Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Which Song Is Better?
Fullmetal Alchemist Discussion Board > Fullmetal Alchemist Discussions > FMA Music > FMA-1 Anime Music
Pages: 1, 2, 3
Yannealchemist


In my opinion, YeLLOW Generation - Behind the gate at this time smile.gif
xrninja
hmm, i don't really like either that much. my order of preference:

OP:
AKFG - Rewrite
Porno Graffiti - Melissa
Cool Joke - UNDO
L'arc en Ciel - Ready Steady Go

ED:
Kitade Nana - Kesenai Tsumi
Crystal Kay - Motherland
YeLLOW Generation - Tobira no Mukou he
Sowelu - I Will

tongue.gif but i think between the two, i like ready steady go a teeeny bit more.
Dark State
I like ready steady go a bit more
konic vince
I don't like any of the closings that much except Kitade Nana's Kesenai Tsumi. I like all the openings, especially Rewrite, that awesome song that nobody can hate smile.gif
Forock
Kodoku is the best...the one played by a piano- one of the main tunes with no singer.
Dancing Alchemist
I really don't like either of them that much.
inneRdemonS
i dont like foriegin music, i dont understand it....
Kitoky
I think I prefer Ready Steady Go more than Tobira no Mukou e. Tobira no Mukou e doesn't seem to catch me very much and isn't the favorite of the majority of people.

The only song that really caught me was Kesenai Tsumi, but the others I had to get used to be and my current favorite is I Will by Sowelu...

Though I did like Motherland for quite so time...

kimi ga....tabidatsu hi wa....
lenita
so long time i don't write but... defenitly I prefer L'arc-en-ciel for that song i started to see the anime laugh.gif
xrninja
QUOTE(Kitoky @ Jan 27 2005, 11:52 AM)
Though I did like Motherland for quite so time...

kimi ga....tabidatsu hi wa....
[snapback]99064[/snapback]


itsumo to onaji....ja ne to te wo futta..... laugh.gif

i didn't like melissa or motherland that much before, but all of a sudden i really like both songs. i always try to sing motherland in the car, but it requires a large voice range i don't have. not that that stops me. biggrin.gif
Prinz_Zoisit
behind the gate was the one with the snow right?
i chose read steady, hm dunno why^^;;
Chiyo
Difficult, I like both songs alot...well actually I like all the songs. I went for Ready Steady Go...because I can at least sing along to parts of that biggrin.gif
Phoenix_alchemist
Out of the two, I'd pick READY STEADY GO, but I like Undo more.
Kitoky
QUOTE(xrninja @ Jan 27 2005, 05:11 PM)
QUOTE(Kitoky @ Jan 27 2005, 11:52 AM)
Though I did like Motherland for quite so time...

kimi ga....tabidatsu hi wa....
[snapback]99064[/snapback]


itsumo to onaji....ja ne to te wo futta..... laugh.gif

i didn't like melissa or motherland that much before, but all of a sudden i really like both songs. i always try to sing motherland in the car, but it requires a large voice range i don't have. not that that stops me. biggrin.gif
[snapback]99409[/snapback]



XD

....marude...ashita mo mata...kono machi de au mitai ni...

Melissa also didn't catch me at first but that beside the beach beat kinda...got me addicted. I dunno but porno Graffiti always has these songs that reminds me of these beachside parties with these songs. Motherland was catch especially for the vocal and at first it sounded like an American singer going Japanese. XD
lightalchemist
Does anyone know a website where I can listen to them? unsure.gif
And I'm not sure but I like Ready Steady Go.Please help.See how lost I am.
AlchemistEd
I like Ready Steady Go
white dragon knight
Out of these two I choose Ready Steady Go
hidden_death
out of the two i would pick READY STEADY GO i donno because i like it tongue.gif
hagane_no_tokage
ah, but wouldn't the correct translation of 'tobira no mukou he' be beyond the door...? not behind the gate... O_o

in any case, of the two, i think i like ready steady better. but my all-time fave hagaren song has to be kesenai. ^___^ that song rocks. XD
xrninja
QUOTE(hagane_no_tokage @ Feb 6 2005, 10:01 PM)
ah, but wouldn't the correct translation of 'tobira no mukou he' be beyond the door...?  not behind the gate...  O_o
[snapback]108276[/snapback]


yup. i see "beyond the gate" quite often as well; maybe people think it fits better with fma, and they're mixing it up with the great and powerful mon. and even though the mon has a tobira...oh well. laugh.gif
hagane_no_tokage
ah, i suppose that taken in that light it makes more sense... i had seen it before and i was like wtf? that's not what it means at all! O_o

i get it now. i was thinking too hard, i guess. happy.gif;; i do that.
AA battery
I chose Tobira no Mukou e... its lyrics suits the Elric brothers much more than Ready Steady Go (in fact, Ready Steady go is my least fav FMA theme song and Tobira no Mukou e is my first fav... go figure XP)
Mikee
For me, I think READY STEADY GO of L`Arc~en~Ciel is better.. happy.gif
Sin Of Envy
Beyond the Gate-it's my favorite so yeah, I like it better...
Vivi Sparrow
Laruku~
Tyna
Anywhere! It's so easy! YouTube, or Google video, or any download sites. That's where I found mine! Yay!! Well, some anyways. Some of them some dude got for me. I love Motherland. There's just something gentle and loving about it that I can't portray when I try to sing it.

And I think "Beyond the Door" sounds better than "Behind the Gate". And the literal translation is "door", too, I think.
JoshP1389
"Behind the Gate" for the win. READY STEADY GO! is just plain overrated.
Tombow
^^ Yeah, me too.
Bwtween the two, I like "Tobira no mukou e" ("Bihind the gate") better. smile.gif
Galorfilinde
Tobira no mukou e is my favourite FMA song. I don't like Ready Steady go very much, it's too 'heavy' for my taste. And the lyrics from Tobira no mukou e are better.
hagane no renkinjutsushi addict
blink.gif that's a hard decission... i like both songs very much...
sweety_pie
READY,STEADY, GO is better
L'arc-en-ciel is so freggin cool

actually I don't think I've ever heard yellow before.
paca
Behind the gate is better.
ready, stedy go....mmmm... I like it but not at all. huh.gif
MikaSilentAlchemist
QUOTE(sweety_pie @ May 3 2006, 08:38 PM) [snapback]390070[/snapback]

READY,STEADY, GO is better
L'arc-en-ciel is so freggin cool

actually I don't think I've ever heard yellow before.



I agree to that one!!!! I love ready steady go!!!!!! My fav song that I can sing to!!!
Robo-Mechanic
Ready Steady Go all the way!
The Great Asparagus
hmm... that's an interesting combination of song choices.

i think... i'll have to go with tobira no mukou he. ready steady go isn't bad, but the beginning when it was like "readysteadygimmegoodluuaack" and the part that goes "pleeeease trust!! me!!" totally killed it lol. otherwise, it's a lovely song
Ed-Al-Win Fan
Never heard the first one before, so I'm going to with Ready Steady Go
Robo-Mechanic
Most people like ready steady go because its more ROCK! oh...
FMA4ever
Well.....I always loved l'Arc~en~Ciel!
Colonel Hatsuharu
Ready Steady Go all the way! My friend let me listen to it once then I bugged her to let me listen more! mwa ha ha ha
Kel
I have to say Tobira no Mukou e. I dont really like ready steady go. well I kinda do. it's one of those things where it's so bad it's good. (this is my opinion just to let you know ><)

but personally I'd say my favourite songs would be (in order): rewrite, undo, kenesei tsumi, tobira no mukou e
sweety_pie
People have been saying that they haven't heard them all so...I'm gonna post links to them from youtube.(That's all I got)

Yellow

READY STEADY GO
_Jelly
Tobira no Mukou e is teh cool. It kinda kicks Ready Steady Go. L'arc~en~ciel's cool...but..not that cool. It's ready how he says "ReadySteadyNeverLookBAaaaaaaak" and all that. Japanese trying to speak English in their songs is funny. =D
fullmetal_alchemistwater
i say yellow genaratipn is better steady ready go is too rocking it hurts my ear one time i had this wired dream that my friend was sing i was like woah that is weird
Vash_the_Gunslinger
I like Ready Steady Go because I don't think I've heard the first one.
Edward's Blondie
READY STEADY GO is awesome.... although I can't even understand it. *sigh*. If anyone that knows Japanese, please translate it for me! I'd surley appriciate it!!
Amethyst Sunset
I vote Tobira no Mukou e, because it's my most favorite ending theme, and Ready Steady Go is only my second favorite among the openings (Rewrite IS THE BEST. XD).

But to be perfectly honest, both songs are great in their own ways, and it depends on the taste of the listener. wink.gif
000_neji
Why isn't rewrite added in the list?,it's the best song in FMA...
DantElric
Both are really great. It's kind of hard to choose, but I voted for Tobira no Mukou E. I love it, with or without vocals. biggrin.gif
Untitled
Ready Steady wins my vote! laugh.gif
Roy Jr.
I voted for ready steady go because it has great tune.

But, I think that yellow generation has a much better message.sleep.gif
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.