Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Edward & Winry! A.k.a. EdXWin.
Fullmetal Alchemist Discussion Board > Fullmetal Alchemist Discussions > FMA Character Discussions
Pages: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 34, 35, 36, 37, 38, 39, 40, 41
sasuki_604
That is so cute! biggrin.gif
My fav. FMA couple!
Fire_from_Ashes
IPB Image

IPB Image

IPB Image

I forgot who drew these... sorry! It wasn't me though!
Gashole
Whenever the two stand side-by-side, I can't help but noticing that Ed is less or as tall as Winry, which leads to my being unable to think of them as a cute couple.

Plus some of the fanarts are too racy for my taste. ph34r.gif
Ailuro
Would you like it better if they made Ed taller in the fanarts and thereby being incorrect? And explain why its racy.. o_o
Fire_from_Ashes
Ah yes. Just wanted to add. That first fanart (the black and white kiss one) is actually the background on my computer.

Gashole, would you rather the heights be incorrect and therefore ruin one of the funniest and series-wide jokes in teh series? About how Ed IS SHORT. Technically (nowadays) a guy under 5'8 is (at least to me) short. the 5'9 to 6'0 range in becoming the average now.
Omakase Shimasu
QUOTE(Gashole @ Nov 23 2004, 03:37 AM)
Whenever the two stand side-by-side, I can't help but noticing that Ed is less or as tall as Winry, which leads to my being unable to think of them as a cute couple.

Funny, I can't help but notice Ed being taller or as tall as Winry in almost every fanart... The art's beautiful though...

This kinda destroys my image of them being a cute couple too, now that I think about it. biggrin.gif;;
RoyxRiza BigFan
those fanart is still yummy >W<
Gashole
QUOTE(Fire_from_Ashes @ Nov 22 2004, 11:32 PM)
Gashole, would you rather the heights be incorrect and therefore ruin one of the funniest and series-wide jokes in teh series? About how Ed IS SHORT. Technically (nowadays) a guy under 5'8 is (at least to me) short. the 5'9 to 6'0 range in becoming the average now.

In the black-and-white one Ed is actually taller though. tongue.gif

Maybe we need more pictures of Ed standing up and Winry sitting down.
Wenry'sfangirl
wow cute pic.s there so Kawii happy.gif Wenry and Ed are ment for each other!!
telepika
Fanart with Winry sitting and Ed standing... Hahahahaha!! Poor Ed...

The Christmas one in which Winry and Ed are the same height,... Ed doesn't have his "antennae." ph34r.gif
Chibi-Usa
KAWAII! Those fanarts are adorable!And anyway,Ed will hit a growth spurt someday! dry.gif
RoyxRiza BigFan
i wish i could draw like them *^*
Omakase Shimasu
QUOTE(Chibi-Usa @ Nov 24 2004, 06:28 PM)
And anyway,Ed will hit a growth spurt someday! dry.gif

I certainly hope not. If anything that would make him OOC in my opinion. tongue.gif

Hehe, Ed standing and Winry sitting... Reminds me of Micheal J. Fox. laugh.gif I love short guys.
telepika
SHORT PEOPLE RULE!!!!! cool.gif
Omakase Shimasu
They do~!! biggrin.gif

Oh, piccie of them... wel, they're not together, but they're official artwork from one of Arakawa's artbooks. The Winry one was made by someone else though (at least, I think... can't understand Japanese, so):

IPB Image
Scrumhalf
QUOTE(Chibi-Usa @ Nov 24 2004, 06:28 PM)
KAWAII! Those fanarts are adorable!And anyway,Ed will hit a growth spurt someday! dry.gif

He already has. (In the real world - Munich '21)
Hex-Sama
@Scrumhalf: How do you find all those awesome pics of Edward and Winry? The best place I've found them *besides this forum and the AnimeSuki forum* is at Love Cherry . Could you give me some of the links where you find this pics, please? OH, I love your avatar at AnimeSuki biggrin.gif . It's so funny laugh.gif
LordGohan
earlier u said u were thikin about shirtless winry...then go to google images...I think u no the rest... biggrin.gif
Ailuro
QUOTE(Hex-Sama @ Nov 28 2004, 01:40 PM)
The best place I've found them *besides this forum and the AnimeSuki forum* is at Love Cherry .

Wish I could read the comics. ~_~
SweetJanie
<Editing the title for "Edxwin" to "Ed x Win" to make the titl easier to read. 02/25/07 ~Tombow>

Ed and Win oughta be together!! I don't remember the chapters but in some of them we can see someting indicating that!! Like Hughes saying that Win was Ed's girlfriend and that she'd make a good wife and Al's comments about those too!!! I hate to know that the anime cut it all!! dry.gif

*hits head on keyboard and cries*
Ninie
I don't like Ed/Winry (in fact, I don't like Ed/Abyone, except Roze) but if you do...
Des
I dislike Ed x Winry. As friends, they're awesome, but as lovers, they're cliche. That pairing would destroy how cool Winry is. No. Just no. >< And that ... stupid Motherland ED with Winry being all shoujo was just traumatizing. They turned her into a FANSERVICE GENERATOR. Bastards!

I HATE Ed x Rose. I'm sorry, that's just disgusting. Ed deserves better than that .. that... whiny-ass bible punching twat.

Ed pairings are just... NO. Don't pair Ed. It'd take away from him. >.< Seriously. Leave the poor boy alone!
Quistis88
QUOTE
I dislike Ed x Winry. As friends, they're awesome, but as lovers, they're cliche. That pairing would destroy how cool Winry is. No. Just no. >< And that ... stupid Motherland ED with Winry being all shoujo was just traumatizing. They turned her into a FANSERVICE GENERATOR. Bastards!

I agree, Des! I prefer Ed alone as well, not that I like to see him alone. But it's just that, right now, Ed doesn't seem the sort for any type of commitment, nor would he be the sort that even someone like myself would seek for any type of commitment.

I like Al x Winry.
xrninja
eew, i'm not a big fan of al/winry. especially after the way the anime ended XP i'm a supporter of ed/winry because i think their relationship's pretty cute, but i could see ed being alone, too. the way they interact hints a bit at it, but unfortunately ed/winry takes a backseat to my OTP, roy/riza wub.gif
Guest_alchemist
well, in the manga, it's more evident that they have 'something' going on between the two. however, it isn't exploited as far as us ed/win shippers hope. however, who knows? right?
Quistis88
QUOTE(xrninja @ Dec 1 2004, 09:12 PM)
but unfortunately ed/winry takes a backseat to my OTP, roy/riza wub.gif

Backseat, indeed. laugh.gif
Ninie
QUOTE(Des @ Dec 1 2004, 05:18 PM)
I HATE Ed x Rose. I'm sorry, that's just disgusting. Ed deserves better than that .. that... whiny-ass bible punching twat.

sad.gif It's because I like Rose... And I think she really needs someone.

*why everyone hates her? Guess I'll never have answers...*

But I agree on what you said about Winry. And Ed, too. Even if I like Ed/Rose, I prefer Ed alone.
hagane_no_tokage
i totally agree that ed/winry is kind of cliche... i admit that there is a lot of chemistry between them, but it strikes me as pretty platonic chemistry, even in the manga. they're old friends, they're good friends...but i think if they ever got together, it would just be weird, and ruin their freindship. she does care a lot about him, but i don't think she would ever really want to be in an intimate relationship with him, yah? but i can see winry totally disapproving of any girl who DOES get close to ed, you know? she'd prolly chase them off saying they're not good enough for him. happy.gif

al/winry is a cute idea, but winry doesn't seem the type to go for younger men. i know it's only a year, but even so, she has always struck me as one of those super-independant strong and self-sufficient women who isn't on the lookout for a boy...but when she falls for one, i see her with an older man. er...not like OLD old, but you know what i mean. al is a sweetheart, but i think that winry sees him like a brother... same with ed.

and ew, ed/rose is just wrong. he deserves soooo much better. she's so...fickle, if you ask me. first she's all, "oh cornello-sama is so great!" and then once he's gone, she
Spoiler: (Click here to Display)
i'll admit rose kinda needs someone...but surely not ed. ed needs a woman who's as strong as he is...someone who can truly stand on her own feet and support him...like how riza always backs up roy, no matter what. rose needs a babysitter...and ed's certainly not going to go for that.

on a different note, i think ross and broche are cute together... roy and riza rule, of course... but poor havoc, when is he gonna catch a break? T__T does anyone else think he would look awful cute with sheska?
xrninja
i kind of think sheska and falman would be cute happy.gif there are quite a few havoc/lanfan people here, but i haven't seen a shred of evidence for that and frankly i like ling/lanfan. but if no one wants havoc, i'll be happy to take him =)
Quistis88
Can I have Fury then? biggrin.gif
Ninie
QUOTE(xrninja @ Dec 1 2004, 11:07 PM)
i kind of think sheska and falman would be cute happy.gif there are quite a few havoc/lanfan people here, but i haven't seen a shred of evidence for that and frankly i like ling/lanfan. but if no one wants havoc, i'll be happy to take him =)

Yes, I made a Lan Fan/Havoc banner happy.gif It's one of my favorite crack pairings happy.gif I think Havoc could be paired with many girls, because he needs one so much... biggrin.gif Even if I'm a RR supporter, I like Riza/Havoc, too.
xrninja
are you short enough for him? laugh.gif go ahead, he seems your type anyhow. you'll be the geeky glasses duo! rolleyes.gif

(<---is also a geek with glasses)

EDIT:
QUOTE
Even if I'm a RR supporter, I like Riza/Havoc, too.


ooh, i'm sorry, i'll have to kill you now. it's for your own good, one cannot live with a mind tainted with hawkeye/havoc!
Guest
anyone thought of havokxwinry ?? tongue.gif.. i do ..
Hex-Sama
I totally and completely support EdwardxWinry wub.gif , and there is more "chemisty" seen between them in the manga then an the anime. Come on, I know they're good friends, but even my best guy friends aren't comfortable walking around infront of me only in there boxers! He's more comforable around Winry then any other woman/girl. If I were Winry... I'd take advantage of the situation. laugh.gif
Hex-Sama
@Ailuro: I wish I could read them too. Well, I have translated some of the single pictures. Like that one were Winry's got some kind of candy or something on her face, and Edward's trying to lick it off tongue.gif , the japanese words above say: Itadakimasu, which in english means "Bon appetit". When I found out I fell out of my chair laughing. laugh.gif
Des
Hagane no tokage, I hate Rose's hairstyle. Why?

Because she stole it from ME! XD I have the same hair, except it's blue where hers is pink and it's not as long.

The Stand and Walk scene was the only scene where I've liked Rose, yeah. =3

Ninie, I think the reason people dislike Rose is because when she yelled at Ed for showing her the truth about Cornello, that was totally ungrateful and immature and very annoying. Then when she showed up later, she was just ... blank. o-o
Compared to all of the other female characters who are much cooler, she is just so weak and unimpressive. And she should NEVER be paired with Edward. That is wrong on levels I cannot even express.

QUOTE
Come on, I know they're good friends, but even my best guy friends aren't comfortable walking around infront of me only in there boxers! He's more comforable around Winry then any other woman/girl. If I were Winry... I'd take advantage of the situation.


I think if Edward-san thought Winry would "take advantage of the situation", he wouldn't be walking around her in boxers, now would he? Come on now. That's only more proof that he sees her as a sister, even if Winry does like him. Plus, Winry has far too much respect for him to "take advantage of the situation." Not only is Ed x Winry cliche, it is bordering on incestual.

....Farman x Sciezska would be cute.

But what about Ross x Sciezska? >3 http://www.deviantart.com/view/9521882/
Ailuro
QUOTE(Hex-Sama @ Dec 1 2004, 08:49 PM)
@Ailuro: I wish I could read them too. Well, I have translated some of the single pictures. Like that one were Winry's got some kind of candy or something on her face, and Edward's trying to lick it off tongue.gif , the japanese words above say: Itadakimasu, which in english means "Bon appetit". When I found out I fell out of my chair laughing. laugh.gif

Ah yes, I know what itadakimasu means, I just can't read hiragana or kanji. ph34r.gif

FYI: "Bon appetit" isn't even English, tis French. xD
hagane_no_tokage
@Des no kidding, rose stole your hairdo? i like blue better than pink, anyhow, so yours is better, in that case. happy.gif

and i agree, if Ed was concerned Winry would try and have her way with him, do you think he would be so content to not only walk around in his boxers with her in the room, but fall alseep with his stomach exposed like Al is always chiding him for? they have an amazing foundation of trust, and they know they've got the other's back, but it still just seems like it would put them in an awkward position to get together. they would do anything for one another, it seems...but i just can't see them hooking up on a romantic level without it being...weird.

@xrninja i'll fight your for havoc! *puts up dukes* tongue.gif
Ninie
QUOTE(Des @ Dec 2 2004, 12:12 AM)
Ninie, I think the reason people dislike Rose is because when she yelled at Ed for showing her the truth about Cornello, that was totally ungrateful and immature and very annoying.  Then when she showed up later, she was just ... blank. o-o
Compared to all of the other female characters who are much cooler, she is just so weak and unimpressive.  And she should NEVER be paired with Edward. That is wrong on levels I cannot even express.

Well, I think she reacted this way because she is human. I would have done the same thing, even if it's ungrateful, immature and annoying.
xrninja
QUOTE(hagane_no_tokage @ Dec 2 2004, 02:10 PM)

@xrninja i'll fight your for havoc!  *puts up dukes*  tongue.gif

hahah go for it! but sorry, i've never lost in a fight against a girl before wink.gif (i've had my ass kicked by plenty of black belt guys, though) rolleyes.gif
darkangelslayer
i think that winry and ed shouldnt get 2gether cz then when or if they break up it would b awkard.even if they were a couple and saw each other it would b awkard.
ed:hey winry!
winry:hey honey!
now tell me that sounds wrong!
Des
QUOTE(hagane_no_tokage @ Dec 2 2004, 02:10 PM)
@Des no kidding, rose stole your hairdo?  i like blue better than pink, anyhow, so yours is better, in that case.  happy.gif

and i agree, if Ed was concerned Winry would try and have her way with him, do you think he would be so content to not only walk around in his boxers with her in the room, but fall alseep with his stomach exposed like Al is always chiding him for?  they have an amazing foundation of trust, and they know they've got the other's back, but it still just seems like it would put them in an awkward position to get together.  they would do anything for one another, it seems...but i just can't see them hooking up on a romantic level without it being...weird.

@xrninja i'll fight your for havoc!  *puts up dukes*  tongue.gif

Thanks! **shakes fist at Rose** Friggin' hairstyle thief~!


It would be seriously wierd. O.o; I really don't think there's anyone in the show who Ed would fall in love with.

...How many of you people would I have to fight to get Ed? XD
Quistis88
QUOTE(Des @ Dec 2 2004, 07:12 PM)
...How many of you people would I have to fight to get Ed? XD

Fight for Ed? That's suicide! laugh.gif You'd probably have to fight Ed himself as well!
Hex-Sama
QUOTE(Quistis88 @ Dec 2 2004, 08:10 PM)
QUOTE(Des @ Dec 2 2004, 07:12 PM)
...How many of you people would I have to fight to get Ed? XD

Fight for Ed? That's suicide! laugh.gif You'd probably have to fight Ed himself as well!

I would be willing to make that sacrifice. *lmao* laugh.gif
Des
QUOTE(Quistis88 @ Dec 2 2004, 08:10 PM)
QUOTE(Des @ Dec 2 2004, 07:12 PM)
...How many of you people would I have to fight to get Ed? XD

Fight for Ed? That's suicide! laugh.gif You'd probably have to fight Ed himself as well!

I think I'd rather fight Edward-san than an angry fangirl mob. It'd be more fun and less likely for me to die. XD

Besides, when you fight with someone, you learn everything about how they are. I can think of nothing more intimate! ^^
hagane_no_tokage
i don't think i would fight for ed's hand, cuz somehow i just can't even se him condoning such a thing... i sure wouldn't mind having him as a brother (i think i'm a little old for him, anyway... ~_~), but somehow i can kind of see him being a lone wolf for a long time. just because that seems more his personality, he doesn't strike me as the type to settle down quickly, know what i mean? so i will back out of the fight to be ed's partner... but can i at least play with his hair sometimes??? XD it'd be awesome to have ed for a drinking buddy. heh...when he's old enough. XD

@xrninja...i'm not a black belt...yet. i just passed my blue belt test, tho, so i'm feeling lucky... bring it on... ph34r.gif havoc shall be miiiiiine! ^o^

*in the background, havoc gets a nosebleed at the thought of girls fighting over him*
xrninja
QUOTE(hagane_no_tokage @ Dec 2 2004, 10:39 PM)
@xrninja...i'm not a black belt...yet.  i just passed my blue belt test, tho, so i'm feeling lucky...  bring it on...   ph34r.gif  havoc shall be miiiiiine!  ^o^

*in the background, havoc gets a nosebleed at the thought of girls fighting over him*

sure thing! i outrank you too wink.gif on our dojo's rank system at least. i keep on stopping for months at a time, though (this time because of college apps. and my sensei left because of paycheck problems and i don't know if i want to go back if he's gone) i think havoc should be scared that so many violent girls are fighting for him laugh.gif

i wouldn't want to be with ed as anything other than a good friend, though. like tokage said, he's more of a lone wolfish (if he's not with winry tongue.gif)
Des
QUOTE(hagane_no_tokage @ Dec 2 2004, 10:39 PM)
i don't think i would fight for ed's hand, cuz somehow i just can't even se him condoning such a thing...  i sure wouldn't mind having him as a brother (i think i'm a little old for him, anyway...  ~_~), but somehow i can kind of see him being a lone wolf for a long time.  just because that seems more his personality, he doesn't strike me as the type to settle down quickly, know what i mean?  so i will back out of the fight to be ed's partner...  but can i at least play with his hair sometimes???  XD  it'd be awesome to have ed for a drinking buddy.  heh...when he's old enough.  XD

@xrninja...i'm not a black belt...yet.  i just passed my blue belt test, tho, so i'm feeling lucky...  bring it on...   ph34r.gif  havoc shall be miiiiiine!  ^o^

*in the background, havoc gets a nosebleed at the thought of girls fighting over him*

I'm mainly kidding anyway, I think the same way you do about his personality. In all honesty, I wouldn't lay a finger on Edward-san. XD

Though maybe he'd like to hang out with me a lot because then he wouldn't be the shortest person around! >.>;;
Des
QUOTE(xrninja @ Dec 2 2004, 11:52 PM)
i wouldn't want to be with ed as anything other than a good friend, though. like tokage said, he's more of a lone wolfish (if he's not with winry tongue.gif)

And trust me, he's not. =P
Quistis88
QUOTE(Des @ Dec 2 2004, 10:58 PM)
Besides, when you fight with someone, you learn everything about how they are. I can think of nothing more intimate! ^^

Heh, I can see it now . . .

Random Fangirl: "OMG! If I fight Ed I get to touch him! OMG, OMG!"
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.