Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Homosexual Couples: Do You Have Favorite Same-sex FMA Parings? Which One?
Fullmetal Alchemist Discussion Board > Fullmetal Alchemist Discussions > FMA Character Discussions
Pages: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17
Kihaku
Heh, I could see Greed and Kimblee "getting along". biggrin.gif
Archer is less human than the homunculi? You mean when he was a cyborg or before alread? tongue.gif
blueices
Archer was pretty creepy...(chimeras seemed to turn him on) dry.gif
Kimbley was just plain cool (only he could pull off that variation of the mullet)...and Greed was equally kakkoi (thats why they can get along..)


Spoiler: (Click here to Display)
Omakase Shimasu
QUOTE(Kihaku @ Dec 30 2004, 02:27 PM)
blueices: Kase is a fellow fan of the KimbleyxArcher pairing! I wonder why she hasn't commented yet... yeah, they do go well together.. don't they? wink.gif

(My post got deleted. -.- I remember praising blueices for naming these pairings though. wink.gif)

laugh.gif So true.
Spoiler: (Click here to Display)
dragonflame327
QUOTE(BlueRakuen @ Aug 23 2004, 05:45 AM)
also the whole Wrath's "give me your body" thing is slowly getting to my head @__@

Yes!! XD Fanfic inspiration right there...

I voted EnvyxWrath.^^ Who was the other person?

Yes! EnvyxEdxAl! I for some reason, haven't noticed this thread yet, wtf? Lol.
Omakase Shimasu
biggrin.gif The other person who voted EnvyxWrath was Vael. He's the ultimate EnvyxWrath/EnvyxEd fanboy. wink.gif

And I understand how you could've missed this topic, since it isn't all that popular like say the Hottest Character poll. laugh.gif
Slashrose1010
I voted for Roy/Hughes because I just love both characters. I probably like Hughes more though smile.gif But the one I would want to see most is Winry/Riza. Come one, why do you think? wink.gif
Penguin
I voted for Roy/Ed. I just love how they interact, and it makes it a very interesting possibility in the fandom for a relationship. I do know the age difference and that they are both male, but I find this all the more dynamic and deep for them as a couple.

Plus, all the fanfics and doujinshi have gotten to me. =)
dragonflame327
Mhmm. Have to contact him.^^ Thanks.

From Aileon:

I voted Al/Ed... maybe ppl thinks i'm sick for loving this pairing ^^;;; But I think they're soooo cute together *0* I don't mind if it's incest... or maybe cause it's incest, i like it more than others XDDDD

Agreed!! I like it because it is, myself. And your avatar is so cute!!^__^
Slashrose1010
*pukes* Yak, that is really nasty. LOL, but pretty funny. lol can you imagine if they were like that? I guess Ed would have to be the chick in the relationship since Al's armor doesn't have any holes. (lol, yes I crossed that line.)
dragonflame327
Nice! XD I prefer Al human in the relationship, but if it was pre-ending, then I guess he'd use the lion cloth and his hands, if you know what I mean.
Slashrose1010
lol... this is just getting raunchy and disturbing...
Kihaku
Eh? The relationship between Al and Ed... well I see it "cuter" when Al isn't in the armour... or at least it's physically cuter then...
Hmm... don't know what I'm saying anymore...

Penguin: I like what you said! biggrin.gif
Penguin
Thank you Kihaku. XP

Plus, I agree with you a lot on the relationship between Ed and Al. I am not one for Elricest, personally. I really see their love as a platonic love. What they have is a brotherly love. I see where people get the idea and I understand but it is not my serving of waffles in the morning.

I think the main reason being is because my sister and I share a very close bond much like the two Elric brothers. If anything happened to us like it did to them, I am sure my sister and I would say and do the same things the brothers did for eachother in the series, all the way to giving up our entire selves for one another. Just because we are close... doesn't mean we love eachother. That is why I see it as a sibling love and nothing more. I know what it is because I experience it. XD

Now, not to say people can't like the coupling. That is the wonders of fandom [ and I say this as a Roy/Ed fan ] and people can go wild all they want. Whee!
Haste
I maybe stupid, but what is SHONEN-AI is that the act of homosexuality?
Penguin
Yes, Shounen-ai is the term for "boy's love". That is what many fangirls [ me among them ] squeel about. Scary, huh? tongue.gif
dragonflame327
I personally hate it how people will say two of the opposite together is a turn-on, great, perfect, wonderful, hot, etc.; yet when it comes to two of the same gender they'll go "that's just wrong." or something of the like. Basically, people who support homosexual relationships of the opposite gender, yet are against those of the same. Thinking it's "nasty", "I'd don't like it", etc is fine but just...that is...no. I hate that.

That little bit aside, which I may delete in the future...XD. Hmm...I wonder if Ed would be on the bottom in EdxAl, or Wrath on top for EnvyxWrath. Though technically, that's condradicting, since the person who comes first is on top but I think you get my point...^_^;;

Go shounen/shoujo-ai!!!^^ (If you're wondering, I happen to like both.)
Kihaku
Penguin: Yup! I don't see Ed's and Al's relationship deeper than brotherly love either. i think it's beautiful that way biggrin.gif Although I have nothing against the pairing either...

Haste: Like Penguin said, shonen-ai means boy's love, but it doesn't involve anything too intimate.. when it gets to that it's about yaoi. wink.gif

dragonflame: hmm... Did you mean girls liking shonen-ai but not shoujo-ai and boys liking shoujo-ai and not shonen-ai? Well... I must admit that I like shonen-ai/yaoi much more. I'm okay with shoujo-ai/yuri.. but seeing two girls together (pictured to making more appealing for guys) probably wouldn't be as "wonderful" wink.gif I don't know yet though.. tongue.gif I'm happy though that you like both biggrin.gif Oh.. and yeah... the ukes can rise from the top tongue.gif
DarkWater Alchemist
Hmm, yes, I also like shonen-ai more than shoujo-ai. i don't really know why... I guess because for me it's more interesting to see boys together, yes.

Ukes on top are even cuter ^^
Kihaku
Yeah... like is there are two uke types, then one has to be on top! tongue.gif
I for some reason like my fav characters to be seme... but sometimes it's cute when seme type are bottom laugh.gif .
Omakase Shimasu
laugh.gif I'm the other way around (favorites are usually uke~) but everybody alreadyknew that, me guesses.

But yush, it's fun to see the officially-labeled-uke topping the seme once in a while. X3 Variation's the spice of life afterall.

Buwaha, Roy/Ed owns all. ph34r.gif Why aren't there more votes though?
icanflyouch
Roy/Ed does own all. Well... at least it owns me~!
Omakase Shimasu
^^v Faithful 'R/E shipper' to the end.

Wonder why FMA hasn't got shipper-pairings yet though. I thought it was some kind of hype. blink.gif
icanflyouch
I could say the same~.

By shipping, do you mean like the name 'darkshipping', or something? *pulled out a random YGO one*
Joy to suffering
I voted for RoyxEd, cause they are the best couple EVER, but, I have to admit, HughesxRoy is starting to grow on me...
Omakase Shimasu
@icanflyouch: Yep, I mean those. biggrin.gif I thought it was only for game-pairings at first, but then I found out otherwise. Not that I really mind there aren't any shipper-pairings, because they confuse the he** out of me. tongue.gif But still, just wondering.


@Joy: Yay yay, don't be swayed! RE can take them (Hughes/Roy) on any day, woohoo! *puts away pom-poms* happy.gif
Joy to suffering
Of course, Roy/Ed is definately still the best, but Hughes/Roy is, I dunno. kinda cute. Roy/Ed will ALWAYS conquer, though. wink.gif
Joisu
I voted for Roy/Ed. That' the shit.. biggrin.gif
aNiMeAzNgUrLLH
I'm not really a person who is interested in homosexual couples. I loathe yaoi(there's some yaoi pairings I support from other anime, but it's hard to explain why I support it). I'm more of a yuri fan, even though I still despise homosexual pairings.

I like Riza/Winry. That's my choice.
Omakase Shimasu
@Joy: Yes, Hughes/Roy does have/did have potential and nobody can argue the fact. wink.gif But like you said, Roy/Ed conquers all! XD


@Joisu: I'm sure RE appreciate your vote! ^^v (Me included X3 - they're leading with 4 votes now)


@aNiMeAzNgUrLLH: Still, your vote's appreciated. biggrin.gif To me it's always better than not vote at all. (Maybe you can stand those particular pairings because they're hinted at or are actually canon?)
Kihaku
Shipperpairings for FMA? But if there aren't any.. we could make them up tongue.gif

Hughes/ Roy sooooo has potential! Especially in the early days tongue.gif
In the poll I voted for Roy/Ed though... I like both, but I probably like Hughes/Roy more biggrin.gif
aNiMeAzNgUrLLH: You loath yaoi? I admit that I didn't like shonen-ai pirings amongst my favourite chracters who I considered to be totally straight wink.gif even though all canon shonen-ai/yaoi parings were okay wink.gif (Now it's a different story..)
Omakase Shimasu
Ooooh, you wanna make up shipper-pairings? laugh.gif That'd be fun! I actually tried thinking of something before, but I couldn't come up with anything interesting and/or original. *big sigh* -.-
icanflyouch
Roy/Havoc could be smokeshipping... maybe. 8D

And maybe Roy/Ed could be... weldshipping. Ew no, that sounds corny. XD

Sweetshipping for Al/Winry.

Oh man I'm bad at this. XD;;;
Queen of the dammed
Literaly snipping for BarryxFalman!!!! XDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDd
Omakase Shimasu
laugh.gif I love your ideas! They're way better than my own. smile.gif I'd like to hear more~ (Or does that mean a whole 'nother thread?)
icanflyouch
Riza/Winry... violentshipping maybe?

Envy/Ed could be sadisticshipping.

*sits for hours trying to think of Havoc/Hawkeye* TT-TT
aNiMeAzNgUrLLH
@Omakase Shimasu:Well, I'm a person who's neutral on many things, and I really don't hate any shippings. People can be sexest sometimes(making the females feel low), and so I kind of have this little . . . grudge against guys, and I guess that's what makes me dislike yaoi. Er, well, I do support a few yaoi shippings(from some certain animes) but I just can't help it, that's all. I'm not overobsessed on yaoi/yuri shippings, though. I usually get obsessed on straight shippings. I could care less about hints and canons. biggrin.gif And for some odd reason, I sometimes like seeing yuri shippings. xD Stupid me.

@Kihaku: I disliked yaoi, yuri, and incest when I was about 13. Then I've come to learn that it's just the way life is. I think and support about incest sometimes, but it really doesn't interest me as much as yuri or het. It's not that I dislike the yaoi pairing, I'm fine with it. I support whatever I want, they support whatever they want, we don't argue, life is good. The thing is . . . there are some stupid fangirls out there who bash(fangirls who supports RoyEd and hates Winry, I don't hate RoyEd or anything) and gets into other people's business, which is very annoying.

I don't get why the bash. I find it stupid for someone to be wasting their time expressing something they hate, when they could use that time to support what they like.
Kihaku
Ooh... I don't have any good ideas.. *sighs* I have to think of those. and now I'm tired (as if it's anything new)
A new thread? Maybe?

Hmm... EnvyxEd has been classified as sado-ai tongue.gif So yes, sadisticshipping! biggrin.gif
And I'm just agreeing with everyone agian. Have to think of my own...
Hey aren't all shippings within the military people generally considered militaryshippings? wink.gif
But to be more exact...RussellxEd... hotblondshipping tongue.gif (also goes into the general category alchemistshippings= shippings between alchemists tongue.gif)
Actually I would have like to call it idealshipping, but I guess I'd be too biast?tongue.gif

LH: You're right! I like to waste my energy praising all I like instead of saying negative things about those I hate.. Well I don't really hate anything(although yes, some) and am pretty ready for opinions.. so...

Hmm.. interesting. The thing about yaoi/shonen-ai is also that women aren't seen in a "humbled" role. It's one of the guys. So that would be one great thing about it.
Hints and canons... *thinks* are quite important to me. I'd probably have a hard time liking a couple in which I don't see any proper chemistry...
Omakase Shimasu
laugh.gif I think a whole different thread for th shippings would be more efficient. wink.gif I'll start on it tomorrow or manybe the day after since we're having company tomorrow. Or maybe one of you guys can do it in my absence~

Great suggestions so far though! And I can sympathize, icanflyouch. I can't think of anything better than gunshipping. -.- (I thought Havoc had something with guns too?)


@LH: Complete agreement here. It'd be so much better if everybody just respected other people's preferences and wouldn't instigate bash wars with negative comments about a character/pairing or even maybe an aspect of the show they didn't like just to make other people see they shouldn't like it either.


@Kihaku: Hints can be a nice thing, but somehow... I like envisioning characters who don't have much of anything to do with each other, but still trying to form a relationship despite that. Ugh, can't explain very well right now, but... It's more like... I'm envisioning what it would be like if these two characters met and eventually started a relationship, or maybe not. biggrin.gif Just letting my imagination run wild.

I can also understand what it feels like to come up dry in such a case and wishing the two had had more hints and stuff. biggrin.gif;; That's annoying. (So I think the RussellxEd pairing was very fortunate in my eyes)
dragonflame327
*internet was out for a while*

Well, I don't like bashing persay, but arguing your point is fun.^^ Well, debating anyway. i. e. : Collete is annoying, I hate her. I'm explained why in many a thread at the GameFAQs boards. I have friend there who feels the same way so it's even better.^^
jessin
wtf al/ ed???

*looks at poll* You're making me cry..... TT______________TT
Omakase Shimasu
Sorry, but you really shouldn't have entered this thread if you knew you'd find it offensive or anything like that. ^^;; (I thought Elricest was pretty popular among the fanbase)
Kihaku
Kase: Ooh.. you never made the thread tongue.gif
I likehinted pairs tongue.gif. I can't really like pairs that don't have any proper chemistry between them. I need to have a reason for a pairing, right? wink.gif
Even if it is a little hinted there is room for imagination. Actually there always is.
Like with RusellxEd.. *sighs*. That has so much potential. wink.gif

jessin: It's okay. I know that some couples can be so cute that they make you cry. wink.gif

random note: My brother came to check what I was doing and caught sight of Roy/Ed wink.gif He was wondering a little.. it seems like Al/Ed didn't surprise him though wink.gif.
Omakase Shimasu
biggrin.gif;; Caught me. I'll get right to it though~

Hints are nice yes, but I also like the freedom to experiment without it aka crack pairings. ^^v

?? I thought -- didn't you say he knew Roy/Ed would be popular-est? blink.gif
Kihaku
Nah, no hurries wink.gif

crack pairings.. I think crack pairings are fun! wink.gif Or at least if I know what you mean by crack pairings... I don't take them "seriously" though and wouldn't become a fan or anything tongue.gif They're just... fun.
Now for pairings I adore/support/like/worship etc. I need some proof. wink.gif

Yeah, that's what I told him. tongue.gif I think he was more wondering that what on earth I'm thinking tongue.gif . Although I don't think he was so surprised. It's different when you see it there before you. tongue.gif
Omakase Shimasu
I kinda already made it. biggrin.gif;;

Crack pairings are basically pairings that don't have any hints. biggrin.gif Like (totally random) King Bradley and Ross.... @.@ Ooof~

Aaaa~ It's just too bad the images won't sway your brother to become a shonen-ai fan. tongue.gif He knew it was Roy and Ed in there? I wouldn't have guessed he'd be so familiar with it. I usually can't see the difference between characters when it comes to doujisnhi. biggrin.gif;; Maybe it's the art-style....
Kihaku
Yeah, I say you made the thread! yay! wink.gif
yeah, I thought crack pairings would be the random ones.. those have been discussed too. wink.gif Although some could classify Roy/Ed to be one.. or? tongue.gif
If they refuse to see hints...

Oh no.. my rother has't seen any images ... yet. Just the names. tongue.gif but good idea.. I think I could bombard him with some.. I doubt it would help though.. but since he doesn't like Ed or Roy he'd probably be more accepting in terms of the pairing wink.gif (pretty boys who he doesn't like can be usually considered gay tongue.gif). Ah, I dislike wasted potential.
Doujinshi art.. well I haven't read that many.. I don't know. I don't think it's difficult to disitinguish the chracters.. but sometimes that happens to me with manga and minor characters. tongue.gif
Omakase Shimasu
Yes, shonen-ai pairings could be considered to be crack pairings by most since they can't see or refuse to see the most obvious of hints. tongue.gif Guess crack pairings are biased, since everyone sees these things individually.. different. biggrin.gif;;

Wasted potential - ugh, hate that~ tongue.gif You'll just have to make your brother see! Oooh, so the ones he doesn't like make a cute pair? X3 Roy/Ed! Roy/Ed! Roy/Ed!
Kihaku
Hmm.. I guess shonen-ai pairings are considered crack pairings by those opposed and if the pairings aren't canon. tongue.gif (I mean thos both options together.)
Ah, we all see things differently.. some not at all. That's why more people should open their eyes.

Usually my bro doesn't pair people... well not in anime anyway. But he has that "thing" with seeing certain characters gay. tongue.gif I think though that since he wasn't shocked at all (I'm a little surprised) at Al/Ed.. he might consider that okay...
And since he knew the potential of Roy/Ed that has to mean something.. tongue.gif
Omakase Shimasu
Hmm... makes me wonder if they mean canon hints or just generally hints. blink.gif Um, did you really mean 'more people shouldn't' open their eyes instead of should? biggrin.gif;;

laugh.gif Usually men don't take interest in pairings. Guess it's a girl thing. rolleyes.gif Ever the matchmakers. Uhm? He knows Al and Ed are brothers... and he doesn't find that surprising? laugh.gif Well, considering he's against shonen-ai he might not find it okay. tongue.gif

Oh yes, yes, yes... X3 It definitely means something alright.
Kihaku
Oh drat have to edit my post. I'm really sleepy tongue.gif
Nah.. I'd expect it to mean canon hints. wink.gif

My brother came to bug me again (how convinient, he chooses the right time biggrin.gif). he pointed to the pairing (Roy/Ed)... Don't know what he meant. My computer just made a noise at that point then he remarked that my comp doesn't like it. (he didn't say that he doesn't though biggrin.gif)

Yeah, it's always the girls who're matchmakers.. *sighs*. But I know my brother could think differently. I think it's that he would never mention seriously a shonen-ai pairing that he'd like and he loathes the girl characters in anime, so he won't pair the guys with them. tongue.gif
Yeah, but my bro considers both Al and Ed "suspicious" so I don't think that pairing would be surprising to him. I have to ask him about that..
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.