8

6/10

While the picture is cute, the rest just seems too amateurish. Sorry.

5/10

looks like a basic copy and past job *shrugs* an amateur could do that

7.6/10
I still think it looks girly.

Excuse me? Give constructive criticism. Explain how it looks like a basic copy and paste job. Don't just blatantly say that, especially when it's derogatory like that.
I just don't overpack mine with effects.
I wouldn't normally get angry, it just seems like you've been bashing my signatures without reason lately.

8/10 for Bacon.
Like I said in the avatar thread, I like how the hair is blurred tro show motion in the background.

okay then here:

take scar, greyscale him, copy him, paste on brown layered bg

That doesn't quite answer my question, hun.
Try using an image (that isn't Scar, btw) that was scanned in, with the original background meticulously taken out, colors fixed, scratches and dust marks removed, creating a background completely from scratch, going through every single font to find one that works then arranging them.

Not trying to fight with you here Ailuro but, all that stuff you mentioned isnt that hard really LOL
Sorry *Hides*

7/10 ~ Who is that on your sig and Avatar btw?

It is if you saw what I had to work with. =.=

you could try working with something...better?

10/10 Poem!

Well, taking a picture, fixing it up, then making a background to put it on is basically what you do also. It's ridiculous to tell Ailuro that her work is easy if you think you're putting a lot of work into your signatures.

7/10 I've seen better backgrounds from you.

7

Tell me what wrong with this one

There's no background. 5/10

9/10
I am not a big fan of Kingdom Hearts

I don't have a pic to rate,but just rate the "In case of fire"

10/10
Funny,I like it.

7 or an 8

~ 7/10 Too Black

7/10
the picture is nice but maybe a more rivating backround?
@ Yume-chan :lol nice that is really clever. XD

9

5.5/10

Isn't very interesting...
4/10.

it's cute but....the background is very plain and the pic is not great quality
7/10

Can I ask you something? Why are you constantly ribbing me man? You are one of the reasons I don't post on this thread much anymore. I can give a rats behind what you think you have seen better from me...I like my sigs, I dont need your constant critiques of my work and BTW Ailuro responded after what I said *She understood what I meant*...There was no need for you to play body guard, Kid!

@ Seventh Sky 8/10

7.8/10

The cropping is excellent and the color scheme suits the images well, but the abstract paint marks on the background seem to disrupt the image...also, the edges are a little sloppy...

Maa, seeing as you seem to enjoy bringing out new signatures relatively often, it's inevitable that recent works will be compared to older ones every now and then. If you like the signature, then it shouldn't bother you significantly if someone else isn't quite as fond of it, ne? ;

7/10

If you were not such good friends with Fool I might have taken your advice as if you meant it, Ne?

@Smoke-san: Ara, but I did mean what I typed. Whether you decide to take it one way or another isn't for me to decide, I guess. (The rating is the same as before.)

7/10

lovin the anime/manga choice, the girl looks kinda...wierd to me in that pic >.< Also, can you train fool in developing better mannerisms please? ^_~

8/10


I dunno. I feel he's rather tactful in what he says. I actually think you should brush up on your etiquette. But that's only my opinion of course. It's your decision whether to act upon it or not.
And just to let you know, I don't feel any antipathy toward you, nor does Foolmetal, I'm sure. So please don't feel it toward both him nor me.

7/10

the sig's still not doing it for me

*okay I get ya ^_~ see ya around then ^^

9.4/10

Lovely blending of images without overdoing the blueness, and those white speckles add a nice finishing touch. I'm kind of wondering if it might look even more effective if the light in the upper right-hand corner weren't covered up, but I guess then the text would have nowhere to go. :\

It's probably because her head is so huge compared to the rest of her body (especially the neck). The rather large eyes might also throw off people. XP

Certainly, if he's lacking in them. What would you like to suggest?

8/10 Aww so cute :3

9.5/10

the words are weird cause I'm a guy but the pic and background look awesome.

Lol, thanks

9/10

awesome as always 8/10

8/10

Eh? I've never actually tried to put you down about your signatures, if that's what you mean...and what is wrong with constructive criticism? Would you rather I just give you a lower rating without a reason? All I was saying is that your current signature isn't as nice as others I've seen you make.

7/10 The background's pretty nice, but the animation and the text aren't so easy on the eyes.

@Smoke- It sounds like that maybe, but he does that with everyone, myself included. He's really one of the nicest people here, just harsh when it comes to judging.

I still give 10/10 because you took an already great pic and made it look amazing. I also love the effect (how did you do that...?)

Do what? XD

I love yours. I'm starting to think it's my favorite out of all of your work. XD I just love the effects on the left image and the right one looks so clear. The background has so much detail to it...I could stare at this one for hours... o.o 10/10 I miss your matching avatar! XP

9/10

I'd say it's one of your best so far. I even love the text, which I'm usually very picky on. I love how he almost blends in but still catches the eyes. And the border style is a nice touch. Though the color scheme seems a bit off, I can't explain it.

I know what you mean about the color scheme. XD I added an overlay of blue to the whole image and it didn't turn out as well as I wanted it to.

Hmm, the background looks a little simple. 8/10 Who is that character? XD

I like simple. <3

It's Jing, King of Bandits.

Um, 9/10 again. x3

8.5/10. It's nice, but I don't like simple. >_< To me, simple is like one didn't put enough effort into it.

Whatever I gave you last time...7/10

(Ailuro, I like yours!)

8/10

8/10 I just love your icy-ish backgrounds ^^

(new siggie, I was trying a new style and...kind of failed XD)

Lets just say I am mostly pissed at the way you always seem to come to the rescue of one of your favs on here when I or others make a criticism or let opinion be know about something they have created/said. Basically it is not what you say about my sigs that bother me *I really can care less about that* otherwise I would have stated so the 400 times you have "criticised" my work. Somehow I knew you would think something else then what I had intended >.< and so did several others from the couple posts i received in response to my post. *sigh* I'm over it! Maybe we can still manage a workable friendship foolmetal

*I am forever misunderstood*
Foolmetal 8/10
Seventh Sky 7/10 I liked the last one a lot better but the size of this one is nice. Good work as always.

I'm not really in the mood to point out the holes in that explanation or argue any further, so I'll leave you with the last word. Although...this post could be considered as the last word...XD

What did I give you before? I think it was 7/10.

oh you make trying to like you so difficult Ok Foolmetal *nods* >.<

8/10

I really like the colors, but it'd be nice if there was more text... 9/10

Personally, I like criticism for my sigs and stuff as long as people tell me what I'm doing wrong so I can try and change it...My current sig would be better if there were more scans of these two around *sighs*