Scar's my man. He's the best.

man this will be funnier when you watch the rest of the series

Are you gonna vote or what

already did, i voted envy

and btw Tell me if you have seen all the episodes

Most of them. a friend has downloaded them all so I will have seen them all by the end of the month. I expected you to vote gluttony

I like gluttony alot but i like Envy more, he's got that evil attitude in him the sinical style that i like lol

and what's the last episode you seen

Then why is your name Gluttony and you use Gluttony pictures

he was the first person that came to mind when making a name here >.<, i'm thinking of getting my name changed thou

Might want to do that

i watched all series and i'm saying SCAR!!!!
He's cool person and he can do anything to finish his job

just did that now to create a siggy for this name lol

and funny thing is Scar isn't a bad guy lol he's one of the good guys

I know but this is for the people who have only seen it on adultswim. By the way envy looks much better

Scar is not good or bad. He can do anything for his aim. İf he should kill someone (and he killed) he kill without thinking.

Hey scar san how many episodes have seen...Oh and loose the star wars avitar it looks stupid

Scar-san has probably seen all of them and I don't like Star Wars either, but I don't go flipping people off about it. And Scar-san is right. Scar isn't really good nor bad, but he leans more on the good side. And yes, I have seen every episode.

I picked Lust. She is the most human of the humonculi and she is very sedductive. Also, she kicks ass. [spoiler]She would have killed Wrath if Ed hadn't been stupid and thrown her locket at her like that[/spoiler] I also like Sloth, though she was a total bitch at first... I felt bad when she died, and not just because she is Trisha's humonculus.

sorry the star wars thing just bothers me. Lust is a good choise though . Doesn't Lust end up working with Ed. I saw a scene where they discuss why she wants a soul.

I don't really consider any of the Sins as bad, except for Envy and Pride. ATleast the others had a more nicer side them, and they had a much better cause. Scar isn't bad either. He helps the Elrics later in the series. As for Barry...well he's nuts lol and in love with Riza (in the manga).
I'd go for Envy, cause he's the baddest of the bad.

My vote would go to Scar, but I'm sorry...Greed is just too cool. And besides...

[spoiler]Scar ends up not being such a bad guy after all.[/spoiler]

Envy is my fav bad guy

I never really liked any of the sins, but I guess my favorite would be Lust if I had to pick one. Of course, that's because she was one of the only two-dimensional sin of the bunch. At least her mind could comprehend higher reasoning and understanding, and she was able to change too. You go girl! Now if we could only fix that dress...

~Merc

envy gets my vote.

sloth was just like lust thank you very much

oh and yes Scar has never been a bad guy, only in the eyes of the military, he killed the bad people that he thought were bad, he didn't go killing innocent lives

First of all İ said that i watched all episodes. And FMA JPD İ dont care u like my avatar or not. İf u dont like Star Wars dont look at my avatar. İ dont have time for that stupid ideas!!! And stop talking about other peoples avatars(at least my avatar) thats not your business!! respect other peoples hobies little. İ love Star Wars and just you dont like it, İ wont change my avatar

-I voted for Greed-
He's the only homonculus I ever liked. He's the most human of all of them because all he wants is common human nature: He only wants what he desires and will do anything to obtain it, after all, he is greedy. Plus I really like his outfit, glasses and bracelets....too bad he had a short apperance in both the anime and the manga.

good one dude, even thou i don't like star wars myself exept for a couple of the bad guys there pretty cool, but I don't care for star wars in general I feel ya lmao@people getting upset over someone else's avatar what a joke, what a comedian he is, thinking he can control over what someone else puts in his avatar lol I would have said the same thing if not worse

scar is the coolest

I like Wrath the best!!!!

I don't care what anybody else says. Scar will always be my favorite.

but that goes against this thing seeing he's not a bad guy

scar yah

You are right dude

I like Barry the Chopper most
I mean, in the manga.
I love the hearts that surrounds his head in the manga when he sees Hawkeye and calls her "missy".
Greed is cool too.
As for Scar... after *sigh it's a spoiler* [spoiler] after Roze's rapture and pregnancy, I began to notice that... well, scar isn't really that bad. And he is dark [/spoiler]
I like Lust and Gluttony too, but after Envy (sigh a spoiler) [spoiler]killed Maes Hughes [/spoiler] I like him less.

I'd say Scar. He was pretty badass, but he had a nicer side to him.

Barry the Chopper would be my fave in the manga.

All the Homunculus are badd ass just not Gluttony all he does is eat.But if I had to choose a fav. Id either say Wrath or Pride.*Hints the name*

While I agree with you, that kind of reasoning could get you locked up someday.

"Oh no, officer, that wasn't an innocent old woman, she was an evil psycho trying to kill us! She's evil I tell you! EVIL! You tell me I'm crazy, but I tell you she's EVIL!!"

lol, you're right there, Udon.

If I had to vote for one person, it would be Greed. He was a rebel, a badass, and the most human of the homunculi. Plus he was the Ultimate Shield.^^

But Scar is definitely one of the coolest if not the coolest.

I reckon scar is the least deep/effective bad guy in both the anime and manga. In both he is so superficial/shallow, that I think his mere presence is a cliche. Killing begets more killing eh? Well, whoever heard of that concept? </sarcasm> Whatever tragic past he has, he is practically shoving it into everyone's face without pushing himself to get on with his life. In short, Scar is probably the most overrated villain of the show/manga, a cliche in himself, melodramatic and until I see some more character developments in him (so far I've seen little or none, and I have finished the anime series and up to the latest manga chapter).

The best villain in the anime... mmm.... I don't know - perhaps Greed or Pride. Both are awesome. In the manga however, I think Wrath is the BEST villain (if his sinister nature was maintained in the anime, he would no doubt be the best there as well). I'll admit that Lust and Gluttony (who cares about Envy?) were both great earlier on, but of course, since one of them has been disposed of, the only villian who scares me and strikes me as terrifying yet powerful and cunning is Wrath. I'll be interested to see what further plans he has up his sleave... he seems to have his own agenda and may be different to the "Father".

lmao

a bad guy is someone that does something evil for fun, something to satisfy his need for killing, kicking someone's ass or whatever

Scar doesn't fit any of that

he's just misguided

Oops, a double post...the next post, though, was the one I wanted...

I voted Scar, though it's very close between him and Envy for me. Scar, I like because, as someone else said earlier, he has a lighter side to him. He's gone through a lot with his brother, understanding why he had his arm, in his perspective, and then just everything else that happens in the series.

He actually cared, in a weird...Scar sort of way.

Anyway, that's just my logic. Even after all that he went through, he didn't really let it make him into a "bad" person, per se, but just a person who let his past influence his decisions, with his brother.

Okay, moving off of Scar-san...

Envy, I like, because he's just a "bad guy" in the series. Like «°~Envy™~°» said, he just does what he does, which we call evil because of ep25, because he enjoys it. He said in one of the episodes he doesn't want what the other Homunculus want, he just wants to see humans suffer because of another thing in his past. He doesn't do his "job" for any other reason than that, which is hinting just a little mild insanity. And what's a bad guy without a few problems in his head?

So, yeah...it was very close for me, but I had to vote Scar since figured there was the majority for Envy and Scar-san deserved credit, too.


EDIT: I had something else posted, but I can't figure out how to do the spoiler thing, so I had to edit...

Scar``

I wish I could revote for greed.(I made this topic before I had seen the whole series

Greed is bad ass sucks that Ed (that asshole)kills him I hate Ed spoiler My fav moment:

Heh, heh, I like Envy 4 some reason.

Envy, dont know why,I just like him the most.

LUST!!!! <--- my first choice. Most kikass homunculus, in my opinion. And her figure(according to barry) is highly ...well..you know.

Envy comes in second (lol.. the CH 50)

Yes that really sucked that Greed had to die,and hah lovely picture.I cant wait to see that moment in the anime,Ill probably be busting out laughing.

I like Barry especially in the manga because he was so funny.

I like Lust.

GREED!!!!!

he is awesome!