[QUOTE]conflick
Its actuly conflict

*thinks about the guys at her school* yeah that sounds about right. 16, heh heh Ed is the same age as me! Wee! Maybe if we beg the FMA movie making people (im horrible with names) they'll make a second movie focusing on EDXWIN stuff... Unless something already happened in the movie. (havent seen it yet, but heard rumors)

Maybe if we beg the FMA movie making people (im horrible with names) they'll make a second movie focusing on EDXWIN stuff... Unless something already happened in the movie.
-------------------------------------------
Or *happy dance*
We get a fan made Ainime Of EdWin!
I saw one once of Riza and Ed,
funny thing actuly...
Riza , in a hotel room, holds ed at gun point ot take his cloths off and he's kinda like thinking "No way!" Then before he says anything he is thinking "Well, can't hurt!" and she has the gun the whole time time Ed finaly gets it away from her and then he's all standing there naked witht the gun congradulating himself on getting Riza's gun (an impossible feat) and Winry walks in, sees Ed naked and busts up laghing thus destroying whatever manhood he had!
It was too funny! Hm, I'll try to find it again!
There's 3 versions. The winry one, and Roy (Same only Roy walks in and asks Riza wheres his piece, thus angering Riza), and one where Al walks in and says "Winry's not going to like this." and Ed yells at him and chases him down the hall.
I'll shut up from being hyper and go find them...I hope.
Bye!
_---------------------------------------------
EdWin hentai isn't hard to find...neither is RoyxEd hentai for that matter.

OMG tell when you do that sounds great! Seriously though If they dont at least do something in the manga I'll cry

I like winry and ed having a sister/brother relationship rather than a boyfriend/girlfriend one. I think the friendship w/al and winry would change too if ed and winry had a romantic relationship

ahhhh! idk part of me wants them to become a couple! im just gonna wait and see

Yea, Al's friendship with Winry probably would change if Ed and Winry started a relationship. He would probably start treating Winry like a sister rather than a best friend, or he would feel awkward, or he would say "FINALLY." and run off with some cats. ....I think I'll wait for the manga and see. x3

I lost hope in the anime/movie for an Edwin relationship. u.u; Well, I didn't lose it, I just put the rest of it into the manga. XD Since there's so many hints and stuff. <3

Al would run off with some cats?
Ok, but your are correct that Al would see Winry differntly.
If Al and Ed weren't bros I'd say 3 sum, but they are so no.
Easy way to clear one thing up...FIND AL A CHICK! A cat lover perhaps.
Ooh! fan fic idea! I've been toying with one for Al but I just got the perfect idea!
Al, in armor meets a girl who doesn't care if he has flesh or not, she loves him uncondisionly! Ed changes Al, Who saddly forgets, Then ....I'll go write this down!
This is better then trying to write a Scar/Winry kiss sceen where Ed's not trying to kill anyone.
bye!

What eliss_music ment that Ed dosnt love like Hughes.

Where'd this come from?
Huges is an outgoing guy who shows everyone his love of his family.
Were you saying that Ed doesn't show his love the same way?
If so, and this is just a theory, that Ed had kids (doesn't matter the mom! Just not Envy... ) He'd show (no in pictures <3) that he loves his kids!
Ed has a whole big family issuse anyway...
Dad scramed, Mom died, Al almost died, He doesn't want to pull Winry into this (Thanks Berry the Copper..loser.) and sorts of stuff!
He'd rather live alone on a island then potentaily put everyone he loves in danger....No a bad reason but he goes out of his way to try this...bad idea.
ok, I'm done for now!
ps-Sorry Aog, My dyslexia wouldn't let me read you sentence correctly.
Loves anyway!

He doesnt brag about all that crap and stuff.

Ha! I think ed could be like hughes if he got married and had children ! AHAHA high ranking milliatary officer who is physco all over again

I just joined the forums so I guess I'm a little late replying to this topic but anyways...

Well if the writers decide to get dumb and completely change Ed's character, then they'll do that. But if FMA was real life (who said it isn't xDDD) and Ed and Al and everyone were real I don't think Ed would go out or anything with Winry.

Besides, he's mine xDDD

yeah, i don't think that either. heh, oh well. For some odd reason I've always thought of Ed and Rose.

Its not THAT ood Karo. I can see that too. Even though I don't exactly want to. But I like that better than EdxWin

Ha Ha! Hughes, Part 2!-Hughes newly found sidekick totures military personal in the stalls! No one is safe, I repeat, No one is safe. (physco and Jaws music in the background).
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
ED-"WTF?"
RP(me)-"Oh dont tell me you didnt see that coming!"
ED-"Hughes Part 2?"
RP- "hmmm, not the best of titles is it? Heh heh."
ED- "You're an idiot."
RP- "WHO ARE YOU CALLING AN IDIOT THAT CANT COME UP WITH A GOOD TITLE FOR SOME RANDOM PARAGRAPH THAT POPPED IN HER HEAD!
ED-"you"
RP- "oh...Okay"
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Okay, I'll shut up now. (EDxWIN all da way!)

Hmm...wow, my first post ever. Well, at least I'd be able to make it in a 503 chat xD Hello! I'm new to the forums and I just wanted to stop by, mainly because I've been reading this for a while.

I, personally, love Ed x Winry. Arakawa handles it surprisingly well and I admire her for that. Ed and Winry's interactions (many of them gut-busting funny) are very sweet. Although it is debatable among fans, it is quite apparent that Winry loves Ed more than Al. She treats Al more like a sibling than anything else and, if one were to take the time to notice it, she treats Edward differently.

Winry understands what Ed and Al have to do. Even though she constantly worries her head off about them, she doesn't want to hold them back and does her best to help them whenever they need it. Edward's a bit slow when it comes to Winry's feelings, but they understand each other none the less. Ed needs a girl who can understand his very unique personality, traits, habits, etc and who better than Winry?

It's practically canon in the manga. One side has already admitted her feelings; we just need the other, more thickheaded side to realize his. Which, for the sake of the escalating plot, will take a long while.

Eh, I've practically repeated what you all said. But, hey. I wanted to write it out myself xD It's nice to meet you all.

Hey, Kanki, welcome to the forums! Nice avatar. Makes 'Up Where We Belong' play in my head *hums*

The idea of Hughes!Ed pestering Roy makes me happy x3 With his hands all bandaged up and put in braces because Winry smooshed 'em good during labour (omgmore automail).

Hey there Kanki Good to see some well-written and intelligent posts on Edwin.

Edward and Winry?, Will they ever fall in love?


Answer: SUPER DUPER MARVELOUS FANTASTIC GREAT NICE BETTER DISASTERRIFIC! I hope ED DOESNT COMPLAIN!!!!!!

No offence but I don't think anyone is going to listen to you not being all for edxwin when you are stupid enough to think a cartoon character is yours. They like eachother deal with it.

Oooh harsh .... but I agree with the bottom line - Ed's fictional and is therefore intangible. He is a product of people's imagination and his actions/feelings will be a result of Arakawa's will put down on paper.

no,never.

I still whant my EdxRose thing to happen.

As I said, the most EdxRose you're gonna get is fanfiction. So deal with it and stop making a new post every couple of pages about it. You said you wanted EdRose a week ago. We get it. Stop spamming.

WOWZ REALLY LYKE OMG?


Go to the EdxRose topic. I'm pretty sure there is a thread.

Thanks for the info.

Aog, You came to an EdWin Topic to suport Rose...Not too bright, no offence.

Ed wouldn't go psyco nuts like the absolutly hot Huges (Can't help it, I have a thing for older guys ) But he would be proud of his offsping nonetheless.
reason why: Dad- vanished, Mom- died when boys were young.
Pinako- beat him senceless if he aboandoned his kids, regardless of the mother! (Go Pinako!)
Add Winry to this formula and get this :
Ed would be proud of his kids because he'd honestly love them, Winry too.
If they showed talent in alchmey..he'd bost (Who wouldn't ). Winry, who lost her parents at a young age also, would love her kids and not want to leave them out of fear of not coming back to them (psycolodgicly speaking).
They'd know alchemy and engineering (not a bad combo at all) plus...
they'd be soo cute! Rose has a habbit of *pause* haveing ugly kids. Rose lovers, sorry.
Girls open them selves to the ones they love, guys bottle it up and let it boil over inside till the cork pops (relativly speaking.) and Ed's just not there yet.
I say (screw what the movie says) that by age 20-ish or so, He'd say something to her about it.
Ed and Winry are the couple that (unlike a joke previously posted) wouldn't pop a kid a year (maybe, but mostly no... ) but they type of couple that the two of them can sit stareing into a sunset curled up in each others arms and say nothing at all, but have everything said in that moment. tell me that's not special.

Al will find a girl (probly milly, Molly,...?!... what's her name from down the street in Resembool [?]) one day but till then he'll have to deal with it. Besides, Ed's working on it thus pushing Winry away.

Reminds me, I had a story in the works that inspired another one....A What if story....
"What if it never happened...." I'll be working on it for a bit but I'll post it in my fics, I promise!

EdWin is logical, Ed x anyone else is ilogical (sp?), EdxRoy/ EdxEnvy is just funny and well.....EdxElysia was too cute! Wrong in so many ways but cute.
EdxRiza keeps poping into my skull but it's more Post EdxRiza, like they had a moment or three (heehee, I mean Hi!) and they either A-get tense around each other or B-She gets protective (more mom like then anything) over him (normal for al) while she is still majorly protective of Roy.
Hm, I'm a writter, I can't help it. *Enjoys RizaxRoy kiss picture in mind*

EdWin 100%!

I know people may say edxwin doens't work, but Ed with anyone else is just out of the question... at this stage in his life anyway. Unless there is some chick on the side we never see in the anime and manga then it's Winry 100 %

I liked your description of their coupley ways it is so true. I was only joking about physco Ed with his children but I really do think he would be proud

oh. I took that seriously XD! Anywho, I hope something good happens in the manga between them. I hope Ed finally understands how he feels about her in the next chapter. (judging by where he's at I'd say he'll have some thinking time while trying to get out. )

I disagree about EdxRose. IT COULD EdxWinry. because there are child hood friends and there are alwys together.

Issue: Ed x Winry = Childhood friends

Answer: Nothing wrong with that. I think it's the best kind of love really. From what I've seen of the Japanese, they're big on childhood friends going into lovers I said it before, usually, if there is a boy and a girl who have been childhood friends, 70% of the time, they'll like each other more in some way ^ ^ So really, for me, Edwin had always been the default relationship.... especially since she appears in so many ending/opening credits (actually she appears more in the credits than she does in the show )

Thanks for the proof that you all show I am happy for Ed


But I think I cant breathe anymore today. May be I go to the doctor and do check up..... (cant ever speak because my heart is like crashing down.)


NO KIDDING GUYS!!! ITS NOT A JOKE! I CANT BREATHE!

I would like to see more of Winry. My first manga ever (got it just the yesterday <3) is FMA vol2 and no winry! i was kinda sad but it's manga of fma...I couldn't complain!
Also, relise this : Ancient times in Japan had loads of small villages away from other villages so the girls and boys of the villages 99.99% of the time married their best friends from the same village.
Rizenbul is like a village, miles away from everything. If Ed never did what he did he'd probly be (playfully) fighting Al (still) over who'd marry Winry.

Logic concludes that due to these sercumstances, Ed and Winry are a logical conclusion. Or in english EdWin proability 100%.

Childhood friends (I moved too much to have any) are always likely to fall for each other due to the fact that they are friends (meaning they like eachother anyway and know each others strong points.) and they both suffered hardships (Winry's parent's deaths, Mr.Elric leaveing, trisha dieing, Ed and Als perdicament, ect) plus I belive any children they have together would be very 'powerful'. They'd have almost excelent Alchemy skills (deniey this and the Geneologic Psycologst will come out.) and would be skilled in Automail. Not a bad combo!
Also, Ed's being in the military might (Going by Military Brat standers of what happens, I'm one.) infulence his kids to nnot nesscerily join but respcet a basic of the military. English : They might not join, or even respect the military in a normal sence but they will always have it's influance in their lives, even if they never leave Rizenbul and no military members come to visit.

I'm a scientist and logic states EdWin, the writer in me might write other stuff (RoyxEd, I swear I'm working on it! ;p ) but it's always Edwin.

yeah and I know from personal experience. YOu may not always fall for your childhood friend because maybe you loose contact with him or something. But trust me when you suddenly realise that he is a man (she is a woman) then you start to fall for them, it's that change into adult hood where your strong love and affection for them can most certainly turn into romantic love.

That depends on if they mature into the right person.

Me and my boyfriend now were childhood friends and we suddenly just fell for eachother. It was hard though, I can understand Ed and Winry. It's really difficult to tell them, you have been friends for so long and if you tell them that you have feelings for them and they don't have them back for you. Then it can totally weird up your friendship. There is also then chance you may end up breaking eachother's hearts and then the friendship is most definetly down the drain.

So it will take Ed and Winry time, but I understand perfectly. And yes in the anime and manga the probabilty of Ed with anyone else but WInry is slim. The scientists way of thinking! ahaha

Well, I'd love to endulge on my thoughts but I'd include too many spoilers ^^;; All I'll say is that I think that Ed and Winry make a very cute couple... who knows :o

Si! Childhood friends do make the best couples! And Mizumi, if you are afraid of revealing spoliers, use spolier tags. Or do what I do and write WARNING THIS INFORMATION/POST THINGY MAY CONTAIN SPOLIERS. in big bold letters. That always helps. ^^;

If I can Quote Freudian work, You can add a spoiler tag.

90% of all anime I read/watch is couples that were best friends (Even for short times).POST THINGY! Sounds like a b-rate hooror movie! lol!

Now, mind you I was going through 8years or so of Collage level psycology (my hobby, whoo hoo!) and found this.
I found that if 'something' or 'someone' moved Ed and Winry away, the chances of coupledom would be slim. I'm going to play Devil's Advocate here, so no yelling at me.
[SPOILER THINGY WHATCHAMADUZIT!]
Winry's parents were killed in Ishbal (I belive the Anime states the military did it, not sure) so she doesn't like Ishbalans much(In the manga it was scar.)
On top of this she and Pinako do like alchmey anyway.
(first few eps Pinako was uncomfortale around it, before the boys got their "bright idea").
State Alchemists started the Ishbal thing and either way (manga or anime) she has every reason to hate both Ishbalans and military personel.
She doesn't like the military anyway (ie when Roy first shows up)
and now that Ed is always away with them, she feels like she's losing him.
He also never calls or writes so she feels even more disconnected.
She loves him anyway and wants him to come home
(full bodies or not, just alive)
but he's a "mission man" and he has obligations to keep (Military, al, ect.)
that keep him away from home. Winry knows he won't "come to his sences" and come home till the world is black and burning in hell fire (just an expresion for the end of time) but she faintly tries anyway.

If you'll remember Psiren/Claira caught Ed in an uncomfortable situation (accedintel groping). This proves that he is uncomfortable around women (all women) and has "sexual issuses" to deal with.
I disagree with this theory, But just so you know its not "is he or is not gay" but "does he like anyone or no one at all". I don't realy belive this idea because with Clause and Rose (kinda i guess) he flirted with them lightly, and on more them countable acasions with Winry.

Add all the travleing he's used to, how restless he gets indoors and the fact that he hates being treated like a child, his mind set is this: He'll never truly settle down.
Doesn't mean he won't get married, have kids, ect. but it does mean that untill he "runs out of energy" he won't rest. This mostly relys on his love of Al.
Psycology also states that this type of conection (again I deffinatly don't agree) can cause insestual thoughts and emotions. A similer thing with his surounding military 'brothers' (women count in this too).

Whole point is: Psycology states that he is a restless insestual who is most likely gay but social views make him belive he is straight.
That's not our Ed. Ed honestly is straight (90% so anyway) and I've really only seen 3 bronettes (Trisha/Sloth goes back to insest.) that he could possibly connect to, Clause and Maria, and Rose (not happening). Everyone else is blond like Winry.(psycology states that if you love someone, you'll try to find others like them.)

Psycology also states that if RosexEd were to happen, here's the outcome.
positive: He'd be away 90% of the time, she'd be with kids.
Negative: the Kids would wonder about their dad, Rose and Ed argued way too much about belifes and such so a religus house hold (while rose would want) would be imposible (ed would probly influance alchmey unknowingly), Rose has every reason to hate military (town plundered, raped, ect.).

So Rose/Ed Doesn't work, Dr.Sigmund Freud thinks Ed's gay (and insestuus, ew),
he also thinks that Winry is a lost cause (minus Ed's "gayness").

Sorry, I started looking stuff up and found a ditch inwhich to climb into.
loves!

Please feel free to tell me that freud sucks as much as I know he does.
He's been so wrong, Acording to him I'm a pyschoic homicidal who loves to rape women. Boy was he wrong! I'm a normal, non-violent person who refuse to hurt others in any form.

LoveS!

wow. Congradulations Eliss Music. You've officially made milk come out of my nose for the first time. (i was drinking milk while reading this)

You guys must like makeing fun of my posts.

I don't make fun of your posts.
In fact I respect your differance in opinions.

Freud made fun of everyone....He's a loser, end of story.

The EdxRose not working is based solely on psycological studies, not my opinion.
Sorry if it's not up to par, but it was funny to read anyway!

It made Random Person spit milk from her nose!
*claps* That's funny, but what exaclty made you do that?
I've had, milk, pepsi, corn, marbles (long story, I was 7) come out of my nose
so don't feel bad!

Aog, which post are you saying I'm making fun of?
I wasn't and I can totely explane myself. Wow, I need to go be a professer
so I can bore other people and not myself or you guys.
I get like this, I get on a scientific topic and I go nuts and loose everyone.I'm sorry guys and girls, Forgive me!:wub: *cute kitten face with big eyes*
Loves!

EdxRose really doesn't work for some reason. Maybe AlxRose,but EdxRose is just well stupid.

That was a very good statement eliss, the only thing I would like to point out is ed's uncomfortableness with women. You can't really try to say he wouldn't grow out of it when he is a man. I mean... he was about 12 years old when he groped siren, i think any guy would be scared or even embarrased, hell I would be if i groped a guy accidently. Besides he has no experience, he just needs to be with the right person and it would fall into place (when he is much older mind you) lol!

Few things
one, the guy you grop wouldn't mind!
second, freud says no one "grows out" of mental inflamations such as this.
third, we all know Ed's normal.

No expieriance? Get Winry & Ed drunk and call it a date!

My whole few of Ed's psyciatric state is this:
between 12 to 16 he is a typical male.
he likes travle, outdoors, thinks about girls (clams up when talking to them),ect.

The insestus part really got me. How many close same sex siblings do you see macking it out with each other? Seriusly. Also I found this:

"Childhood friends of oposing genders are more apt to gain in marrage then non-childhood friends.....(like 20 pages later)....They know each others thoughts, secrets and disires (agree) and each others fears and dislikes, however they will never know as much if they never were in intement standers. ....(3 pages later)...If they should produce offspring and dis-gain in marrage, they shall hold of grudges for eternety untill they retry the love again."
Or (the military issuse mind you)
" If he is never home and she realy sees him she will love him more, yet resent his leaveing more for all human disire strives to cling to one another's love-spouce. The couple that is always together with no time alone begings to hate and resent marrage. A perfect balance is being able to work a normal porshion of the day, be home the rest then the wife should leave for a normal porshion and returns, then it's family day out, backto husband leaveing ect. This perfect form should be practiced daily."

English: Dr. Carter (top qoute) says they will be more intemently involved then non-friends. Professer John Markerter (no clue, thats his name. bottom qoute) says that their is a perfect balance, that even the best of friends need space.

Oh and one more tHing.
Freud says Winry wrenches Ed because she hates him for something, Dr. Carter says she does it because she wants to make sure he gets the message and not go anywhere. (Love Dr.Carter's view!)
loves!

I was kind of talking about NightMistress.

Hmmm I don't like to make fun of your posts. Heck, I don't even think I'm making fun at all. I just usually make rebuttles when posts make no sense (ie:your first post a couple weeks ago in this thread), are ignorant and not founded on anything (same post), and are spam (ie: the more recent one since you stated the same thing pretty much a week ago). You like EdRose, that's fine. We knew that already so why post it again without any form of support or discussion to go with it? You haven't added anything of use to the discussion. If you can't do that, don't bother hitting the reply button because we don't want to bother reading it.

wow you definatly did your homework!

[quote=Summerlover01,Aug 26 2005, 05:17 PM]
Whole point is: Psycology states that he is a restless insestual who is most likely gay but social views make him belive he is straight.

[/quote]

wow you definatly did your homework!

[/quote]

Homework? That was just off the top of my head from 8 or more years of reaserching psychology! Thanks!

I just realized earlier today that I can't draw Edward worth a lick! Wait, worth a penny! ok, sounds better now. Anyway, I can't draw him very well yet I can draw Inuyasha desent enough! I also have good days (you can tell who every one is in good detail) and middle days (You can make a good guess at who it is) and bad days (you have to ask followed by "you sure?").


My scietific hobbies are strange because I'm useing what started as a way to help myself understand my own mental disorders (all minor ones) has now been able to analyze and psychologicly investigate possablitys for anime charaters.
I either need a life or more anime choices. ooh...shinny picture of Al...Sorry, you say something?

I wrote a fic I might add on to later, it aplys here cuz it's edwin, anyone wanna read it so far?
LOves! (ps-I'd give a scietific explanation formyself but I don't feel good right now)

[QUOTE]I just realized earlier today that I can't draw Edward worth a lick! Wait, worth a penny! ok, sounds better now. Anyway, I can't draw him very well yet I can draw Inuyasha desent enough! I also have good days (you can tell who every one is in good detail) and middle days (You can make a good guess at who it is) and bad days (you have to ask followed by "you sure?"). [QUOTE]


Lol I cant ethier.
Or mabe I just dont have the talent of an artist or mabe Im just not trying hard enough.

Eliss: Okay, first, let me tell you that I really don't want to be rude and that I found your psychologie (sp?) theory interesting but do you know, Eliss, that you're doing all of this because of some pieces of paper... Because that's what Winry, Ed and all other characters of Full Metal Alchemist are!

I don't know if you're totally sure of what you're saying but:

-You state that Ed is 90% straight= Okaaayyy, why not... That's not really exact for me but anyway, it's not important...

The all 'groping' thing with PSiren was only an accident and only here for humor! I don't even know if Bones thought about the 'sexual issues' of Ed when they did this scene... Plus, he was only twelve years old.

You state all these things about how Winry's feeling and Ed too but did you ever talk to Hiromu Arakawa, Did Hiromu Arakawa ever confess to you about the feelings of the characters she created?

Why I am saying Hiromu Arakawa anyway? Shouldn't I say Winry or Ed, etc? No, because Hiromu Arakawa is the one in charge of this manga.

We already know that Winry is in love with Ed, of course, but do we have any proof that Ed is really in love with her? Of course, there was this all Scar accident thing! So what?

What I'm trying to say is that Arakawa sensei is the only one who knows Ed's true feelings and who will decide what his faith will be. She is the one who knows if he has incestual feelings toward his brother too. If she wants him to fall in love in Rose then he'll fall in love with Rose! Same for the EdWin pairing (if this will ever happen!)! And who said that if they really get together, it'd be the true and eternal love? Who said Ed or even Winry will not die in the next chapters?

Arakawa sensei is definitly not scared of disappointing FMA fans!

[SPOILER]Hughes had a lot of fans, now he's dead! A lot of people likes Envy too but he's certainly gonna die soon, of course, I'll say it again, Who knows...?[/SPOILER]

So, Will ever Ed and Winry ever fall in love?

We'll see what Arakawa sensei has in store! Maybe their feelings for each other will grow or maybe they'll vanish because of some events!

There is just no way that Ed could be gay.
The EdxRoy thing wont happen, theres to many chicks around for them to be gay.