Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Harry Potter And The Deathly Hallows
Fullmetal Alchemist Discussion Board > General Discussions > Open Talk
Pages: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6
the sellout
Yeah, I get what you're saying. Like I said, I still can't get over the death of certain black dog.

Neville is awesome, indeed. I cried when I read the part with his parents in the hospital, and cheered when he punched one of Malfoy's cronies (don't remember which), he definitely became much braver in the 5th book.

Hee, don't worry. Although, honestly, I'm not particularly fond of some of those ships, I've seen weirder ships out there (Snape/Sorting Hat story, lmao. o_O I kid you not!) and some just plain scary ones. It's the Harry Potter fandom, a place which can either bring you joy or nightmares.

Ah, you truly are a Potter nut. tongue.gif I am myself a Black/Lupin with a hint of Weasley nut. biggrin.gif

Characters:
-Ron Weasley
-Sirius Black
-Remus Lupin
-Severus Snape
-The entire Weasley family

Ship:
-Ron/Hermione
-Harry/Luna (not Ginny, please! She's the only Weasley I don't love)
-Remus/Sirius
-Severus/Remus
-Sirius/James (pre-Lily)
-Harry/Ron

That's it! I hope I didn't make you yawn! biggrin.gif
xrninja
i'm the only one of my friends who's excited (and caught up) for the sixth book! i have it pre-ordered and ready to arrive on my doorstep when it comes out. biggrin.gif since it's summer vacation and all, i re-read the other five books to refresh my memory. (i'd forgotten most of the 4th and almost all of the 5th, since i rushed through them right after they came out, and then had to give them to my sister to read.) as for theories, i've played around with the idea of Neville being the prince, but....i really don't know. i'm excited to see what JK Rowling will pull on us. biggrin.gif

as for favorite characters....
- Harry Potter
- all the Weasleys minus Percy and Ginny
- Sirius Black
- Remus Lupin
- Albus Dumbledore (i'm slightly....suspicious of him, though)
- Minerva McGonagall
- Professor Flitwick
- Neville Longbottom

disliked characters:
- all the Malfoys
- Dobby and Winky
- Peter Pettigrew
- Cedric Diggory
- Cho Chang (she's so annoying)
- Professor Umbridge (hem, hem)

i don't have any particular ships, but ones i ish-support:
- Ron/Hermione
- Remus/Sirius
- Harry/Hermione

...and i can't remember the others at the moment. have any of you been to veritaserum.com? it's pretty interesting.
WhiteMike
I can totally see Dumbledore pulling an Obi-Wan, which is a really stupid thing to do. I don't think that Rowling would degrade herself like that, using someone elses ideas to get even more money. Like I said, I don't think that she would do that.
I think that Filch is going to start screwing around with the schools inner workings more. Even though he is a squib, that doesn't mean he can't use his janitorial powers to follow orders from, I don't know, the Dark Lord. If Lord V. could convince Filch to commit even more hateful acts against the students, or give the Lord some inside information, no one would be the wiser.
[Spoiler Coming Up]
I don't think that Sirius is dead. I mean, he fell behind a bloody curtain! I guess that there are some pretty strange things that happen in the wizarding world, so anything can happen. I hope that he doesn't pull an Obi-Wan either. Oh God, enough of the Star Wars plots!
I'll think of some more ideas later, but I'm too tired, lol.
Omakase Shimasu
@the sellout: Neville's part in book 5 was very refreshing and sudden. In my eyes, in any case. A pleasant surprise.

About your ships, no yawning on my end. biggrin.gif I'm glad to see you're not too fond of Ginny either. Well, maybe not glad, but something along that line. I thought I was the only one out there who didn't like the girl all that much.


@xrninja: You're an HP too?? That surprised me... blink.gif Wow.

And what's this? Sirius & Remus? ohmy.gif

I don't have the book pre-ordered, but I'm certainly going to buy it once it's hitting the online stores, whether it's English or Dutch.

LINK!


@WhiteMike: At first I also doubted Sirius' death, but then I saw this article about Rowlings and how distraught she was at having killed off one of her characters (getting no sympathy from her husband whatsoever rolleyes.gif).

Ah well... everybody saw that one coming. It softened the blow somewhat.
Preypacer
Yeah, I too, lost some of the HP fever because of the long wait, but now I am starting to get into it again! happy.gif

For the HBP, I'm thinking of Blaise Zambini. I remember reading an interview with JKR that she will be bringing him up more in the upcoming books. I had noticed that there is always a hint of a new chara in the book before it, like Cedric for instance, before they get a larger part in the next book. Well, Blaise didn't get anything in 5, but with JKR noticing that Blaise's chara in a lot of fanfics and finally announced his gender, makes me think he could be a good candiate for the HBP.

As for fav charas happy.gif:
Draco Malfoy (or at the least fanon Draco tongue.gif )
Snape
Lupin
McGonagall
Sirius

fav ships:
Hermione/Draco
Snape/Lupin
I always like the near impossible one! *chuckle*
and Harry/Hermione which got me into the HP fandom

charas I don't like:
majority of the Weasleys (*shrugs* I don't know, never much cared for any of them)
Umbridge (most deffinatley! But I will say she was very well written for us to hate her like that! happy.gif )
Cho
House elves (can't stand the way they talk! mad.gif )
Pettigrew
Fudge
Omakase Shimasu
Heh, redundant question alert. Who on earth is Umbridge again? It seems my HP knowledge center has deserted my brains... _-_;;
Preypacer
*chuckle* Umbridge was the *ahem* "witch" that took over Dumbledore's place in the last book. The one that looked like a toad(?). Need to readed that one. She was the one who came up with the Inquisitorial Squad, banned Harry from Quiddtich, etc.

From the HP Lexicon:
Ministry witch, Special Assistant to the Minister of Magic.
Umbridge was assigned by Cornelius Fudge to the job of Defense Against the Dark Arts teacher when Dumbledore was having trouble finding someone to fill the post. Umbridge gradually took over, first becoming Hogwarts High Inquisitor and eventually becoming Headmistress. In the end, she was attacked by a herd of Centaurs and rescued by Dumbledore
Omakase Shimasu
Ah! Of course! She really was awful. I'd be surprised if she didn't end up in everybody's 'intense dislike' list.

Which reminds me, I didn't list mine. biggrin.gif But that's because I don't mind most characters for a change. The best I can come up with is Umbridge and Ginny. Of course, Ginny isn't as bad as Umbridge. Oh, maybe Fudge as well. X1

I think I should really start re-reading those books, that by the time I get my hands on the fifth book I actually have a sense of what's going on, and for what reason.
Preypacer
I was wondering if anyone is planning on going to a release parties? Or are you going to have your book shipped to you?

I'm hoping to attend one at one of the nearby stores. For the last DVD release they gave out little HP notebooks, HP party eyeglasses, and a bobblehead of Fluffy! *chukle* I'd say Fluffy was left over, but I still thought it was neat to get some free stuff! happy.gif
The RZA
i cant wait 4 it
Omakase Shimasu
I haven't heard of any parties/meetings held here in the Netherlands yet, but I chalk that up to the fact I haven't been trying to find out. biggrin.gif;; I'm not much of a party-person myself, but the goodies seem fun indeed.

No shipping for me. smile.gif I'm just going to wait until it hits the bookstores near here. I have to keep a close eyes on my bank-account. I'm horribly in-debt with my brother right now. -__-;;
xrninja
QUOTE(Omakase Shimasu @ Jun 30 2005, 11:26 AM)
@xrninja: You're an HP too?? That surprised me... blink.gif Wow.
[snapback]202826[/snapback]


the Harry Potter series has always been one of my favorites. tongue.gif i'm not a big fan of classics; i lean more towards the fantasy genre. HP's not the best written series, but what it lacks in syntax it certainly makes up for in plot. biggrin.gif

QUOTE(Omakase Shimasu @ Jun 30 2005, 11:26 AM)
And what's this? Sirius & Remus? ohmy.gif
[snapback]202826[/snapback]


shocked? i like shounen-ai when i feel it's appropriate. tongue.gif (like in all of Tenipuri, cough...) but FMA's one of those series where i don't feel it belongs and i'm adamantly against all FMA shounen-ai pairings.


as for release parties...i've always wanted to go to one, and this year was promising, since i'm old enough that my parents would let me out to go to one, and it's in the summertime, when i have absolutely nothing to do. but alas, my sister's friend pre-ordered book 6 for all of her friends, and since my sister and i share a set, my copy's already been accounted for. well, that's not really an "alas" but more of an "oh...drat." ah well, there's always book 7. tongue.gif maybe i'll just draw a lightning bolt on my forehead in eyeliner, so i can look festive as i snatch my copy off of my doorstep.

oh, i also have a question. i was browsing around veritaserum.com, and i'm curious: what version is this cover for? is it actually a real cover?
IPB Image


(by the way, i'm going to change the number of days left until the release accordingly, just because i'm a big dork like that. so it's 12 days now.)
Le Monkey
I belive that that is the Classic AMERICAN cover.
In the uk we have 2 different covers.
Classic and
IPB Image
Adult versions
IPB Image
Azura Elric
I'm rather curious why the adult cover is on potion making. Out of all the covers I've seen, that one stands out differently from the others. (No Harry or Dumbledore)
«°~Envy™~°»
what's with all this Harry Cotter crud :| no offense but nvm ignore me lol I get the same responses from people that don't like star trek lol
Le Monkey
QUOTE(Azura Elric @ Jul 4 2005, 06:56 AM)
I'm rather curious why the adult cover is on potion making. Out of all the covers I've seen, that one stands out differently from the others. (No Harry or Dumbledore)
[snapback]205551[/snapback]



In the uk bloomberg have releaced the books with an adult//child covers...

Eg. The last book had a bronze statue of a Phenix on it.. It is just different covers..
WhiteMike
QUOTE(«°~Envy™~°» @ Jul 4 2005, 08:58 AM)
what's with all this Harry Cotter crud :| no offense but nvm ignore me lol I get the same responses from people that don't like star trek lol
[snapback]205553[/snapback]


Well, the star trek comment is totally understandable...
xrninja
QUOTE(le monkey @ Jul 4 2005, 09:06 AM)
QUOTE(Azura Elric @ Jul 4 2005, 06:56 AM)
I'm rather curious why the adult cover is on potion making. Out of all the covers I've seen, that one stands out differently from the others. (No Harry or Dumbledore)
[snapback]205551[/snapback]



In the uk bloomberg have releaced the books with an adult//child covers...

Eg. The last book had a bronze statue of a Phenix on it.. It is just different covers..
[snapback]205629[/snapback]


yeah, i was looking at some of the international covers online last night, and i noticed that all of the UK adult versions have something on the cover that directly relates to the title. i.e., the first book had a picture of the Philosopher's Stone, the second had a door to the Chamber of Secrets, the third had a picture of Azkaban, the fourth had the Goblet of Fire, and the fifth had a phoenix. but book 6 seems to break that trend, with a potions book instead of, well, the Half-Blood Prince. i dunno, there's a lot of speculation on the significance of the author, and maybe he's the new Potions master, if something happened to Snape or if Snape finally got the Defense Against the Dark Arts position...
WhiteMike
QUOTE(le monkey @ Jul 4 2005, 07:36 AM)
I belive that that is the Classic AMERICAN cover.
In the uk we have 2 different covers.
Classic and
IPB Image
Adult versions
IPB Image
[snapback]205518[/snapback]


I still don't understand why they need an adult version of the book, I guess it's just to make more money.
Le Monkey
QUOTE(xrninja @ Jul 4 2005, 04:33 PM)
QUOTE(le monkey @ Jul 4 2005, 09:06 AM)
QUOTE(Azura Elric @ Jul 4 2005, 06:56 AM)
I'm rather curious why the adult cover is on potion making. Out of all the covers I've seen, that one stands out differently from the others. (No Harry or Dumbledore)
[snapback]205551[/snapback]



In the uk bloomberg have releaced the books with an adult//child covers...

Eg. The last book had a bronze statue of a Phenix on it.. It is just different covers..
[snapback]205629[/snapback]


yeah, i was looking at some of the international covers online last night, and i noticed that all of the UK adult versions have something on the cover that directly relates to the title. i.e., the first book had a picture of the Philosopher's Stone, the second had a door to the Chamber of Secrets, the third had a picture of Azkaban, the fourth had the Goblet of Fire, and the fifth had a phoenix. but book 6 seems to break that trend, with a potions book instead of, well, the Half-Blood Prince. i dunno, there's a lot of speculation on the significance of the author, and maybe he's the new Potions master, if something happened to Snape or if Snape finally got the Defense Against the Dark Arts position...
[snapback]205816[/snapback]



I was wondering the same thing too..
Well nevermind...

QUOTE(WhiteMike @ Jul 4 2005, 05:13 PM)
QUOTE(le monkey @ Jul 4 2005, 07:36 AM)
I belive that that is the Classic AMERICAN cover.
In the uk we have 2 different covers.
Classic and
IPB Image
Adult versions
IPB Image
[snapback]205518[/snapback]


I still don't understand why they need an adult version of the book, I guess it's just to make more money.
[snapback]205844[/snapback]



Probably.. and it is valued at a higher price.. Eg. Collectors edditon..
DonnaDelDrago
QUOTE(WhiteMike @ Jul 5 2005, 02:13 AM)
I still don't understand why they need an adult version of the book, I guess it's just to make more money.
[snapback]205844[/snapback]



They do this for people like me: I don't buy books if I dislike the cover. And The cover of the classic version is not that good...

But the german version has strange covers anyway...
Le Monkey
Dose it?
Maybe everyone should post up pictures of the covers from their contry!
Automne
Wow, you're all so lucky! I have to wait until september for HBP release! I think the french covers are totally awful and childish! Here is the OTP cover:
Luckyalchemy27
The one that xrninja posted is the "deluxe" version in the U.S.

*sniffleses* I still am not quite over Sirius. He was my second favorite character. Second only to Lupin. *is wearing an "I heart Lupin" t-shirt*
Spark Alchemist
aww i feel your pain Lucky i too was devistated...lol...i cried i must admit just like i cried when Cedric died... sad.gif im so glad to see that there are hp fans on here though especially ones that are a bit older too...i thought i was so alone...lol...im ready for the next book and will be in line at midnight getting my reserved copy at b&n...lol
Luckyalchemy27
I didn't cry when Cedric died, but I did for Sirius.

Hey, has anyone seen Victor Krum's actor for the next movie? He's really hot. ^^
Celestial Shadow
sleep.gif; Leave it to anime fans to make Harry Potter a shounen-ai.
Luckyalchemy27
QUOTE
Leave it to anime fans to make Harry Potter a shounen-ai.


That's what we're here for. laugh.gif
Le Monkey
That frence cover is ammusingly BAD!
Automne
Lol! And you didn't see the others le monkey!
Luckyalchemy27
I just got a call from a newspaper reporter. He interviewed me about the Harry Potter books. I is so excited!! laugh.gif
fullmetalalchemistchick
harry potte is ok i just like the movies there awesome
WhiteMike
QUOTE(fullmetalalchemistchick @ Jul 6 2005, 06:16 PM)
harry potte is ok i just like the movies there awesome
[snapback]207038[/snapback]


The books are way better then the movies, read them all to fully understand all the background plots!
fullmetalalchemistchick
oh ok ummmm.... i dont like the books i'm reading a series already i read the fisrt two and they didn't intereste me so i didn't read any more
xrninja
i don't really like Daniel Radcliffe as Harry, so the movies aren't as appealing to me (plus, this sounds really stupid, but it bothers me how off-center Harry's scar is in the movie). that won't stop me from watching all of them, but...has anyone else seen the trailer for the fourth movie? the effects look really cool, but why do Harry and Ron both have so much hair? blink.gif
WhiteMike
QUOTE(xrninja @ Jul 6 2005, 07:20 PM)
i don't really like Daniel Radcliffe as Harry, so the movies aren't as appealing to me (plus, this sounds really stupid, but it bothers me how off-center Harry's scar is in the movie). that won't stop me from watching all of them, but...has anyone else seen the trailer for the fourth movie? the effects look really cool, but why do Harry and Ron both have so much hair? blink.gif
[snapback]207071[/snapback]


lol, that made me laugh too. One thing in the trailer that I hope they correct is with the first challenge, with the hungarian horntail, where in the book Harry doesn't even aimlessly jump around the rocks to get the egg, he summons his Firebolt and flies around. In the trailer, they have him jumping around, it kinda made me mad, I hate when they change the story!
Luckyalchemy27
I heart the dude who plays Krum. He ish hawt. XD
fullmetalalchemistchick
eh heh heh who happy.gif"
Luckyalchemy27
IPB Image

I think he's cute. ^^
fullmetalalchemistchick
really i'm not feeling it with that guy
Luckyalchemy27
Good. *hugs Viktor protectively* He ish mine.
Le Monkey
Oh Ghod....
Yet another Fangirl bace developing here now...
@Lucky: you know Hermionie Has him dont you?
tongue.gif
WhiteMike
QUOTE(Luckyalchemy27 @ Jul 6 2005, 11:45 PM)
IPB Image

I think he's cute. ^^
[snapback]207209[/snapback]


Thats the guy who plays Krum? Well, all I can say is that he better have a damn good accent.
Luckyalchemy27
QUOTE
@Lucky: you know Hermionie Has him dont you?


I kidnapped him. tongue.gif
fullmetalalchemistchick
*sarcastic look* oh so sad i was kidding i wanted him *thinks to self: as if*
Le Monkey
18 hours and counting! happy.gif
WhiteMike
lol, I'm getting it at Zellers tomorrow for $14CAN. I'm splitting the cost with my sister so I will only have to pay $7CAN. $7 for a book that is normally $41 ish is not bad at all...
Le Monkey
6hours and counting..
Im getting it +the bonus book for free!
the sellout
Ok, just finished the book.


A LOT OF SPOILERS AHEAD!!!














Cried. And cried. I knew Dumbledore was going to die, but I'm still surprised about the person who killed him. I was disappointed that Snape turned. I always liked that he was a bad-good guy. I almost feel betrayed because I trusted him, just like Dumbledore did.

When Dumbledore showed up in the portrait in the headmaster's study? I WEPT.

What I didn't like? Ginny Weasley, she's the freaking epitome of a Mary Sue. EVERYONE loves her, she's really good at quidditch, and of course Harry now LOVES her. So disappointed.. I really expected better from JKR.

And well.. might I just add that Tonks is going to become Harry Potter's Relena? I can see it already. Beh, I like Tonks a lot, but I feel that pairing her up with Lupin was, well, unecessary. It just seems that JKR just wanted every character to be with someone. And, I must say, the whole romantic part of the story felt like reading a fan fiction, seriously. Oh, well.

Overall, I liked it. The interection between Harry and Dumbledore was perfect, which is what made the book for me. There's so much I want to say but that I can't recall right now, so I'll write more later.
Avid Guest
Yay, I'm not the only one who's finished! [spoiler] I agree with you, sellout, this book really made me want to curl up in a corner and cry sad.gif . I was just starting to trust Snape too! I really hope Harry kills him.

I can't say that I'm suprised that Harry and Ginny got together, I was kind of expecting it. And now that you mention it, she is a bit Mary Sueish. What suprised me was how Ron and Hermione didn't become a "couple", so to speak. I always assumed they'd get together before Harry and anyone. It definately felt as though I was reading a fanfction romance at certain points; Tonks being in love with Lupin was surprising and almost a little random. Exactly how large is the age difference between them anyways?

Finding out that Snape is the half-blood prince wasn't all that suprising; How many other potions masters do we know? Damn, I hope he dies mad.gif [/spoiler]

I'm really looking forward to the next book. Things are finally gonna start getting somewhere! Now that we have the answers to questions we've been waiting for since the first book, and everythings coming to a head, the climax is definately gonna be interesting.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.