Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Edward & Winry! A.k.a. EdXWin.
Fullmetal Alchemist Discussion Board > Fullmetal Alchemist Discussions > FMA Character Discussions
Pages: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 34, 35, 36, 37, 38, 39, 40, 41
A Pierrot's Aria
*Hangs head in shame* Seeing as EdWin is my OTP, I'm currently kicking myself for not attempting to keep this thread alive!

I think one of the theme songs for Ed and Winry would definitely have to be Harbour by Vienna Teng. I heard this song about two years ago and instantly thought it was a perfect fit for EdWin. I believe I actually posted it a long while ago in the character/couples song thread...

I think the whole song fits them perfectly; particularly the last verse:

"You've got a journey to make
There's your horizon to chase
So go far beyond where we stand
No matter the distance
I'm holding your hand
"

wub.gif

I mean, it just encompasses Ed and Winry's situation so well: While Ed is always travelling (to get Al's body back etc etc), Winry will always be waiting for him and thinking/worrying/caring about him no matter where he is. And he always will have her to come back to. happy.gif

*Shields self from further pillow attacks* laugh.gif
Dearheart
Oh gosh, I LOVE THAT SONG. (Vienna Teng is so brilliant; she's like the Arakawa of music. trufax.) And it really does fit them like a glove. Sometimes I think Vienna (Warning --Potential end of series spoilers ahead) went forward in time, read chapter 108, then came back and wrote that song just for EdWin. (Or at least the last ten pages of the manga.) xD And besides that, the lyrics are just plain gorgeous. Her lyrics are poetry. <3

"Fix You" is obvious, and I'm pretty sure most of us here are familiar with that song. "Pieces" isn't nearly as famous (though it deserves to be), but it's kind of the Ed-version of Fix You...

I'm here again, a thousand miles away from you
A broken mess, just scattered pieces of who I am
I tried so hard, thought I could do this on my own
I've lost so much along the way

Then I'll see your face, I know I'm finally yours
I find everything I thought I lost before
You call my name, I come to you in pieces
So you can make me whole


*sniffles* Makes me tear up every time...
Sakuyahanabi
Hey, look at that, this thread seems to be alive after all! biggrin.gif

I so agree with you, Vienna Teng is brilliant, and her music is so EdWin. <3

Dearheart, did you make that amazing EdWin mmv on youtube, with 'Erics song'? (Your name is almost the same as that youtube user, and the song is, well, by Vienna Teng) - It was the very first EdWin mmv I ever saw, and I think it's beautiful. I still watch it from time to time. wink.gif

Edit; hold on, I just clicked at your sig - it is you who made it. As I said before, it was the very first manga!EdWin vid I watched, back when I didn't really knew anything about the FMA manga, but only watched the original anime. Your vid was partly my inspiration to actually read the manga (as I saw it was loaded with EdWin moments)
Dearheart
Ahaha...yep, I made that one. (My internet username is ALWAYS either Dearheart, or Dearheart42. I float around in a lot of places.) It was my first-ever EdWin video, and I'm still pretty proud of it. happy.gif I'm glad you like it so much! "Eric's Song" is a great match for EdWin...and Royai too. Lol, when I said Vienna Teng was the Arakawa of music, I wasn't joking! wink.gif

EDIT: Oh, awesome! I'm glad I indirectly managed to pull someone into the manga! I have a love/hate relationship with both animes, but the manga is near-perfect IMO. (Of course, all the EdWin moments don't hurt at all.) biggrin.gif
A Pierrot's Aria
@Dearheart I adore the song, too! You also made great choices for the other theme songs with Fix You and Pieces. The lyrics you posted from Pieces are so fitting! They made me tear up just reading them. (I don't think I've ever actually heard the song before! ohmy.gif *Goes to listen*)

And you're right, Vienna Teng seriously is the Arakawa of music!

Talking about EdWin has made me decide it's about time to have an EdWin themed avatar/sig. wub.gif
Sakuyahanabi
A Pierriot's Aria, the pic looks so official! Is it? ohmy.gif I'm sorry if this is a case of 'You-Should-Know-This-Already', I don't usually spend much time in the fandom (but I figured it would be a good way to improve my English a bit)

Btw, now that we're talking about songs that fit EdWin...

I think that 'Morningside' by Sara Bareillies fit their relationship pretty nicely from Winry's POV. tongue.gif
A Pierrot's Aria
@Sakuyahanabi The pic is official! tongue.gif Here's the full pic: wub.gif (And hey, we can't know everything! xP)



And I'll have to take a listen to the song you mentioned! ohmy.gif

@Dearheart I listened to Pieces and I love it!!!
Dearheart
Ahh, that picture melts me into a puddle of happy fangirl goo everytime I look at it... <3333 I listened to that song, Saku; it's very catchy! biggrin.gif

Ooh! I have a PERFECT song for Winry/EdWin! "Sticking With You" by Addison Road:

Come on, it's me you're talking to
There's something going on inside of you
Don't have to say it, but I wish you would
'Cause it would be much easier

You always hide behind yourself
You walk a lonely road with no one's help
I hate to break the news
You're headed for a fall

And if I have to jump, then I'll jump
And I won't look down
You can cry, you can fight
We can scream and shout
I'll push and pull until your walls come down
And you understand I'm gonna be around
I'm sticking with you


Haha, I'm loving all this EdWin-song-swapping. This is fun. biggrin.gif (I'm really glad you liked "Pieces", Pierrot! It's such a wonderful song and hardly anyone knows about it, lol...) BTW, just to give you guys a heads-up, most of the songs I'm sharing are already on my "Sun and Sky" playlist. If you're in the mood for some EdWin goodness, or just awesome music in general, feel free to tune in whenever you want! Every song fits the pairing like a glove and is guarantied to satisfy your inner fangirl. wink.gif
A Pierrot's Aria
@Sakuyahanabi Morningside it a pretty cool song for Winry's POV! biggrin.gif

@Dearheart Wow! That song really is fitting for Winry/EdWin! Winry would love for Ed to finally let his emotions out once in a while, through crying etc.

(Yeah, Pieces is now going on my mp3 player. xP I find it's usually the lesser known songs that are some of the best. laugh.gif)

Funnily enough, the next song I was going to share was If My Heart Was a House by Owl City and amazingly, I see it's already on your playlist! xP That's a great theme song for EdWin! I'd say my reasons for this are pretty much the same as to why I think Harbour by Vienna Teng is a great EdWin theme song. biggrin.gif

Unfortunately, I can't actually listen to your playlist because it's blocked in my country due to licensing restrictions. wacko.gif I would have loved to have listened to it!

Uuuh...there's another song that I think fits EdWin (and also HohoTrisha, come to think of it) but I can't for the life of me remember what it's called. My sister got me to listen to it a while ago, but I never got the chance to save the song. I'll have to ask her about it and report back here. ohmy.gif
Dark-Winds
Oh! I've got some pretty good Edwin songs! But first and foremost, I love the song "Pieces" by Red smile.gif That song has always reminded me of Ed to Winry! Great pick!

Here's a song that reminds me of Winry to Ed: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N5BTOWo_8vc

It's call "Homeless Heart" by Amanda Stott. I think it will be very obvious why this song reminds me of them when you listen to it biggrin.gif

And I've got another one! This also reminds me of Winry to Ed (and even Al! Not romantically of course lol) It's called "It's Me" by Nevertheless. I'll even include one of my favorite Edwin AMVs for you guys to watch with the song: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m28811PkLR0...9707A4D4383B7A2

This song really reminds me of Winry to Ed because no matter where he goes or what he does, she'll always be there waiting for him happy.gif It also shows how she'll always be there for him when ever he needs her.
JPPCouto
Edwin is my favourite anime couple biggrin.gif
Hikarioneza
I love Ed and Winry, they're much more than your typical "childhood friends falling in love" couple (Or, maybe they seem that way at first glance, but because of their history and all what they've been through, it's just ... different with them. If that even makes sense. tongue.gif)

Funnily enough, I only really love their relationship in the manga. I don't really think the the first anime portrayed their bond in the best way, and it most certainly wasn't a relationship I could see working. In Arakawa's original story, however, they have this amazing close bond, built on years of close friendship and trust, something which slowly but surely turned into something more. Its that kind of relationship were you can see that they're so right for each other. Even a relationship you can see lasting forever. I don't usually buy the childhood friends romance thing, because its tend to be done in a very shallow way (at least in other manga/anime I've have seen) but FMA manage to do this in the most realistic way possible. For example, we never see Winry gush about Ed, after she realised her love for him, and I always found that to be very sweet. wub.gif
A Pierrot's Aria
@Dearheart It turns out that I could actually listen the majority of your playlist, after all. Only two or so of them were blocked in my region. That's such an awesome playlist...you have me addicted to these awesome EdxWin songs! wub.gif

@Sakuyahanabi Haha! Ooooh yes, I remember watching that video! laugh.gif

So, guys, I'm wondering here what your favourite EdxWin fanfics are? biggrin.gif

Also, if you have any EdxWin fanfics that you've written that you would like to share with us, that would be completely awesome, too! I'm sure all of us EdxWin fans would love to read it!

Although, remember, if you're going to link a fanfic, don't link anything rated above PG-13!
Dearheart
@Sakuyahanabi - Hahaaa...yep, I've seen that one. It's very OOC, but in a hilarious way. Which was kinda the point, I think. xD Oh Vic, I love you so much... (Gotta say, though, his improvised proposal to Winry (Caitlen) still takes the cake for me!)

(I'm glad most of my playlist worked out for you, Aria! Those songs are pretty addicting, aren't they?) wink.gif Ooohh, favorite EdWin fanfics? I haven't read a whole lot ('cause I'm not brave enough to venture into the FF.net archives anymore, lol!), but I will say...I think one of the greatest EdWin authors in the world is Tobu Ishi. She takes a lot of the blame for my obsession with EdWin. Not only are her stories and ideas wonderful, but she is SUPERB at keeping Ed and Winry in-character and developing them in believable, canon-friendly ways. And based on what little I've seen in EdWin fanfics, that's a rare thing.

Granted, she writes lots of other stuff besides EdWin, but she's brilliant at everything. (As if her english "Bratja" lyrics weren't a big enough testament to that, lol.) I highly recommend her work, especially "EdWin 100 Themes" (WONDERFUL STUFF), "Rosarium" and "Wired".

I do have some EdWin fanfics of my own up my sleeves, but most of them aren't done yet. xD I guess I can share this oneshot, for now: More Than Enough

I've also got these little music drabbles I whipped up recently. I'll go ahead and share them here, since they're so short... tongue.gif (Warning: depressing what-if/character death in this first one!)

---

"Unforgivable Sinner" - Lene Marlin

Swallowing back grief, Al pushes open the door and sees the shadow of what once was his brother, sitting slumped on the floor in a sea of books and alchemic formulas and half-completed (half-hoped) human transmutation circles - maps charted to nowhere to find the missing piece of them that can no longer be found.

"Ed?" He calls his name softly, steps into the study and drops to his knees in front him, silently begging his big brother to look up, to come back him, to remember how to live.

"I never told her," says Edward, in a voice as empty as his eyes. "She waited, and waited, but I never told her and she...she never knew, and now she's gone and it's...too late to say it." A sudden, unexpected wave of pain crashes through the numbness and he chokes on tears that won't come. "She never knew I loved her."

"Brother, it's alright." Alphonse blinks back his own tears and reaches out to squeeze Ed's shoulder in fervent reassurance. "She did know. She did, I promise."

"How do you know?" Edward lifts his head at last. Their eyes meet, and Al manages a rueful smile.

"Because I told her."

~ all the feelings that you hide
gonna tear you up inside
you hope she knows you tried ~



"Blah Blah Blah" - Rockapella

Ed wakes up from a long, deeply satisfying nap and hears Al and Winry snickering from the seat across from him. The train screeches to a noisy halt and he winces. "Didn't need that eardrum, anyway," he grumbles, stifling a yawn and sitting up to stretch his arms. The snickering increases.

"What?" he demands, shooting a suspicious glare at them. Al hastily hides something behind his armored back. Winry just points and giggles even harder. Confused and irritated, Edward turns to look out the window - and sees his own face staring back at him from the glass, covered in big, black, scrawling doodles. The offending marker drops to the floor as Al and Winry collapse against each other in howling laughter, immensely pleased with themselves.

Until Edward picks it up, grinning devilishly, and pulls the cap off with a sinister pop.

"Al?" Winry whispers, inching out of her seat. "Do you think we should run now?"

~ why you wanna go and do me like you do?
why you wanna beat me blue? ~



"Vanilla Twilight" - Owl City

I wish you were here. Edward signs his name at the bottom, carefully folds the letter and slips it in an envelope, along with a picture of him soaked in seawater and grinning broadly next to his latest adventure: a great white shark, three times his size, hanging high and ready for the upcoming feast. He addresses the back of the envelope slowly, as if to savor the destination he's sending it to; then leans back in his chair with a sigh and gazes out at the starry night, and wonders if she's looking up at it too.

A week later, Winry runs to the mailbox as if her life depends on it, yanks it open and fumbles with the contents inside, blue eyes scanning them all over for the one name she yearns to see. A tiny laugh of delight escapes her lips when she finds it; and she hugs the envelope to her chest, just for a moment, before she tears it open to drink in what's inside.

~ 'cause I'll doze off safe and soundly
but I'll miss your arms around me
I'd send a postcard to you, dear
'cause I wish you were here ~



"The Journey" - X-Ray Dog

When he commits the greatest sin,
she will forgive him.

When he suffers the consequences and loses everything he holds dear,
she will give all she has to offer.

When he can't stand on his own,
she will teach him how to walk again.

When he burns down the past in the name of making a future,
she will salvage the memories worth keeping.

When he has no home and no light to pierce the darkness,
she will provide hers.

When he leaves,
she will wait for his return.

When he wavers,
she will hold him steady.

When he won't listen to reason,
she will knock some sense into him.

When he struggles with demons,
she will fight with him.

When he breaks,
she will fix it and forge it stronger.

When he refuses to cry,
she will wash his pain in her own tears.

When he cannot love himself,
she will.

And when he finally conquers the odds,
she will be there to say:
Idiot. Welcome home.
A Pierrot's Aria
@Dearheart Yes, those songs really ARE addicting! xP And yeah, I've read Tobu Ishi's works in the past and I can say easily that she has amazing EdxWin fics! biggrin.gif I too, would recommend, to anyone, her EdWin 100 themes!

And your oneshots are brilliant! I LOVE More Than Enough, because I love EdxWin and Ed and Al brotherly love!! I totally agree that Ed would never pick one over the other. wub.gif I love the interaction between Ed and Winry in your fic, because I'm a huuuuuuge sucker for fluff! blush.gif

And your drabbles are brilliant!! I love the last one especially! wub.gif Each word/sentence is so true for how Ed and Winry work. I can tell easily tell that will be one of the pieces I'll always come back to read again.

To answer my own question....our very own Dearheart's EdWin works are definitely among my list of favourites! biggrin.gif
Tombow
<Program note>

Sakuyahanabi, Dearheart, Dark-Winds, A Pierrot's Aria, Hikarioneza, and allykatty1, I moved the series of EdxWin discussion you guys are having to Thread for EdxWin Fans who had finished reading/watching FMA Manga/FMA:Brotherhood thread so that you don't have to add <Series Final Spoiler Warning!> on your post every time you mention some series final spoiler content. biggrin.gif Please continue this discussion there. biggrin.gif
A Pierrot's Aria
Greetings, fellow EdxWinry fans!

So we all love EdWin and/or Edward and Winry on this thread, and I'm sure they're one of the reasons you love this amazing series so much! So we'd love to see what you can up with to show fellow FMA fans how much you love Fullmetal Alchemist in the run up to FMA day (Oct 3rd)--and this can be done through your favourite characters and/or couples!

We're hosting a "Don't Forget FMA" Event here on the board and we'd love for everyone to take part. You can do this by submitting fanfictions/essays/general prose, AMVs/MMVs/Fan Music and fanart/fanworks/cosplay. The event has already started and ends midnight 3rd October (in your respective time zone.) 3rd October is a very prominent date for us FMA fans, so we'd love to see what you come up with! You can find more info here.

You can also take part in Dearheart's Project Don't forget, which is a fantastic project in which you can share your stories about what FMA means to you/how it has impacted you. Read more info on that here.

We hope to see you participating in the event!
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.