whispers* That's better than nothin' so deal with it. I'd rather have a topic too though.
Ronaldo Rodregez
QUOTE(Celestial Fangirl @ Aug 15 2005, 09:09 PM)
*Whispers* That's better than nothin' so deal with it. I'd rather have a topic too though.
[snapback]252836[/snapback]


They aren't dictators. They won't take away the idea if we argue. =P

I'm just saying, people would read a topic more than look at the Bogs. I didn't even notice it till a week ago.
Celestial Shadow
I totally agree but no one else likes us writer peoples...sad.gif
The RZA
your not that bad

READ MY FANFIC
foolmetal alchemist
I actually think the reason Bryant wants them in the Blog section is to give more popularity to the Blogs. If it has a fanfic section, it will most likely get more views. happy.gif
Celestial Shadow
*Never thought of that* Maybe...but meanwhile our writing may never get viewed.
foolmetal alchemist
I'll personally advertise for you. biggrin.gif
Celestial Shadow
tongue.gif I'll hold you to that then.
Art of Misconception
Fanfictions would be nice. It attracts a lot more readers' attention, that's for sure. And some people are spectacular writers.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.