How do you know anyway? I shouldn't even respond to your post! It is exactly like these all 'I want the RoseXEd thing to happen'!

I know it's paper! I'm not stupid, I just have a scietific mind so
EVERYTHING gets annalized by Psycology in my
head without thinking.
Ed isn't gay, but no one can be 100% sure on
their sexuality (just because your straight or
gay doesn't mean you refuse the same or oposing sex completely).
I posted it as a fun thing,
A little scientific view for the fans to read.
RoyxEd may not happen in hte anime/manga but
that's what FAN FICTION is for!
It's this wonderful little place where anything can happen!

I don't Rose, Doesn't mean I hate her and want her to "die".
I don't have to ask Ms. Arakawa anything,
I just admire and apreshiate her work!
I don't really care of EdWin ever happens or
if Ed doesn't like Winry at all,
The whole point of going into an anime world is to
not realize that real life sucks in general
(war, ect.) and that I know it's pure fantacy,
when has fantacy stopped humans from haveing fun?
Without it there'd be no anime, manga, stories, movies,
any of it! It would all be "This is real and the truth"
and Life would suck big time, I hate reality,
FMA is much better.

My whole Point was this:
It was for fun.
Dr.Freud died long before FMA was ever wrote!
Dr.Carter, Who is a Psycological Scientist, only read it because of his 13 yr old daughter who is half Japanese loved it. (<--He is my Sensai of Science & Philiosophy)
Prf. Markerter answered a curiosity question that I asked.
The post was only a "Hey, Ever wonder this?"
kind of thing not a "Serius and proven reality" thing.

Lighten up a bit, relax and have fun, besides,
"What is the point of life if we have to die in the ground not in the sky?" - The Great Gizmoe.
Heaven is a fantacy till you reach it, no?

Eliss, I didn't say you were stupid! I'd never say that! I actually answered to Aog who replies with really poor arguments!
I like psychology and all that is relied to it too! The only thing I was trying to say is that Arakawa sensei can surprise us at any moments! She did it so many times already!
Of course, fanfictions are great too! It means we can put our dreams on paper!
You even have the same view of anime than me! Anime is here so we can get away from the very harsh reality!

I wrote it that way because some people will never get it otherwise.
I called myself stupid, don't worry about it!

Big shocker would be to end it with a wedding but not have it be anyone we thought of putting together....And I've heard some wierd ones!

Loves to all!

Ps-dear Eliss_Music, stop posting after every post! It's bad for you!
signed,Eliss.

Hum, Yes! Who knows! Arakawa sensei is perfectly able to do something like this!

Ps= I should wrote the same PS for me too!

[quote=eliss_music,Aug 26 2005, 11:10 PM]
[quote=Summerlover01,Aug 26 2005, 05:17 PM]
Whole point is: Psycology states that he is a restless insestual who is most likely gay but social views make him belive he is straight.
[/quote]

lol. Best Quote EVER!
Anyway I guess I'll add my piece of knowledge to the topic (which isnt that much really but it makes sense) I cant remember exactly where I heard this from (it couldve been from this very topic who knows) It states the guys dont even think about settling down or starting a family until they are around the age of thier second or third year of collage(sp?). Yeppers thats all I gotta say.

[QUOTE]It states the guys dont even think about settling down or starting a family until they are around the age of thier second or third year of collage(sp?).

I dont know we sould prove this but I could think of a way.
But wait this just came to me.
How can any of us prove any of this crap were talking about anyway.

yeah true, in the end all we really know is that winry is in love with Edward. That's enough for me. So is ed's awkward behaviour around her

Well we all have to belive in something.

Ummm excuse me but go die now!

DUH! OMFG ISH THAT TRUE!!!!1111!! YA MUS BE SO INTELLIZENT!!!

REAL: Ahem, Don't triple post, don't spam. I sincerely hope my actual language is not foreign to you and that your intellectual capacities don't only allow you to understand the line above, thank you!

EDIT: Ah yes, and follow Saturn's instruction! I'm sure it'll be better for everyone!

Yeah die, go to hell and die.

wow. someone needs to read the rules. PLEASE DONT BECOME A NOOB! I SAY THIS TO PROTECT YOU!


^^;

It is nice for him/her, Random! but I think he/she already became one! We can't save him/her anymore!

It is posibale but very hard.

we really shouldn't be so hard but that person went to far when they posted with mindless crap like 'I like cheese' seriously my patience with n00bs is wearing very thin

Mine too.

Mine is thin too, Saturn! Just go read the AlXWinry thread by I LOVE Edward! I don't think you'll find someone worse than her!

I know... I have already rolled my eyes 50 times over that stupid topic. Al is seventeen? and Winry confessed her love? The hell>?

Hum, yeah! She even posted another thread to know if someone confessed his/her love in the movie! Next time, she'll post one saying "O MY GOSH! ENVY IS IN LUV WITH HOENHEIM AND ED IS A NAZI!"

She gave me a headache

Back on topic: I don't know if this had already been discussed but, since EdWin fans (and I'm slightly starting to like it too, curse you Saturn!) are allowed to imagine what happens after the movie, maybe Ed will meet an Alter!Winry? (Even if this Noah girl is really suspicious! <___<)

Yeah, i really doubt that Ed future he will meet a Alter Winry.

Sorry, you said?

Well, Everyone in Amestris certainly has an Alter in the other world so Winry must have one too! Though, maybe she can be different compared to the Amestris!Winry!

If there is an alter Winry, wouldnt there be an alter Ed. So wouldnt alter Ed be with alter Winry? And non alter Ed would be without (hopefully not forever!) non alter Winry?
wow, I said alter at least 6 times XD

Hey Aog, Love ya lots hun but please realize that it's only personal if you provok them. Other wise, lets just chill and talk like normal fans. Do normal fans exist? I'm saddly noticing a puss towards fangirl on my behalf. Note to self : Fangirl self bad!

QUOTE(Random Person @ Aug 29 2005, 04:21 PM)

If there is an alter Winry, wouldnt there be an alter Ed. So wouldnt alter Ed be with alter Winry? And non alter Ed would be without (hopefully not forever!) non alter Winry?
wow, I said alter at least 6 times XD

[snapback]267426[/snapback]

Alter-metor! lol, sorry. Joke on Like-a-metor.

I have no clue about the alter thing you speak of but I read a story
about Ed (late 20's or older, like eary 30s) was married, had no children and it wasn't anyone we knew.
Theres very little dialog, it's mostly 'picture drawing' or for the simple people lots of descriptions.

My thing is that everyone has equals in this world.
One for love, hate, compainionship, oposing force, enemy, loyal, name it and it's got an oposite.
[STORY DESRIPTION] I'll try to post both these storys, I just need permission.

Ed was the leave before sun up come back around sundown,
lived far away from everything but close to Eastern HQ
(Mrs. Armstrong [Sparkle's Mom] drove him home everyday,
he'd walk in the mornings),
and the whole theme was from her view.
She spent the day doing chores and remembering how they met,
which was on a train rigged to explode.
By the End before he comes home she finds a picture of Winry,
Pinako,Al, Central military Crew and Al's wife
who strangly resimbled a younger and more pants wearing Lust.
She found a paper sticking out the back that said
"If I ever once lost the most, It was her."
That's where it pretty much ends.
She finds out that he did have feelings
(wether love or friendship, maybe family) but he married her instead.
(this was before Winry dies)
An add on leter was Her at Winry's grave.
She aperently died in (human) Al's arms,
Ed wasn't even near there and didn't find out for over a year.

Sorry if i keep discribing storys, I just know them so well.
*I'm cute, forgive me!*

Dont worry Eliss_music we forgive you.

Hahaha sin! I know EdxWin is so addictive. But so is Edxenvy! I read this awesome fic about that too and I will send it to you.

Only ed and win are a little more plausible now since envy is dead

Holy crap! Im having a huge case of deja vue. I couldve sworn I read this exact same post 5 times.

Anywho back to topic, well sorta: Is there an alter Ed, cuz i can seriously(sp) see Ed meeting alter Ed and alter Winry married or dating or something. Then Ed would be like wtf? I miss Winry now *sobs*.

rose and ed would be cute but in the end of the show rose has a baby!!!! *whos ur daddy XD*?????

Awwwwwwgh. *cuddles teddly bear and pouts*

Saturn: Yes, my fav character is dead! T__T

[SPOILER]But he achieved his goal: To Kill Hoenheim! HAHAHAHAHA!!!...Ahem...[/SPOILER]

For EdWin, yes I'm starting to to like it because I'm starting to like Winry too...Maybe I'm falling in love with Winry! I can't wait to read the fic you're talking about, Saturn!

Random: Actually

[SPOILER]Yes, there is an Alter!Ed who is (coincidence?) Alphonse Heiderich's brother! Heiderich, in the movie, is, like Ed, looking for his brother but he never finds him at the end since he dies by the hand of (this bitch!) Dietlinde Eckart! So where is the Alter!Ed? Is he dead? Why did he disappear? Maybe he even crossed the Gate? But How? Argh!!!! So much questions! I personnally think he's dead because when Dante made Ed cross the Gate at the end of the serie, he found himself in another boy's body that looked just like him but with short hair! I guess it was the Alter!Ed but he died just after his talk with Hoenheim and that death made the soul of the Amestris!Ed cross the Gate again and return in his own and real body![/SPOILER]

Eliss: ARGHH!!! Now that you talked about your fic, I want to talk about mine too!
It's funny because I'm thinking of doing an Ed/Envy/Winry love triangle! ( Yes! Winry in love with Envy! I know I'm crazy! T__T)

Thanks for the info!

ahaha sin! Let me know wbout your fic okay! I want to read that! Looks like it will be good stuff.

The fic I am talking about with edxenvy is called "The Pact" and is on adult fanfiction by someone named "Chiruken" I think...

Theres an adult fanfiction site?
*shouts* I'll go read that!

Sin Luxuria : OOH! I wanna read! *bounces off the walls*

Zyric: *grabs tedy bear and cuddles next to you* See? I got my bear too!

Random person: Three words for You!
VUE JA DA! The felling you've Never been here before! bwhahahaha!
I'm hyper. Ed would cry if Winry got married!
A fic my friend is writing is about Winry's wedding to Havoc ( )
and Ed did the tears everywhere thing and disrupted the wedding by
talking to winry in the middle of service.
He finaly tells her and...Should I spoil this one or post it?
*Sly grin, looks around*
*yells* LOVES!

wow. Ed crying durning a wedding. Now thats' something. You people got me into the mood to make a fanfic now. Farewell Im off to make a plot!

good luck! Edxwin love!

You guys wanna read that story? It's funny.

I have my fingers crossed for Ed and Winry. But if it doesn't happen it's not the end of the world. Yet, Ed also seems the type that would not want to get together with anyone. More of a...no, he seems more of the person to fly solo. I'd love it if they got together but what would it be like? I can't seem to picture that.

::notices thread turned to more of an EdxWin fanfic discussion:: I'll be sure to check out some of your fanfics!!

If anyone want to see, i made a doujin call "The Day at School"
, it a EdxWin doujin. It also contain other pairing but the story will
be different from FMA. ^.^;;

Saturn: Yep, I know that fic and I'm sorta waiting for the...Lemon! It's off topic since we're talking about EnvyXEd and we should talk about EdWin instead, but did you read the fic Cut Me Off by WingedBonnie on FF.net! God, it's an AU but it's really good stuff! *___*

Random: You're welcome! And good luck for your fic!

Eliss: Ed? Crying during a wedding? It's a bit OOC because I think Ed would more express the feelings he has for Winry by anger and jealousy!

Oinchinjey: Ooh! cool! A doujin! It's AU, isn't it? Hehe, Ed and Winry at school! I'm sure it'll be interesting!

w00t, 503.

*scuttles away*

??? What is this?

Yes, but it was a last straw, no more life lines kinda thing.
he had his anger and jealousy time, now it's
"I'm too late" and "Why me" syndrom stuff.

It wasn't sad tears or happy tears, it's those tears of "why me"
peopel get when it's the end of the line sorta thing.

My friend made me a funny picture!
It's the hello kittie one, but they have words.

He also drew a flash of Winry giving birth and Ed was freaked out because he was watching but the baby looks like a chibi armstrong and hit's him with a wrench, right after coming out! Theres no link, but he one first place in comedy for fan film!

The title says Ed and WInry, nothing about not talking about EdWin stuff. As long as 90% is EdWin, I don't see any problem.
Forgive me, I (strangely) get hyper when I haven't eaten!
Loves!

Ps-Sheska, Nice avatar, have any more pics of her?

Why would Ed cry for anything other than his guilt, his brother/mum, maybe rockbell's death or some tragedy. Certainly not during a wedding.

Wow, Saturn, you wrote a EdxEnvy fic? Most of the time you write Edwin, so didn't think that was possible

Anyways, I believe alter Ed has long since died. Whatever happens after the conclusion of the movie is left to your imagination, but I can assure everyone that unless it is officially shown in another movie/OVA/second FMA series, Ed will never ever get together with Winry, or maybe even alter winry (supposing he is alive and kicking to be make it into that stage of "getting together" with anyone). End of Story.

More to expect from the manga, hopefully, else I will be sorely disappointed.

no I didn't write an edxenvy fic, but trust me, it's floating around in my mind.

At the moment I'm working on a edxwin smut. It's going to be too hardcore to post on here... basically it's an experimentation fic. It all starts with this erotic book Winry receives from her friend. It spirs Ideas! I will be posting it on my livejournal account so if anyone isn't immature and can read smut, your welcome to the link. Just let me know

What is your LJ screen name so I can friend you? Mines is Nightmistress85

problaby, but i dont konw ed is so crazy, you think that if could work????

I'm saturnstars

It wont be up yet, but it will soon!

XD GO EDxWIN!!!

yaeh!

(Anywayz... I don't think it's gonna happen. And not just because I like RoyxEd XD This relationship may be hinted at, but... nah. It's the same with Roy and Riza (it was Evil Genius who translated it Liza), I think. They do have potential, maybe, but... gah gah gah, I don't have any reasons OK?! I just don't think it's going to happen. It's either all gonna be one-sided or they'll never act on their feelings. Huff.)



yeah but i think riza/roy have a better chance ed/win are like bro and sis mostly