Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Edward & Winry! A.k.a. EdXWin.
Fullmetal Alchemist Discussion Board > Fullmetal Alchemist Discussions > FMA Character Discussions
Pages: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 34, 35, 36, 37, 38, 39, 40, 41
Omakase Shimasu
You don't have piercings either, Kasumi?? Hmm, the process might be a bit painful at first. biggrin.gif;; Just like getting a shot but less so in my opinion. What you really don't wanna do is getting only one ear pierced twice at the same time. ph34r.gif That's HELL.

laugh.gif I remember that particular campaign. Hilarious to think back on. tongue.gif Lucky for Arakawa-sensei it didn't happen.
Kasumi
The things is, I ABSOLUTELY HATE needle shots... happy.gif;;

Lucky for us it didn't happen. laugh.gif I'd hate to imagine what would happen if Riza fans' worst fear came true. tongue.gif
Fresh_Coffee
I have my ear pierced but I'm not wearing earrings right now. I got it when I was in grade.2
Hedera
Kase
Uh... My dad was like that since my early childhood. sleep.gif Well, I can't do anything better than just trying to find a compromise... unsure.gif

Kasumi
I also HATE needle shots... dry.gif When I was a child I reacted exactly like Ed when I was given a shot - I always tried to run away and my parents brought me back. tongue.gif
Now I still hate shots...

Poor Arakawa-sensei... FMA fans have so many plans about her... biggrin.gif
SweetJanie
Think we should start a new topic, like 'What would u do if u met Arakawa-sensei?' tongue.gif I would beg to be her apprentrice!!

(PS: I know this has nothin to do with this but...how do u make ur sig be a hyperlink too??)
Merc
QUOTE
@Merc: You masochist, you.  No, I could never put 6 holes in my ears, just like that. Hmm, not to mention I like odd numbers. ^^v

Well, when you think about it, Winry's kinda a masochist too, always hitting Ed with wrenches and pounding the everloving crap out of his automail when she repairs it. Of course, nothing is funnier than her...

Spoiler: (Click here to Display)


LMAO, funny girl.

~Merc
Fresh_Coffee
You can start it if you want Janie I tried to get free copies of the manga from here and a picture of her cows for my friend who also loves cows. Did we ever translate the manga with the EdxWinry evidence I never checked.
aNiMeAzNgUrLLH
I definately support Edward and Winry.

If it's freaking popular in Japan, then I really see why not here . . . just check out the Japaneses Hagane search engines, topsites, fanlistings, etc . . . there's so many freaking Edward and Winry supporters in Japan and fansites dedicated to them with fanart, fanfiction, etc. . . ., I wish it was here, too.

Anyway, I feel sorry for the people who dislike EdWin. They're just wasting their time, literally.

Hm, what else . . . can we share fanart in here? I just lurve fanarts.

http://moonstar-id.hp.infoseek.co.jp/i/10000hit.html

http://moonstar-id.hp.infoseek.co.jp/i/rakugaki.html

Haha, in the second link, first picture(I think) it has Roy x Riza in there, too. xD
blueices
The notion of EdxWinry is cute, but I like the way its playing out similar to RoyxRiza...because there is so much drama going on, there really isn't time for romance. Therefore, the hints are there, but they aren't obvious.
That's what I like about the relationships in this series, the love is there but they make you look for it. biggrin.gif
Queen of the dammed
QUOTE(aNiMeAzNgUrLLH @ Jan 14 2005, 02:19 AM)
I definately support Edward and Winry.

If it's freaking popular in Japan, then I really see why not here . . . just check out the Japaneses Hagane search engines, topsites, fanlistings, etc . . . there's so many freaking Edward and Winry supporters in Japan and fansites dedicated to them with fanart, fanfiction, etc. . . ., I wish it was here, too.

Anyway, I feel sorry for the people who dislike EdWin. They're just wasting their time, literally.

Hm, what else . . . can we share fanart in here? I just lurve fanarts.

http://moonstar-id.hp.infoseek.co.jp/i/10000hit.html

http://moonstar-id.hp.infoseek.co.jp/i/rakugaki.html

Haha, in the second link, first picture(I think) it has Roy x Riza in there, too. xD

Kawaii!!!! X3333333 It's so sweet how Winry is kissing Ed!!!!
Hex-Sama
@aNiMeAzNgUrLLH: Thanks for posting those links biggrin.gif . I'm a big Edward/Winry supporter. In one of those pictures it looks like Alphonse dressed up like Edward laugh.gif .
Fresh_Coffee
Ahhh can't wait to see them! happy.gif Are there as much Roy/Riza fans??
Fresh_Coffee
Ahh the fanart is so pretty XD! I wish I could understand aswell. It's been awhile since this topic has been touched.
Queen of the dammed
It's a pitty WHY somany in the states don't like this pairing.... I think it's pretty sweet.... biggrin.gif
Fresh_Coffee
Most feel it's a sibling like relationship. EdxWinry needs more love. Roy/Riza is getting enough how many pages are their forum at? We must continue this topic! For Ed and winry!
hagane_no_tokage
i personally think aru/winry is cuter. X3
blueices
QUOTE(hagane_no_tokage @ Jan 14 2005, 11:53 PM)
i personally think aru/winry is cuter.  X3

Ah Tokage, the reasons to adore you grow greater everyday
Hex-Sama
QUOTE(Ailuro @ Dec 1 2004, 10:38 PM)
QUOTE(Hex-Sama @ Dec 1 2004, 08:49 PM)
@Ailuro: I wish I could read them too. Well, I have translated some of the single pictures. Like that one were Winry's got some kind of candy or something on her face, and Edward's trying to lick it off tongue.gif , the japanese words above say: Itadakimasu, which in english means "Bon appetit". When I found out I fell out of my chair laughing. laugh.gif

Ah yes, I know what itadakimasu means, I just can't read hiragana or kanji. ph34r.gif

FYI: "Bon appetit" isn't even English, tis French. xD

@Ailuro: laugh.gif Oops! Your right, that is french. Sorry about that, I'm kinda "spacy" at times dry.gif . *wants to crawl up in a ball and die from embarrasement* >.<
Ailuro
QUOTE(Hex-Sama @ Jan 14 2005, 09:14 PM)
QUOTE(Ailuro @ Dec 1 2004, 10:38 PM)
QUOTE(Hex-Sama @ Dec 1 2004, 08:49 PM)
@Ailuro: I wish I could read them too. Well, I have translated some of the single pictures. Like that one were Winry's got some kind of candy or something on her face, and Edward's trying to lick it off tongue.gif , the japanese words above say: Itadakimasu, which in english means "Bon appetit". When I found out I fell out of my chair laughing. laugh.gif

Ah yes, I know what itadakimasu means, I just can't read hiragana or kanji. ph34r.gif

FYI: "Bon appetit" isn't even English, tis French. xD

@Ailuro: laugh.gif Oops! Your right, that is french. Sorry about that, I'm kinda "spacy" at times dry.gif . *wants to crawl up in a ball and die from embarrasement* >.<

Oh it's no problem, I'm sure I've done something like that before. I just.. can't think of any off the top of my head right now. tongue.gif
Fresh_Coffee
AlxWinry? I could see it happening but I'm a bigger EdxWinry fan. There is somewhat evidence of them in the manga Al and Winry happy.gif
Hex-Sama
Winry is so lucky. She can have a pick between Edward and Alphonse, either way, it's a win-win situation laugh.gif . But if I were her, I'd choose Edward tongue.gif .
Fresh_Coffee
I would also choose Edward XD... does anyone read the Edxwin Fanfics on Fanfiction net? Some of them are so good.... I wish there was more though
Hex-Sama
@Fresh_Coffee: I've read some of the Edward/Winry fanfictions on Fanfiction.net laugh.gif , but its only been a few. I have a hard time finding good E/W fanfictions sad.gif .
Kirara
I am also an Ed/Winry supporter but I like how the romance is more subtle (same with Riza and Roy). But even if they didn't get together I would still be okay with that. My favorite relationship is Ed and Al's love as brothers. Plus I love the brother's relationship with Pinako/Winry, the military, Izumi, etc. It is sweet how even though they don't have a real family or home they kind of still have an extended family looking out for them. And sorry if I kind of moved this a little off topic. But I do enjoy the Winry/Ed moments, especially the "tough love" Winry shows Ed. laugh.gif
lindzilu
[ biggrin.gif Oh EdXWinry for sure, i for one am a sucker for cute couples and this could be one of the cutest, just wish the show would eleborate on their realtionship. I havent finished the series, does anything actaully happen between the two?
Queen of the dammed
QUOTE(Fresh_Coffee @ Jan 15 2005, 12:25 AM)
Ahhh can't wait to see them! happy.gif Are there as much Roy/Riza fans??

Quite a lot actualy.... XDDDD
Fresh_Coffee
There are really some good ones though. Have you read this fanfic? http://www.fanfiction.net/s/2146353/1/ Very cute happy.gif there is another writer who is really good too!
Fresh_Coffee
In Japan because in North America we can be sure RoyxRiza is dominate. XD I have the urge to read a EdWin fic I've been living off RoyxRiza for awhile now must switch back XD.
Hex-Sama
@Fresh_Coffee: Thanks for giving the link to that story biggrin.gif . Is it just me, or do alot of Edward/Winry fanfictions end with a sad/happy ending unsure.gif ? It usually goes like this: Edward visits Winry, one of them makes a move, and then Edward has to leave... again sad.gif . I don't know, that's just the way most of the ones I've read go. I need to filter more through the fanfiction.net stories, because I'm missing all of the Edward/Winry fics laugh.gif .
Queen of the dammed
Pregnant Winry.... intresting... biggrin.gif
Fresh_Coffee
http://www.fanfiction.net/s/2110677/1/ Another story for you fans. This fanfic writer has 3 more Edwin fics I believe they are all very sweet. XD
Hex-Sama
@Fresh_Coffee: I've heard of that author before, Vitani FyreWolf. That person wrote quite a few good Edward/Winry fanfictions biggrin.gif .
Fresh_Coffee
It's very good I love the one where Winry and Edward are staring at the window. XD I fell off my chair literally. I wish more writers would write Edwin I still think they need more love.
Linda
EdxWinry, would probably be weird... very.. Although there are A LOT of hints in the magna, and i wouldn't really know about the anime, i'm still thinking about ordering the series. So far I found only one picture where Winry and Al hold hands. Plus i can't really see Ed kissing someone blink.gif
Kasumi
Well, one does not have to kiss another to be in love, right? wink.gif

The only problem with EdxWin for me is that I can't see Ed settling down. He's just not that type of guy. Who knows? Maybe he'll change as he grows older. happy.gif
Fresh_Coffee
Al and Winry hold hands? I don't remember that. I can see where you are coming from Kasumi, we can hope Ed will settle down, but I don't think Winry would mind perhaps she would follow him?
Kasumi
Yes, it seems likely that Winry will follow him, in her own quest to becoming the world's best automail mechanic. wink.gif
TanukiFan
QUOTE
Yes, it seems likely that Winry will follow him, in her own quest to becoming the world's best automail mechanic.  wink.gif


Yes, and when the series ends *Sob* the sequel will be called FullBlonde automail mechanic. Actualy, that would be pretty cool.

But I agree with Fresh_Coffee. I cannot see Ed settle down. Al, maybe, but Ed staying in more than one place for more that a week seems odd.

I think this may be my longest post... *sigh*
SweetJanie
Well, Ed is travelling against his will. He wouldn't be travelling if they weren't searching for the philosopher stone...

I believe that, after they get their bodies back, Ed will settle down. After so many years of research and travelling he must be tired. Nothing better than a nice wife and a bunch of kids for a good rest laugh.gif

Your problem is not the impossibility of Ed getting a girlfriend. Your problem is lack of imagination!! tongue.gif Which I have loads rolleyes.gif .
Queen of the dammed
They would certainly make an interesting pair!!!!! laugh.gif
Jaken1001
.......NO! It makes me wanna puke thinking about that(really, it does).
Ed is probaly the hardest person to hook anyone up with. He is pretty cool as just someone that didn't have a girlfriend or boyfriend(if he is gay, who knows)
Wait a minute! I got an idea! Al should become involved with Winry!!!!

MUHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!!!(Ed moment, please ignore this evil ravenous laughter) blink.gif
Aoi Sora
I suppose it's a matter of what you're looking for and how you look at things. I've noticed pretty blatant hints but that might just be the fact that I'm pretty rabid about couplings once I make my mind about one. Wether or not Ed and Winry's relationship reaches fruition by the manga's end is questionable (Damn the Japanese and their brilliantly subtle relationships!) but the potential is there.

As for Al/Win, it's pretty obvious that he probably had a crush on her at one point. I don't see it developing past Winry seeing him as a younger brother. Never know though... She IS into 'heavy metal'.

I really don't think Ed would want to stay single for the rest of his days. His quest obviously takes priority over a lot of things including women, but once that's taken care of I could easily see him settling down and enjoying all the things he missed because of the constant travel. In the end I think all Ed really wants is to live his life the way he used to with Al.
Queen of the dammed
Al definately has something for Winry... but Winry just treats him as younger brother.....
Fresh_Coffee
I don't think Winry would develope feelings for Al like she would Edward.
hidden_death
I...can't...see...them TT_TT
Fresh_Coffee
Thanks Hidden Death for reawaking the topic and I can see them but I don't know why you can't.
Guest
Chapter 44's full of EdXWinry.

*spoilers*

Garfiel nagging Winry about her ungentlemanly *patron* that ran away leaving her with no $.. the scene where Ed's trying to jog everyone's memories, and we learn that Ed was rejected by Winry when they were 5.. because Ed was shorter than Winry.
Ed's reaction is priceless. biggrin.gif
Finally.. that scene where Winry wonders at how large Ed's back is. I wonder what she means too. blink.gif
SweetJanie
w00t!!! Beautiful!!! Thanks, guest!!! I have the chapter, but I just can't get jap... T_T
Btw, that thing about his back being large, it must mean that he carries alot of responsibility on his shoulders and worries as well. At least that's what I imagine it could be... ph34r.gif

*points at sigs* wub.gif
akiasha
Let's see my official feeling on pairings in FMA. Well I'm all for the Win Ed pairing. I tend to think of the pair of them like a love/hate kinda thing. I can't imagine that the two of them would ever be lovey dovey, I can see them butting heads, I can see her pulling out the chainsaw every now and then. But that's just their characters. The pair of them like to be in charge of everything, so having them be in a relationship other than just friends is gonna be one hell of a growth spurt(pardon the pun) for old Ed and Win.

Now the Roy Riza pairing is pretty much stamped on every page, how anyone could miss it is beyond me. I think I understand why it is that they tend to keep this thing quiet. The biggest reason is that Roy is Riza's superior officer, bascially if they ever did get involved in the open they would both be up for a pair of court martials. Which I guess why he enjoys it so much, Roy strikes me as the kind of guy that doesn't go for the easy relationship(though he does enjoy them...). Riza also strikes me as the kind of woman, who does know that she's in love with him, but is also driven to see that he gets his dream. wub.gif Which basically is my way of saying I'm all for the pairing, but I don't think it's gonna go any further until he has the power to pardon himself. In other words, when he becomes fuhrer(I can't for the life of me figure out how to spell that.).

As for the Win Al pairing, I'd really have to stretch my imagination on that one. I can see them as really good friends, but anything more than that would be on the far fetched realm of possiblity. Especially considering I don't think Al has ever hinted at the possibility of him liking her as more than a friend. To me it seems as if Al sees Win as a big sister or this cousin that comes over all the time. Anyways...I just don't see it happening.

All this being said, I'm fairly certain someone will disagree with me. As for the yaoi pairings...I have only one reaction to that. Ewww.... To me that is really stretching it. I think I shall stop here for now.
Guest???
I just want some closure from the anime.. which I think we'll get in the manga.

In terms of EdxWin
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.