Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Edward & Winry! A.k.a. EdXWin.
Fullmetal Alchemist Discussion Board > Fullmetal Alchemist Discussions > FMA Character Discussions
Pages: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 34, 35, 36, 37, 38, 39, 40, 41
rzerox21xx
One of my deviantart romantic swimsuit requst was done by this awesome artist of edwin


this is her gallery

http://alexisathene.deviantart.com/
A Pierrot's Aria
That's a really great poem, DisasterPiece! I like how you can see hints of how Winry would normally act around Ed (throwing wrenches and such) to her feelings towards him. I love the line, "We laughed, we played, we cried, we laughed again," because it has a sense of nostalgia in it.

And that's a great picture, rzerox21xx!! It's good to see a little swimsuit EdxWin!: )

edxwinryfan
The artwork in that gallery is very well done. biggrin.gif
rzerox21xx
QUOTE (edxwinryfan @ Feb 20 2010, 01:54 PM) *
The artwork in that gallery is very well done. biggrin.gif



yeah she does good work. I'm happy she drew this for me.

this week's episode preview.



when I saw that, I looked back at the manga and I don't see Ed in her bed but in the chair, I wonder what this suppose to add. hehehe. maybe a little anime extra to add to the edwin. that be cool.
essa
It's actually the second time we see ed and winry in a room, with a bed and dim lights xD
There really has to be someone in brotherhood that has a thing for them lol
Lucky us! xD
qaghou
It has been so long before I return on internet and when I finally did it this morning, it was for knowing that my favorite couple is in a difficult situation... This isn't a great new... Why does the writer make everyone die like that ? ... It's so stupid ! I think that it has to have a good reason for doing that ! Not just because she wanted to ! ...
I had almost cry when I saw Winry saying the name of Ed just before she fall down on the ground... You can see how much she try to resist.. But in the end... She looks like dead.? I hope that the situation will change ! Ed have to do something ! Whatever the person who will react, it has to have someone doing something about the situation ! I personnally hate a end like Evangelion or the third book of Eragon !
lunneth
this is pretty cool. funny too. lol.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_kplVYCyBk8
Disasterpiece
I think the series will end on a good note for EdxWin.

Winry's feelings for Ed have been building and buildig. Arakawa can't leave those hanging!
Hagaren_4ever
Good bit of Edwin in the latest episode! wink.gif I waited a long time to see that animated!

shanryelric
episode 46 shipped edwinry everywhere!!!! winry and ed is so perfect together and i was screaming in depression. KISS HER, YPU FOOOOL!!!!!
Animeoldtimer
QUOTE (shanryelric @ Mar 1 2010, 05:28 AM) *
episode 46 shipped edwinry everywhere!!!! winry and ed is so perfect together and i was screaming in depression. KISS HER, YPU FOOOOL!!!!!



That's what I thought when she said she'd do anything to help. he should have just grabbed her and kissed her. laugh.gif
Forsaken Love
grrrrr! I've waited weeks to finish my edwin amv, (needed this weeks ep) and im still delayed cause I can't find an avi without the map XD nuuuuu hope a clean avi will be released soon
Disasterpiece
I was listening to The Speed of Pain by Marilyn Manson, and in a way it sort of seems like an EdxWin song..if you've heard it then you'd agree that the bridge-outro seems to speak true to the pairing.

The last lyrics are "Hope that we die holding hands....always...."

Each time I hear that, I picture either Ed and Winry just in an intimate and sad embrace not wanting the other to let go, or them spending their final moments together one last time.

*sigh* I do want them to end up together... (something's gotta give, this is as canon as canon can get)

They compliment each other. When I think of them together I think of them in the sense that they need one another. That's why I think this pairing is important, they rely on each other. And the song just helps me re-affirm that belief.

Other than that, I just wonder how it will all play out in the end =| As long as Arakawa doesn't pull a fast one and make Ed and Rose hook up or something like that T_T
Dearheart
SQUEEEEEEE!!! Sweet new episode, topped with a heaping healthy dose of EdWin love!!! *lets inner fangirl loose and EATS UP TEH EDWIN GOODNESS WITH A SPOON NOM NOM NOM...* AWESOME episode. They really nailed the EdxWinry moments. *is very very happy* wub.gif

@ Forsaken Love - Heh, you and me both! (Srsly, why did a freakin' earthquake just HAVE to happen during one of the greatest EdWin-ish episodes? Grrr...) dry.gif

@ Disasterpiece - I totally agree that they complement each other. They fill each other's strengths and weaknesses so well and they care very deeply for each other. Too many people look at their relationship and think "oh, she hits him with wrenches and they fight a lot. They must be in love. Whoohoo." And they don't really see the deeper side of it or think of how they've impacted each other. (Which is sad, 'cause they're missing out.)

But personally, I don't think Ed and Winry would be the type to die holding hands. That sounds a bit too melancholy for them; it would fit Royai better. (This is just my opinion, though. Not trying to shoot yours down or anything!) Ed and Winry strike me more as being the kind of people who'd fight to stay alive for each other, no matter what. That's how it's always been for them: she fixes him when he's hurt, sends him off to fight again with renewed strength and waits for his safe return. And he strives to protect her and come home to her in one piece.

Also, while I'm thinking about it, I don't think he would only want to stay with Winry. He'd also want to stay with his brother. The way I've always seen it, Winry and Al are both equal halves of Edward, and it would be impossible for him to choose between which one he loves more, or which he'd rather stay with for eternity.

Bleh, I don't even know if I'm making sense anymore... tongue.gif

EDIT: Having said all that, I do love myself a good dose of EdWin angst. As long as there's a spark of hope in the midst of it, 'cause that's how they roll. A couple songs I think fit perfectly for this are Fix You by Coldplay and Pieces by Red. Both are incredible songs and describe their relationship so well. I've always seen "Fix You" being from Winry's POV and "Pieces" from Ed's POV. wub.gif
Disasterpiece
QUOTE (Dearheart @ Mar 1 2010, 11:24 PM) *
Also, while I'm thinking about it, I don't think he would only want to stay with Winry. He'd also want to stay with his brother. The way I've always seen it, Winry and Al are both equal halves of Edward, and it would be impossible for him to choose between which one he loves more, or which he'd rather stay with for eternity.

Bleh, I don't even know if I'm making sense anymore... tongue.gif


Ughhh I hope it doesn't come to that T_T ...well I DON'T think that issue of who Ed loves more exists...that could actually be an interesting device to foster EdxWin and Winry and Al saying it's ok for him to love other people but to my knowledge I don't think that issue was brought up in the manga (hence it's probably a given that Ed loves Al deeply.) Maybe Arakawa can work around that, or, as I have stated many many many times, that quite possibly, the series might end with the hint that EdxWin may happen anyway.

But honestly, we don't know jack until the series ends T_T

Best case, EdxWin will be left to the fans to write out thru fanfic tongue.gif
Animeoldtimer
Well, I certainly couldn't see her ending it as a love story between Ed and Al. That's incest and just wrong. Just because you love your brother doesn't have to translate into being "in love." We are all capable of loving our significant others one way and our relatives another. There are four kinds of love after all! I can't see why Al is being left in the dark if Ed does end up in love with Winry. Al does have Mei as well.

I do think their (Ed & Winry) future will be left open to interpretation though.
Dearheart
QUOTE (Animeoldtimer @ Mar 3 2010, 01:14 AM) *
Well, I certainly couldn't see her ending it as a love story between Ed and Al. That's incest and just wrong. Just because you love your brother doesn't have to translate into being "in love."


EWW!! *shudders* No no no, that's NOT what I was talking about at all. Ed and Al love each other deeply, but not like THAT. Ick...

Like I said, Al and Winry are equal halves of Edward, but in DIFFERENT WAYS. I hope nobody got confused by that... xD

And yes, Al definitely has Mei. It's probably just puppy love/friendship right now, but I can easily see it growing deeper as they both get older. And it works perfectly! Al ships EdWin, and Winry ships AlMei, and Ed ships...well, he's too in denial and busy saving the world to know what he ships. biggrin.gif
Katya Martin
Going briefly off topic... that first one is the Official Al Shipperface IMO. xD

I think the brothers will stay close, but I don't think that closeness will get in the way. They're getting more used to being separated, but I think they'll stick together to an extent; I think they'll end up living next door to each other or something. Ed and Winry's kids will have a great time pestering their Uncle Al. Lol.
Animeoldtimer
QUOTE (Dearheart @ Mar 3 2010, 01:02 AM) *
EWW!! *shudders* No no no, that's NOT what I was talking about at all. Ed and Al love each other deeply, but not like THAT. Ick...

Like I said, Al and Winry are equal halves of Edward, but in DIFFERENT WAYS. I hope nobody got confused by that... xD



Yeaaaah! Glad to see someone who has the right reaction to the idea of Ed and Al as a couple. I agree with the rest of your comment.
Katya Martin
Some sort of vague relevance: The following comparison is pretty amazing.

Well well, hagane no chibi-san grew.
KwiatekAlchemist
^

WOW! that's amazing o_o
they both grew up so much. (LOL @ how little Ed used to be)
Now that Ed is taller than Winry,
they should definitely kiss. (:

Katya Martin
The difference in faces is pretty startling, too.
mellulah
I don't want to sound like that relative you haven't seen for a while but, 'My Ed and Winry haven't you grown!'


mellulah - Moved your post and removed the image as it's already been posted. Chi
deet-tastic
O.O

W-whoa.WHOA.

That's amazing. Obviously the changes in Ed are huge, but even Winry..
Thank you for making that.
Disasterpiece
They'll kiss. Somehow.

Here's how I'd envision it.

Ed's napping or something, Winry walks over, etc etc, places a kiss on his cheek, Ed wakes up minutes later sayinfg he had a dream an angel kissed her. And sees Winry and deduces that she kissed him.

Humor ensues, series ends.
A Pierrot's Aria
Wow! Thank you for posting those Katya Martin! I agree, the differences are really startling! Ed's clearly got a much more angular and muscular physique (as well being finally taller.) xD Winry's definitely looking more womanly too. : )
Broken Chouchou
Whoa, they both look like a couple of twelve year olds! ohmy.gif The difference is so striking that it makes you think you should have reacted even back then to how kiddish they looked. Which I have no memory of doing XD Guess that frame is an extreme example, though.
Disasterpiece
They look more defined now

And grown up smile.gif

Reminds me of http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RCD14IrOcIs =]
Forsaken Love
omg, Ed in particular...what a growth spurt XD haha, looks like he went through the whole of puberty in a year (or however long a period of time that was) not to mention his hair also grew quite a lot XD also a gift for edwin fans but mainly a very late bday pressie to XD kkg22104 (why does your forum name have to be so unusual can never remember it) http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z0Y7ewf__ho finally finished it =3
Kyelinn
N'awwwww that was so cute, Forsaken! It really brightened my day, and it really does fit Ed and Winry very well. <3
Disasterpiece
(im BeyondLame, one of the commenters)

you really did inspire me to make amvs again

all i need is Sony Vegas


I plan to write a fanfic about them in about a month or so. I'm deciding whether it should be after COS or depending how the manga ends.Most likely it would be after COS due to how I'd make the character development between the two flow (and their chemistry)

What I want to do (and this is what truly captivates me about the couple) capture how, as I've stated in other posts, how the compliment each other, how they rely and need each other.

A tale of angst, unearthed feelings, need, and love
mandymtt
Doing an edwin 100fanart challenge. Heres the first one im working on. Sorry for the watermarks. They are not finished and I am worried about theft- but i want to share...

this is EDWIN: 100 "home"


I am paying om-age to when they are in briggs and she tunes his automail. I like that a lot. He's going to have another bubble going on about "how about that pie I asked for" ... or something... bleh
A Pierrot's Aria
Looks fantastic so far, mandymtt! I love the idea, it's so cute! : ) I really like your colouring style- especially the highlights!
mandymtt
QUOTE (A Pierrot's Aria @ Mar 8 2010, 02:02 AM) *
Looks fantastic so far, mandymtt! I love the idea, it's so cute! : ) I really like your colouring style- especially the highlights!

thank you smile.gif I have so much more to do. between school i get like a few min a week to touch it. Spring break is coming. It will be done. I swear lol.
Disasterpiece
he reminds me of Greedlin D=

but a good pic nontheless!
Causmicfire
madnymtt - Nice piece, I really love the way you emphasized the little tug on her hair in the corner and the coloring is beautiful.

Messy Beginnings: Set post manga. Winry's not at all happy when Ed's nowhere to be found the day before they're set to leave to Xing on vacation(EdxWin with hints of AlxMay. Only the first chapter of this collection is EdWin).

Hold You Close - Sometimes anniversaries suck, the rest of the time they're not bad. Set post manga/Brotherhood, spoilers if you're not up to date with Brotherhood subs or Viz release of the manga. (Overall EdxWin but with a bit of AlxWin and AlxMay and warning for character death)
kkg22104
QUOTE (Forsaken Love @ Mar 5 2010, 11:03 AM) *
omg, Ed in particular...what a growth spurt XD haha, looks like he went through the whole of puberty in a year (or however long a period of time that was) not to mention his hair also grew quite a lot XD also a gift for edwin fans but mainly a very late bday pressie to XD kkg22104 (why does your forum name have to be so unusual can never remember it) http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z0Y7ewf__ho finally finished it =3


Yay, thank you so much Rin-chan ^^ *hug* I really enjoyed it biggrin.gif
rzerox21xx
Japanese fanart from this blog.
http://moomiso.blog60.fc2.com/blog-date-201003.html

formal


wedding


ch 84, ep 46


school

some fan-made figures I guess

SneakyRuler
Love the first picture! Both Ed and Winry look elegant and undeniably themselves!
Kuji
Hi smile.gif

I'm slowly getting around to posting more around here, so I thought for starters I'd share something with my fellow EdWin fans. (^^
Sorry if this has been posted before/is old! I actually found this pic a few weeks ago at 2ch (RoiRiza fans will like it too, most likely~)
The poster commented about it, and IIRC said something like, this was drawn by another anime staff member, who drew it for a member of Hagaren's anime staff who got married.

Awesome, is it not?! The EdWin fan within me geeked out upon seeing this lol... Enjoy!

Click to view attachment

Oh btw, thought I'd just mention while I'm at it, I've drawn some EdWin pictures myself, which can be found in my Hagaren gallery folder @ Deviantart here. I hope you like them smile.gif
Disasterpiece
Mustang looks like Archer .___. laugh.gif

but love the wedding pic overall smile.gif
rzerox21xx
QUOTE (Kuji @ Mar 27 2010, 03:24 AM) *
Hi smile.gif

I'm slowly getting around to posting more around here, so I thought for starters I'd share something with my fellow EdWin fans. (^^
Sorry if this has been posted before/is old! I actually found this pic a few weeks ago at 2ch (RoiRiza fans will like it too, most likely~)
The poster commented about it, and IIRC said something like, this was drawn by another anime staff member, who drew it for a member of Hagaren's anime staff who got married.

Awesome, is it not?! The EdWin fan within me geeked out upon seeing this lol... Enjoy!

Click to view attachment

Oh btw, thought I'd just mention while I'm at it, I've drawn some EdWin pictures myself, which can be found in my Hagaren gallery folder @ Deviantart here. I hope you like them smile.gif



anime staff for bortherhood or first series, looks like brotherhood staff by the way the character look especially Ed's head. Can I post this on both Edwin and Royai livejournal. If you don't mind, can you give me the image link. I'm a big fan of your work. I have the kiss meme and mistletoe kiss as my favorites adn you are on my watch. You might remember me as the guy who asked for Edwin swimsuit beach fanart to you and other artists lol. I'm a sucker for seeing Winry in a bikini.
shanryelric
*SCREAMS*
DAMN!! that is SOO AWESOME!!! wawawawawaawawa EDWIIIIN~~
Kuji
^That was pretty much my initial reaction too heheh (well close enough) XD

QUOTE (rzerox21xx @ Mar 28 2010, 03:45 AM) *
anime staff for bortherhood or first series, looks like brotherhood staff by the way the character look especially Ed's head. Can I post this on both Edwin and Royai livejournal. If you don't mind, can you give me the image link. I'm a big fan of your work. I have the kiss meme and mistletoe kiss as my favorites adn you are on my watch. You might remember me as the guy who asked for Edwin swimsuit beach fanart to you and other artists lol. I'm a sucker for seeing Winry in a bikini.

Oh hi! Yes, your name rings a bell - Thank you for the support at Deviantart! smile.gif

The picture - I don't have a link to the thread @ 2ch (A Japanese forum), let alone remember what post it was, sorry.
What you could do though, is save the picture that I've attached, and re-upload it to an image hosting website perhaps?
As for who specifically drew the picture, the original comment the poster wrote IIRC was a bit ambiguous, so I'm not sure whether the one who drew it was a part of the staff for the first series or not.
When I first saw it, I thought it looked more similar to the manga style. Regardless, it's a very, very nice picture, one that I'm sure any EdWin and RoiRiza fan would enjoy ;p
Chiyo
I think a small part of me just exploded with delight. When it looks so official it's just that bit easier to believe it may just happen! Thank-you for sharing that.
rzerox21xx
to add more validility on the marriage pic, I asked Amber of deviantart(her sources are very reliable and proven true concerning news on brotherhood and what is the staff and director doing. ) about the pic and this is what she has to say.

I read the story this pic was drawn by the anime staff in Japanese domestic huge BBS, and I actually saw this pic in it.
I hardly remember in detail, but I seem that was not the anime staff's marriage but one of staff who took charge of character songs.
This pic seem to have been uploaded in the blog of character song's producer.
I don't know more than that.
Winry Rockbell~
Wow, that marriage pic is great! Goodness, FMA Brotherhood ships Edwinry soooooo much! I prefer them 100x more than the first anime producers. If only their art and animation could get a little bit better...ahh well, no one's perfect.
A Pierrot's Aria
Love the pic, it's beautiful! biggrin.gif I really envy how neat the lineart looks! It was a nice gesture on part of the team! I would have loved to recieve such a present!

(^And I have to disagree with the previous comment...Art and animation are both superior in the Brotherhood, in my opinion. biggrin.gif Sure, there are a few slip ups, but there was in the first anime too, and most other anime in fact. xD But best not carry this on because I don't want to end up causing some off topic row! xD)

EDIT: I've replied to you by PM Winry Rockbell~ so we won't go off topic. : )
Winry Rockbell~
QUOTE (A Pierrot's Aria @ Mar 28 2010, 08:33 AM) *
Love the pic, it's beautiful! biggrin.gif I really envy how neat the lineart looks! It was a nice gesture on part of the team! I would have loved to recieve such a present!

(^And I have to disagree with the previous comment...Art and animation are both superior in the Brotherhood, in my opinion. biggrin.gif Sure, there are a few slip ups, but there was in the first anime too, and most other anime in fact. xD But best not carry this on because I don't want to end up causing some off topic row! xD)


True. But then, again, I am a ....ty artist and a crazy perfectionist, so I guess I can't talk.
rzerox21xx


anyone know how to make a more clear shaprer version of this?
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.