Woah! The Palm Tree is winning?! I voted Lust. There better not be any vote buying going on! Do we even have pollwatchers? Quick Counts?

Sorry, Election just finished in the 'Pinas and I'm paranoid. Anyway, yeah, LUST RULES!!

I almost feel bad for saying this, but Envy will always have a place in my heart. Yeah, phsycotic androginous bastards are exactly my type. *giggle*

Wow, what a surprise, everybody's favourite androgyenous, palm-treed headed pyschopath with a "Daddy Complex" is winning. (The fangirls shall rejoice) As much as I find Envy's ruthless antics amusing both in the anime and in the manga, I have to vote for anime Lust because she showed the most human emotion out of all the sins.

Greed, of course. He is just too cool.

Greed. At least in the Anime (I am going to read the manga soon).
He wasn't a follower and was all about himself, in a cool way. He seemed to think outside the box too.

Lust, Lust would be my second, for her story and how she and Gluttony were almost always together.

Envy was one of the worst IMO. Well, no, Sloth seemed kind of boring actually. And Wrath got really annoying.

I will say this, although I have not read the manga yet, I really like the idea behind how the Humunculus were created/work in the Anime.

Envy i guest

I like both Wrath and Envy but i voted for wrath on the poll. he seems to be so unloved because he has ed's arm and leg. I don't get it ed would never get them back anyway so why hate him for that reason? darn it fans give the poor kid a break!

Envy Palm-tree head is so cool and amusing. In a good bad kinda way

Envy, of course. He's awesome, in his own insane, murderous, evil kind of way. Woo, go Envy
But I also really like Manga Wrath... and Anime Wrath too :]

Lust! I love her last lines in the manga.

Envy Envy Envy Envy Envy Envy Envy *continues on for about an hour*

Lust. Because in the anime she's so cool, in how she helped Ed and Scar at one point. But I like Greed to, after he told Ed how to kill the others.

My most favorite is Gluttony. I think he's adorable and funny and I love his devotion to Lust. I wish they'd show how those two got together . . . "Where's My Lust? Where's My Lust?". Next would probably be Lust. She seems to have the most human emotions out of all of them and she seems to be pretty smart. Next would be Greed (because he's just kewel), Envy, then Wrath. I found Sloth and Pride boring . . .

I love Envy. He's awesome. But afer that its Greed, Gluttony then Lust .

XD

GREED! GREED! GREED! GREED!

Come on, no one beats Greed. Not only was he a complete badass, but he was a badass with a heart. The chimaera were his family, and even in the end he treated Al, his hostage, well:

Ed: "Al! Where's Al?!"

Greed: (smiling-not grinning manically, but actually smiling) "He's in the forest. I let him go."

Yeah, agree with you, GiG. Ironically, Greed actually valued his subordinates, and had the backbone to rebell against the Big Bad in both Manga and Anime. He rocks in both.

But Sloth was kind of interesting too. She was unpleasant in the sense that she stood for everything Trisha Elric wasn't, but I loved the way she was troubled by her memories, but took a different approach from Lust. In the end I voted Lust though - like most pople said, she must have been one of the most complex Homonculi. These two women are so much more complex than their manga Homonculi counterparts - they'll keep the anime in my heart nomatter how superbly twisted the manga plotline is.

I pick the anime version of wrath (the kid version)

Well, I voted for Envy, the coolest homunculus ever. Sloth and Wrath came in second, Lust was third, and King Bradley (anime Pride and manga Wrath) came in fourth. I just love in volumes 4 and 6 when he's talking to Ed, then all of a sudden asks him if he likes melons, and gives him a melon. Greed is just an idiot. I'm sorry, Greed fans, but that is my opinion. The whole 'immortal' issue ticked me off. He's about as immortal as you can get; even more so than Al. But despite this, he still claims to not be immortal, even though homunculi are meant to be practically immortal.

I picked Envy! I LOVE him^^ He's so incredibly androgynous, evil, psychotic, and cunning I love it! And has a sexy body to boot He's been my favorite anime & manga character for 3 1/2 years now since I saw FMA He's pretty much amazing!

I chose Lust cuz she's so cool, my second is greed...

I'm torn between Greed and Wrath.
The reason for Greed is because he actually was against the other homunculi. And the reason for Wrath is...well...he was cute when he wasn't evil.

Greed is the best!

who is ur favorite homunculus mine is envy

@EnVy7 - You can find discussion threads for FMA characters in FMA Character discussion forum, including "Your favorite Homunculus?" thread. You can add your post there.
We also have many other interesting FMA character discussion threads, like these in that forum. Hope to see your posts there!!

Closing the thread.


ETA: Thread merged.

Lust FTW

Difficult to decide when Envy and Lust are equally wonderful
And then should wrath, when it's so cute!

My fav is Greed without a doubt. I like his relaxed, pimpish, rebelious addituted and his shield is totally awesome Yes, he's deffinaitly my fav.
Second would be Lust, I like her background story in the anime, as well as her additute.

My least fav would be Envy. I thinks he's annoying and ep 25 made me hate him so very badly XD

i picked envy because he's gorgeous and conceited and i love that.

Everybody think's Envy's hot (Well, all of my friends do...)

However, I disagree. My favorite is Sloth, cuz she was still nice to Ed and Al in the end, even though she knew she wasn't their mother.

Edit: Screw it, he is hot. But I'm not admitting anything.

...

Ever!

Lsut is the best by far :blush

I of course voted for Envy~! He's the best homunculi of all! And most angsty and bad XD I've always had tendention to fav the most evil characters and here he is! My pure evil! XD

true he is evil but lust is cool

Yup, she's awesome too~! Every homunculi is special in its own way~! But I think my second favourite homunculi is Greed. I love his storyline (from anime).

ENVY!!!! sorry... "fangirl-ish" much

aw manga characters arnt on the poll T_T i like manga pride XD and envy's cool too

Envy FTW~~!

Ironically, I loathe Envy.

Greed and Lust both tie for me; in my opinion, they were granted the widest range of emotion shown. Gluttony was adorable, too; I enjoyed his childlike personality and thought process, it was refreshing.

<Program Note>


Yeah, good point! XD And, IMO, it's better late than never, so....

Added FMA manga/FMA: Brotherhood homunculi poll choices.

Anyone who had already voted the first poll before, and hence can't vote for the second one, just post your vote choice for the second poll with a note saying you can't vote it because you voted the first one before, and periodically, I can manually add your vote to the vote tally.

I voted for Envy from the first anime... minus the whole son of Hohenheim crap... other than that he was pretty cool. Not as whiny as his manga counterpart was.

And Wrath from the manga/Brotherhood is just amazing... He really scares me! And he won't die.. gosh!

Yay thanks tombow Greeling (does that need spoiler tags? owell better be safe xD) is da epic+ manga pride

I voted for Greed, of course (in both catagories!). Greed's my favorite FMA character!

I LOVE manga!Pride. Next to Kimblee, he's my favorite Bad Guy. He's so deliciously creepy; you just love to hate him. xD He feels like the kind of character you'd see in a horror film. Heehee, what can I say? Creepy Bad Guys are awesome. I like the chills they give me.

As for the anime 1 homunculi, I went with Greed. Because he's just plain awesome.

Envy is the best in both.

Memory might serve me incorrect, but we've never seen Selim's/Pride's tattoo, have we? It could be possible he might not have one at all, since there's a good chance of Mrs. Bradley or a doctor or someone seeing it.

My favorite used to be Envy, and I still think he's fun and badass, but as the manga continued I gravitated more towards Greed and Wrath. Ling, the kickass prince of Xing becoming the arrogant Greed and their constant state of vacillating back and forth was too awesome for me to NOT like. XD

Lust, I just love her.

I wish they could have amalgamated her personality from both series' though, because I'll be honest I quite liked the little backstory for her in anime1. She just seemed like a more rounded character to me.

Lust was/has been my favorite. But she's totally different in the two versions. I don't know which one I like more...:\

for anime #1 non brotherhood I voted for wrath HANNNNDS DOWN ^^
(the cute one nawt the oldy lyke in botherhood )

=O W00T! Envy pwned the others in the first poll x3~ Envy ftw, Reason: He pwns, is strongest, hawt, evil, and cool =P

I've never liked Envy in either version; I've always thought him to be a complete git- just very, very horrible. The other Homunculi are alright, but...

I voted for Greed on both accounts. (Including GreedLing).

Yes! I agree. I still can't forgive him for what he's done.

My favorite hommunculi is Pride (in the manga)...it was shocking when his identity was reaveled, but it made sense in some way. He's so creepy but badass. I loved him especially during the Briggs arc in the tunnels...oooh! I like the way he slices things with his shadows. hehe.

And also Gluttony, he's so funny! "Can I eat him, Lust?" lol. and he's cute in a way, too. X3

In anime1, I liked Lust because of her past + personality.



Totally. Especially the thing about Kimblee...he's an awesome bad guy. ^^