Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Homosexual Couples: Do You Have Favorite Same-sex FMA Parings? Which One?
Fullmetal Alchemist Discussion Board > Fullmetal Alchemist Discussions > FMA Character Discussions
Pages: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17
the sellout
QUOTE
First off, welcome to the FMA fandom! You're here just in time for the movie excitement et al.


Thanks! biggrin.gif And indeed, I couldn't have chosen a better time to join the fandom.

HavocRoy, RoyHavoc.. either way is fine with me! Hee. biggrin.gif Too bad that I'm scared to venture into fan fiction world (finding good stories is as hard as finding an honest politician) because I would really like to read some good HavocRoy stories. Same with HughesRoy. See, the problem is that I don't like reading smut. I mean, I don't mind a nicely done sex scene every now and then, but entirely smut stories don't really appeal to me. And it seems that about 99% of the stories out there are only smut.

I did come across a really good story, my first FMA fan fiction story, just yesterday. It was actually written by you, Toby-Chan. I believe the title was Corset Strings for Gun Clips. I don’t have a LJ account, so I wasn’t able to comment, but it was really such stunning story. You did a splendid job!
NightMistress
QUOTE(the sellout @ Jun 20 2005, 07:39 PM)
QUOTE
First off, welcome to the FMA fandom! You're here just in time for the movie excitement et al.


Thanks! biggrin.gif And indeed, I couldn't have chosen a better time to join the fandom.

HavocRoy, RoyHavoc.. either way is fine with me! Hee. biggrin.gif Too bad that I'm scared to venture into fan fiction world (finding good stories is as hard as finding an honest politician) because I would really like to read some good HavocRoy stories. Same with HughesRoy. See, the problem is that I don't like reading smut. I mean, I don't mind a nicely done sex scene every now and then, but entirely smut stories don't really appeal to me. And it seems that about 99% of the stories out there are only smut.

I did come across a really good story, my first FMA fan fiction story, just yesterday. It was actually written by you, Toby-Chan. I believe the title was Corset Strings for Gun Clips. I don’t have a LJ account, so I wasn’t able to comment, but it was really such stunning story. You did a splendid job!
[snapback]196134[/snapback]



I like tastefully done smut. I have read a few very nice Royai ones (most of their stories aren't smut though).

Aside from HughesRoy, I don't keep up with the yaoi stories really (but am awating some RussellEd) so I can't really determine the smuttiness.

The HughesRoy community gets a nice amount of stories in there. Not all of them are smut either.

http://www.livejournal.com/community/hughesxroy/

I just recently read an extremely sweet HughesRoy fic on LJ:
http://www.livejournal.com/community/fic_o...290.html#cutid1

Also, a great LJ fanart person is Ponderosa121:
http://ponderosa121.livejournal.com/335338.html
http://www.livejournal.com/users/ponderosa121/386751.html
This is a pretty steamy one but http://www.livejournal.com/users/ponderosa121/360401.html
she just recently made a royai one so I'll show you that one since I know you like that pairing:
http://www.livejournal.com/users/ponderosa...820.html#cutid1

We've got a lot of fanfic here at the board to check out as well. A lot of it is probably exported to LJ.
Chibi Reina
>.< *walks up like a zombie* HughesxRoy smut..... heehee

There's this really great Royai smut I read called 'Toy Soldiers' and takes place after the funeral on episode 25. It was really angsty, though, but I still liked it... (I love angst)
Mustang no Miko
Be in awe and fear at my unoriginal patheticness! I am... a Roy x Ed fan! Why? Well, they are my favourite characters... Other than that... It's like the Heero and Duo pairing from Gundam Wing... There aren't really any hints to it... It's just there and people seem to like it. Perhaps it's because they look hot together rolleyes.gif .
NightMistress
QUOTE(Chibi Reina @ Jun 20 2005, 11:52 PM)
>.< *walks up like a zombie* HughesxRoy smut..... heehee

There's this really great Royai smut I read called 'Toy Soldiers' and takes place after the funeral on episode 25. It was really angsty, though, but I still liked it... (I love angst)
[snapback]196365[/snapback]



Lady_Sinstra from LJ wrote that. I love her writing! She's written other REALLY great Royai stuff (smut and non) along with HavocRoy and RoyHavocRiza. I wouldn't hold my breath for any RoyEd by her though. She's not into that pairing much.
Toby-Chan
Super random thought:

Izumi x Sloth.

Mommashipping! laugh.gif
Chibi Reina
How about Fury x Scar???
NightMistress
How about HavocScar? They're both quite tall.
Chibi Reina
Hehe, BredaxBarry....
Toby-Chan
QUOTE(Mustang no Miko @ Jun 20 2005, 08:58 PM)
It's like the Heero and Duo pairing from Gundam Wing... There aren't really any hints to it... It's just there and people seem to like it. Perhaps it's because they look hot together rolleyes.gif .
[snapback]196369[/snapback]



Dude, everyone likes Heero x Duo. It's, like, a rule. Heck, I like Heero x Duo, and I've never even seen Gundam Wing! (Okay... not really...)
Chibi Reina
I didn't even know what yaoi even was back when I watched Gundam Wing! >_< I just watched it for the cute guys and didn't care about anything else at the time...
AlchemistCookie
QUOTE(Omakase Shimasu @ Aug 24 2004, 02:01 AM)
QUOTE(BlueRakuen @ Aug 23 2004, 03:34 PM)
hum... Scar just hates everyone... ScarxScar is the only thing I can come up with
self-love XD

Lolol~

Ah, Scar and his brother? Kinda love-hate thing going on there. XD

Well, there was some shonen-ai between him and Al in one of the eps... o__O
[snapback]9278[/snapback]

I love that bit happy.gif I voted Roy x Ed, but I'm also an Al x Ed fan. Too bad I can't vote twice.
Omakase Shimasu
Wow, this thing's still alive and kicking. biggrin.gif Grand!

I'm glad to see all the new faces popping up in here, much to the dismay of some members on these boards, I can tell. Ah well, can't win 'em all.

About the Russell x Ed pairing, my apologies. When I made this poll, I wasn't really into the pairing so I settled them into the [other] option with the rest. I now really regret that decision. I adore that pairing even. (Same goes for Kimblee/Archer, darnit) Alas...
Airtos
lol shounen-ai X3


my fav pairrings:

[sit down - I like the strange ones..............don´t kill me >.<]


GreedxKimbley
GreedxEnvy [<--- read already some FF - they aren´t that bad todether XP]
ScarxEd [same here - read already - isn´t that bad V.V]

yeah - and all the others ya put in the poll to but.....
.....
I can´t stand EnvyxEd - sry >.<
Squirrel of Doom
I said other because I like HavocxEd.
Satsuka
I chose RizaxWinry. biggrin.gif
GS4Life
The only yaoi couples I would stick with would be cannon. The only Yuri couples I really like are not from FMA.They are Lyn x Florina (Fire Emblem 7)and Sango x Kagome (I have my reason please don't bury me alive,from Inuyasha). So um yeah why am I here? unsure.gif
eliss_music
HavokxEd? *blink*
Okay....
Hm, Who'd I like to see....
(My opinions have changed quit a bit the more into the story I go biggrin.gif )
Havok and human Al maybe.....
RizaxLust came to mind...It would fail horrably but still...
Ed and Al Heinric (please tell me if keep writing his last anme wrong!)
HavokxFuery! WinryxIzumi (I'm just typing names now)
RoyxArmstrong! hey wait...thats not too bad....
Havok and Envy! there we go!
RosexLyra (Before, Not after Lyra.)

ok, my name speaul is done!
peace and love and stuff!
The pretty alchemist
Envyxeveryone... He's the only FMA male character who can fall in love/sleep with a man rolleyes.gif Roy loves women, Ed loves Winry... biggrin.gif
Hm, I have just imagined GluttonyxArmstrong couple... blink.gif
Automne
QUOTE(The pretty alchemist Posted Today @ 03:31 AM)
Ed loves Winry...


HAHA! But we still don't know if Ed loves Winry! biggrin.gif There's still no clue! tongue.gif

I like a new pairing: Movie!AlXWrath! laugh.gif but I still don't like it as much as EnvyXEd! biggrin.gif
Toby-Chan
QUOTE(SinLuxuria @ Aug 20 2005, 04:56 AM)
I like a new pairing: Movie!AlXWrath! laugh.gif 
[snapback]256558[/snapback]



Ooh! I haven't seen the movie yet, so I'm not sure about that, but it's still cool to see someone fangirling over my bizzaro obsession. tongue.gif
Satsuka
QUOTE(eliss_music @ Aug 19 2005, 03:23 PM)
HavokxEd? *blink*
Okay....
Hm, Who'd I like to see....
(My opinions have changed quit a bit the more into the story I go biggrin.gif )
Havok and human Al maybe.....
RizaxLust came to mind...It would fail horrably but still...
Ed and Al Heinric (please tell me if keep writing his last anme wrong!)
HavokxFuery! WinryxIzumi (I'm just typing names now)
RoyxArmstrong! hey wait...thats not too bad....
Havok and Envy! there we go!
RosexLyra (Before, Not after Lyra.)

ok, my name speaul is done!
peace and love and stuff!
[snapback]256032[/snapback]


RizaxLust=hotness ^ ^
Toby-Chan
WinryxIzumi? Even for me, that's a huge WTFFFFFFF...?
Envy's lil' miniskirt
How about, IzumixLust.
Toby-Chan
QUOTE(Envy's lil' miniskirt @ Aug 20 2005, 09:47 AM)
How about, IzumixLust.
[snapback]256656[/snapback]



I dunno. I think IzumixSloth would make more sense.
Envy's lil' miniskirt
Sloth?

Sloth is not worthy of Izumi-sensi! tongue.gif
Random Person
I voted for hughesxroy. Sloth and Izumi? hmm. Intreasting. *starts pondering*
Automne
Very interesting! Wrath would have his two mommies reunited! That would be such a cute family! biggrin.gif

I saw a WinryXPSiren fic once!... O_o
Toby-Chan
QUOTE(SinLuxuria @ Aug 20 2005, 10:28 AM)
Very interesting! Wrath would have his two mommies reunited! That would be such a cute family! biggrin.gif
[snapback]256726[/snapback]



laugh.gif There NEEDS to be a book about that, called "Wrath Has two Mommies."

Only problem is; where does poor Sig fit in? sad.gif


QUOTE
I saw a WinryXPSiren fic once!... O_o


Yeah... Psiren is always used as the random slut of fanfiction, unfortunately. sleep.gif

EDIT:

Omigosh. The more I think about it, the more Winry/Rose reminds me of Utena/Anthy. Which is a good thing. biggrin.gif There are just so many parallels, it's not funny.
Ed_Elric_Fan
I once saw a Barry/Ed fic, and to my surprise I didn't hate it. Not on my favorite lists, but still....
Automne
QUOTE(Toby-Chan Posted Yesterday @ 11:00 AM)
Omigosh. The more I think about it, the more Winry/Rose reminds me of Utena/Anthy. Which is a good thing.  There are just so many parallels, it's not funny.


Winry/Rose? Cute! biggrin.gif Winry will certainly be a good 'Prince' for Rose since she's certainly very protective! biggrin.gif And Ed will be like Akio...No, Ed is certainly not as cruel as him... mellow.gif

QUOTE(Ed_Elric_Fan Posted Yesterday @ 08:19 PM)
I once saw a Barry/Ed fic, and to my surprise I didn't hate it. Not on my favorite lists, but still....


laugh.gif Wow, Barry/Ed! Not bad! Though I think Barry/Al is better! Was it Human!Barry or Armor!Barry in the fic?
Toby-Chan
QUOTE(SinLuxuria @ Aug 21 2005, 04:39 AM)
QUOTE(Toby-Chan Posted Yesterday @ 11:00 AM)
Omigosh. The more I think about it, the more Winry/Rose reminds me of Utena/Anthy. Which is a good thing.  There are just so many parallels, it's not funny.


Winry/Rose? Cute! biggrin.gif Winry will certainly be a good 'Prince' for Rose since she's certainly very protective! biggrin.gif And Ed will be like Akio...No, Ed is certainly not as cruel as him... mellow.gif
[snapback]257626[/snapback]



Nononono! Ed is more like... the wakaba. (Actually, Winry seems like more of a wakaba... but we're making her the prince for the sake of yuri argument.

Dante is obviously the Akio here. I can't believe you wouldn't notice that.
Automne
QUOTE(Toby-Chan Posted Yesterday @ 09:58 AM)
Nononono! Ed is more like... the wakaba. (Actually, Winry seems like more of a wakaba... but we're making her the prince for the sake of yuri argument.

Dante is obviously the Akio here. I can't believe you wouldn't notice that.


Ooh yes! Dante would be perfect for Akio! I think she would do a good Shiori Takatsuki too! biggrin.gif But who would be Juri? I always thought Juri and Riza (or even Izumi) were a lot alike! Dante/Izumi? Dante/Riza? (even if they don't meet in the serie!) Roy as a Ruka?...Here it's strange but not bad! laugh.gif But where to put poor Scieska?
Toby-Chan
There don't have to be perfect parallels.

But Ed would be sort of like Miki in this case, since he's hinted at shyly crushing on both Rose and Winry. Of course, Ed's also struck my mind as being almost like the parallel of Winry's prince; a childhood love/inspiration, whom she misses while he's off on his long journey, but instead of playing the part of meek little mistress waiting for him, she takes on a strong role herself to try and help people.

[spoiler]only difference is that Ed's not a part evil twin of Dante.[/spoiler]

Alphonse is definitely the Wakaba. laugh.gif I can see it now.

Fun fact; did you know that Juri and Gracia have the same Seiyuu? (She played lots of major roles; Misato from Evangelion, Mireille from Noir, Usagi from Sailor moon, Excel From Excel Saga, etc. Whatta range, huh?)

This conversation has inspired me to consider crossover pairs; Winry and Wakaba. Theirs would be heart-attack-inducing enthusiastic love. *_* They'd be dangerous together.
Ed_Elric_Fan
It was armor Barry, hehe
Lyndsie_Elric
Meh... I chose other... I would go with RoyxHavoc! ^^ But (rarely) I like EdxRoy... >.>
NightMistress
I bought a HughesRoy doujinshi this weekend at Otakon. It also gave me a nice suprise of some HavocRoy. I bought this HughesRoy holiday card too. I will have scans up soon. If someone would be a kind heart to translate the doujinshi for me, I'd be ever so grateful!
Toby-Chan
QUOTE(NightMistress @ Aug 22 2005, 11:18 AM)
I bought a HughesRoy doujinshi this weekend at Otakon.  It also gave me a nice suprise of some HavocRoy.  I bought this HughesRoy holiday card too.  I will have scans up soon. If someone would be a kind heart to translate the doujinshi for me, I'd be ever so grateful!
[snapback]257982[/snapback]



That didn't happen to be 'Cigarettes' did it?
NightMistress
It's called Chronic Sorrow Vol. 3
Automne
QUOTE(Toby-Chan Posted Today @ 10:21 AM)
This conversation has inspired me to consider crossover pairs; Winry and Wakaba. Theirs would be heart-attack-inducing enthusiastic love. *_* They'd be dangerous together.


Oh Yeah! A great and dangerous duo! laugh.gif The Onion Princess and the Automail Master! laugh.gif
Me too, I sometimes consider crossover pairings! Lastly, I considered JuriXEnvy to be an interesting pairing! Crazy, isn't it?! laugh.gif But since we're in a yaoi/yuri thread, I'll go with Juri and Riza! These two would be a 'femmes fatales' pairing! biggrin.gif

Gracia and Juri have the same seiyu? I was almost sure Juri and Riza's voices were the same! That's maybe why I thought they were so much alike! I'll listen to Gracia's voice closely now!
NightMistress
Okay guys, I managed to scan my hughesroy card. [attachmentid=2047]

I need to free up some space, but once I do that I can scan the rest of the doujinshi (just the cover is done).[attachmentid=2048]
Toby-Chan
Curse you, Lux! You've forced my nutty brain into needing to draw a EnvyxJuri fan art! I was up till midnight doodling last night! (Okay, I was doodling other stuff too... and it was just 11:30 to midnight... but STILL!)

I'm pretty happy with how the doodle turned out; I may trace and ink/color it. I'm proud because usually I'm not very good with delicate, sensual poses, and well, you know the rule; it can't be an Utena character unless they're posing sensually. tongue.gif ('Cept chu-chu and Wakaba. They just need to be cute) I made Envy look almost like a gentleman. blink.gif

But that's not on topic. On topic...

I LOVE RUSSEL x EDWARD!!!!111one1o1!11!number!!
eliss_music
Ok, wow, uh
I have read most of Utena sieres and
You guys totly lost me yet I completely understood.
Cross overs? Hm, let's see...
*stares blankly at screen*
None that sound cool except (can't remember who's who)
Friuts Basket (Heehee, friut) and Ed.

Weirdest Yaio I've ever read: YugixYugioh.
Ever sence then, It's burned in my brain.
It got stuck there several days ago and I now
have a strang craving to watch Yugioh, I show I can't stand.
YugiohxEd? Maybe....I'm drawing a blank here!
fullmetal_4eva
I don't really like any same sex couples
Envy's lil' miniskirt
QUOTE(Toby-Chan @ Aug 23 2005, 08:34 AM)
Curse you, Lux!  You've forced my nutty brain into needing to draw a EnvyxJuri fan art!  I was up till midnight doodling last night!  (Okay, I was doodling other stuff too... and it was just 11:30 to midnight... but STILL!)

I'm pretty happy with how the doodle turned out; I may trace and ink/color it.  I'm proud because usually I'm not very good with delicate, sensual poses, and well, you know the rule; it can't be an Utena character unless they're posing sensually.  tongue.gif  ('Cept chu-chu and Wakaba. They just need to be cute)  I made Envy look almost like a gentleman.  blink.gif 
[snapback]259157[/snapback]



Well, are you going to share? ohmy.gif
Random Person
Crap, YukiXAl just keeps popping into my mind. O.o;
Toby-Chan
QUOTE(Envy's lil' miniskirt @ Aug 23 2005, 08:08 PM)
Well, are you going to share?  ohmy.gif
[snapback]259878[/snapback]



If I can get it scanned tomorrow, yeah.
What thread should I put it under, though?

QUOTE(Random Person @ Aug 23 2005, 08:34 PM)
Crap, YukiXAl just keeps popping into my mind. O.o;
[snapback]259897[/snapback]



Eeeh? Wouldn't KyouxAl make more sense? I mean, what with Al's cat-love and all.
Then again, Yuki's mouse version has a cuteness that more or less matches chibi armor Al.

QUOTE(eliss_music @ Aug 23 2005, 03:44 PM)
Weirdest Yaio I've ever read: YugixYugioh.
Ever sence then, It's burned in my brain.
[snapback]259477[/snapback]



laugh.gif I remember my friends were (And still are) totally into Yuugi-oh yaoi when they first got me interested. Yuugi x Yami no yuugi/ Hitori no yuugi/ dark... whatever... OTHER Yuugi, struck me as wierd at first, and after lots of prodding I grew to love it like every other fluff-adoring fangirl. When you remember the fact that they really are two different people, it's not so... squicky.

Come to think of it, I haven't revisited anything of the Yuugioh fandom lately. I wonder if it's all as wonderfully cliche'd and horrible as always. laugh.gif RyouxBakura will always be the same old abusive angstiness, and thats why we love it. tongue.gif
Automne
QUOTE(Toby-Chan Posted Yesterday @ 09:34 AM)
I LOVE RUSSEL x EDWARD!!!!111one1o1!11!number!!


hum, RussXEd!!! I love it! This pairing just needs more love! I think there's a good RusselXEd fic on ff.net but it's RoyXEd too! I don't like it when Roy is involved because the author wants Ed to have a tie between Roy and another boy! (There's way too much in EnvyXEd fanfics! sad.gif )

Another pairing I like since a while (because of the fic Cut Me Off by WingedBonnie!) EnvyXKimblee! tongue.gif

Can't wait to see your drawing, Toby! (Yeah I made someone draw a Eny/Juri! laugh.gif )

QUOTE(eliss_music Posted Yesterday @ 03:44 PM)
Weirdest Yaio I've ever read: YugixYugioh.
Ever sence then, It's burned in my brain.
It got stuck there several days ago and I now
have a strang craving to watch Yugioh, I show I can't stand.
YugiohxEd? Maybe....I'm drawing a blank here!


YugiXYami! Weird??!!! It was one of my fav pairing before and almost canon for me! laugh.gif (If only Anzu/Tea were not in the way! dry.gif )
YugiohXEd? I prefer YugiXEd because when I think of it, Ed will certainly be happy because he'll have someone smaller than him! laugh.gif YugiXAl is not bad too!

QUOTE(Toby-Chan Posted Yesterday @ 09:39 PM)
Come to think of it, I haven't revisited anything of the Yuugioh fandom lately. I wonder if it's all as wonderfully cliche'd and horrible as always.  RyouxBakura will always be the same old abusive angstiness, and thats why we love it.


Ah, that famous abusive pairing! I don't know why I like to se Ryou suffer like this! laugh.gif He's so sweet!
Toby-Chan
QUOTE(SinLuxuria @ Aug 24 2005, 01:47 AM)
QUOTE(Toby-Chan Posted Yesterday @ 09:34 AM)
I LOVE RUSSEL x EDWARD!!!!111one1o1!11!number!!


hum, RussXEd!!! I love it! This pairing just needs more love! I think there's a good RusselXEd fic on ff.net but it's RoyXEd too! I don't like it when Roy is involved because the author wants Ed to have a tie between Roy and another boy! (There's way too much in EnvyXEd fanfics! sad.gif )


Correction: There's way too many terrible EnvyxEd fanfics.

I don't know why, since I don't even like the pairing, but I keep on hoping that somebody might make some decent EdxEnvy. I'm weird. (Maybe I just got seduced by FelisDeityus's wonderfulfulness, darn her!)


QUOTE
YugiXYami! Weird??!!! It was one of my fav pairing before and almost canon for me! laugh.gif (If only Anzu/Tea were not in the way! dry.gif )
YugiohXEd? I prefer YugiXEd because when I think of it, Ed will certainly be happy because he'll have someone smaller than him! laugh.gif YugiXAl is not bad too!


Oy! Lay off Anzu. She rules!

... AnzuxMai? biggrin.gif?

But seriously, yeah. YamixYuugi was definitely loveable for a while. I even got my little sister into it. (She was watching the show on WB and during the opening song she squealed, and was like, "Oooh, look! It looks like they're holding hands!")


QUOTE
Ah, that famous abusive pairing! I don't know why I like to se Ryou suffer like this! laugh.gif He's so sweet!


Because Ryou-chan is just a natural fangirl's punching bag. I like angsty fics when he shakes his dependence and gets his revenge. (I think this kind of thing is the reason I became such an angst junky. >.>)
eliss_music
Russle and Ed would fight constantly.
R "Who was that?"
E "No one."
R "Was that a girl?"
E " My machanic, why?"
*they tumble a bit*
R "Why are you cheating on me!"
E "Because your useless!"
(I'm so random today, I kinda lost this one.)

Yugioh and Ed would go something like this:
Y " Where is my dinner?"
E "I don't cook."
Y "Fix me my dinner!"
E "Go play cards!"
Y *yells name of some card that magicly pops up*
E *uses alchmey to make is look like a poster of Songo.*
Yugioh would be shocked.

Yugi and Ed? hm, interesting, let's see:
E "Honey, I'm home."
Y "Here's dinner" *sets plate of food infront of him*
E "You been talking to yoursefl again?"
Y "No, why?"
E "You talk in your sleep."
Y "No I don't!" *runs off crying*

Yup, that works! Hey, any one know where I can find friuts basket manga online, just to read.
I haven't read them in so long I've forgottin who's who.
Loves! [Please forgive my random ness, I can't help it.]

Also, You don't have to like samesex couples (real or not) but don't be mad at them for it is all I ask. And don't excommunicate them for it either, Not a pretty site. Extra loves! *puts fma pasifyer in mouth*
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.