Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Roy X Who? (besides Roy X Riza)
Fullmetal Alchemist Discussion Board > Fullmetal Alchemist Discussions > FMA Character Discussions
Pages: 1, 2, 3
Kihaku
Oh jeez.. READ THE OTHER POSTS. Thank you.
Once again. This is for ALTERNATE pairings.. RoyxRiza isn't counted... since that's pretty obvious and wouldn't make an interesting poll.

Another reason for not counting other... *sighs*

And I'm too tired to argue about gay couples being "gay".
Omakase Shimasu
With Hakai's permission I could take out the 'other' option. X3

But then we'd still have to contend with people who neglect to read the first few posts where the purpose of the thread and the absence of a mainstream pairing has been clearly stated.
Tobu Ishi
Well, being quite solidly straight myself, and having truly nothing against homosexuality, I can say it's possible to be at least 99% thrown over one side of the fence. happy.gif If there's a little seed of femlove in me somewhere, I haven't found it yet, and it's not for lack of wishing. (I know scads of really nice girls, but I can't seem to find a cute guy...or bring myself to date a girl. sleep.gif; )

Roy strikes me as very straight; same with Ed. Just their general behavior screams 'straight' to me. You know? All orientations aside, though, I have to say that what really disturbs me about RoyEd isn't their sexuality. It's their age. Ed's only fifteen, sixteen toward the end of the series, and Roy has got to be pushing thirty. That's a huge gap, not to mention counts as molestation no matter how you slice it, and Roy does not come off as a child molestor to me.

So, since Roy/Riza is not an option here, I'm proud to be the first person to vote for the only woman in the show who's as sneaky, manipulative, ruthless, exhibitionist, and sexy as Colonel Mustang... Psiren. laugh.gif
hakai-kun
Oooh! good job with the RoyxPsirenxRoy! l0l
Sure, Kase, you can take out the 'other' pairing. l0l i didn't think it'd be such a problem when i first put it there. I figured, hey, maybe someone will come up with something interesting. l0l. Good job Tobu Ishi! l0l.
People should at least read the *first* post, i think. -shrugs- ah well.. PM me if you take off the 'others', ok Kase? Sankyuu!
Username05
Roy and Riza!
Kihaku
Kase:
I don't know... It would be a pity though, because some people have great options for "other".
I don't know why it's so hard to read at least the first page of the topic.. plus this thread isn't that long. *sighs*
Oh well, even though I read everything sometimes things just escape my mind.. but well.. I would have thought that by now this is pretty obvious.

Tobu Ishi:
Ah, at least someone has something to base their opinion on! Yay for you!
Heh... being too staright is kind of suspicious. Although... I don't know if Ed has actually shown much interest in general...
About the age. Yeah... I'm also a little uptight when it comes to huge age gaps. I'm okay if the younger person is round 16... and it's not like Ed is getting younger. In a few years it wouldn't be that bad (but then Roy would be going steady with Riza... laugh.gif )

RoyxPsiren! smile.gif Hey that's a considerable option. He actually seemed even interested in her. Yeah, well of course, she's an attractive woman. biggrin.gif

Username 05:
I hope you didn't vote "other"
Blackwings
Oh... im the only one voted for Harvoc x Roy...

i think itd be cute...
Kihaku
Good for you! wink.gif
We were hoping for votes.. That's a cute couple too wink.gif.
NightMistress
If Royai's not an option then ROYxHUGHESxROY ALL THE WAY!!! RoyxHavoc isn't that bad either I guess.
Mustang Fangirl
Oh yeah, HughesxRoy....I love that one.

Actually I would love to see RoyxYuki Eiri (I know, I know,a Gravitation not FMA character, but that would be great)

Hmmm....getting ideas now. Better stop thinking along those lines biggrin.gif
Kihaku
Heh, that's interesting.... Roy would be the seme wink.gif.

QUOTE(NightMistress @ Apr 15 2005, 01:48 PM)
If Royai's not an option then ROYxHUGHESxROY ALL THE WAY!!! RoyxHavoc isn't that bad either I guess.
[snapback]153359[/snapback]


I definitely agree! smile.gif
Mustang's Apprentice
[COLOR=blue]
RoyxRiza owns all of them.


But since that is not an option I voted RoyxWinry because I think he flirted with her once.
Mustang's Apprentice
I wonder why my color didn't work.....
Hagane No Renkinjutsushi {ED}
I think it would be roy and hughes because they are best friends ^^
Satsuka
ROY X ED FANS UNITE!!! Anway since Roy x Riza isn't on the poll,I chose Roy x Ed because it's my second favorite pairing right after Roy x Riza.
Reika
RoyXRiza of course! Why isn't there any option that allows to vote for that pair??? I think it's cannon enough
Siobhain_chan
Roy doesnt seem Homosexual. So I dont know why those pairings are winning.

Anyways, I picked RoyxLust. You know how good they'd look together?
NightMistress
QUOTE(Siobhain_chan @ Jul 21 2005, 12:45 AM)
Roy doesnt seem Homosexual. So I dont know why those pairings are winning.

Anyways, I picked RoyxLust. You know how good they'd look together?
[snapback]221025[/snapback]


That's one of the reasons why I don't mind RoyLust too much. The sheer hottness factor. I mean, Riza is "strong and beautiful" hott, but Lust is "bombshell" hott.

The homosexual (yaoi) pairs are winning because they are popular amongst us fangirl types.
Siobhain_chan
Heh. If we could do any pairing, royxyuki sohma.

Oh damn. Id DIE
Siobhain_chan
Im more for hotness factors. MOstly hetrosexual relationships for me.

But YukixRoy I wouldnt mind xD Im obsessed with them both.

oh god x.x I watch Subbed episodes, Im watching the sixth episode on tv (dubbed) and nina sounds like an idiot.
GaluxKitty
Dude, Roy/Havoc/Roy all the way. 8D
Galorfilinde
I voted RoyxEd. I like RoyxHughes too, but RoyxEd wins tongue.gif Why? I just think they're cute together ^^
Colette
...I guess if it's not RoyxRiza, it's RoyxLust.

Once again, [spoiler]Roy steals Havoc's girlfriend >D[/spoiler]
manemana
buuh.
why is there nobody else vote for royxalxroy?
al is such a cute, nice boy.
while roy is a...
i don't know. i just think they fit together smile.gif
for riza, i prefer rizaxed. hehe


Nil-chan
RizaXEd? ok....
well..... im going to have to agree with Sumonner Collete, RoyLust if there is no royai here, just cause its what ROy does...
_Jelly
Any pairring with Ed, is just ruined, IMO.

Mainly Lust, I suppose. No Riza, so yeah.
55th_animalalchemist
QUOTE(Summoner Colette @ May 29 2006, 08:11 PM) [snapback]403162[/snapback]

...I guess if it's not RoyxRiza, it's RoyxLust.

Once again, [spoiler]Roy steals Havoc's girlfriend >D[/spoiler]


That`s true, haha laugh.gif
But I choose RoyxwinryxRoy, Why? , because they have a past that united them (the parents of you know who) and I think because of that Roy or Winry could be obsesive with each other. And later who knows, could be gettin in love Roy of winry or Winry of Roy.

That could be possible ,right? huh.gif
Porgand
HavocxRoy.


It was the first ever yaoi pairing I supported, ahhh nostalgy.
Alchemical
I can't really see Roy as a homosexual person (Maybe some drunken bi incidents in Ishbal, but, otherwise, nah.) so I chose other and am going with Roy x Olivier. But I still think Roy is better off with Riza. *nodnod*
Freya-chan
^ ya about ishbal its like those dojinshis i have
RoyXRiza all the way
i could stand RoyXWinry if winry were about 7 years older
RoyXJeanXMaes prefered yaoi pairing
That One Dude
royxhavoc! *nosebleed* (yes, girls can get nosebleeds too..!)
Freya-chan
me like RoyXMaes too

linkage to site for FMA yaoi Fanfics from G-NC-17:
Linkage here enter at own risk
Naivete
Roy/Al huh?.. I can't really see that happening.
Roy/Ed used to be good for me but its over-rated now.
I have yet to read a Roy/Lust doujin.
Same with Roy/Winry.
Roy/Jean is good if written properly but if it's centered around sex, then no.
Same with Roy/Maes.

Hmph, I can't decide.
Fushi
Did I hear someone say RoyxOliver?



:D
Popogeejo
Roy caught between Oliver and Riza...poor guy.
Causmicfire
RoyxOlivier if not RoyxRiza
Firearm Alchemist
Well you wanted to leave RoyxRiza out so I chose RoyxHughes...
Fushi
Honestly, I think Maes was the best match for Roy. Their dynamic was amazing, and I love the idea of them having a relationship before Maes met Gracia.

But of course, not only did Hughes get married but he died too, so now I support RoyxAlcohol. =P
zonkiethegreat
In my weird defense for RoyXWinry...
Believe it or not there is a quite a few shippers for Roy/Winry, and even more fanfics made about them then Ling/RanFan. Of course not like Royai. It is twisted, but by the end of Shamballa, I know a lot of people who came out loving the idea of RoyXWinry.

In Shamballa:

1.) Winry loses Ed (basically forever) and she seems to accept this.

2.) Roy X Riza in Shamballa - was a little uncomfortable, it seemed as if they acknowledged each other, and definitely care for one another, but where was the spark?

3.) The director had stated in the Special Features that there was a whole scene cut out of the movie where Roy and Winry were supposed to make up. The scene where Winry and Schiezska find the lilies on Hughe's grave. That was supposed to be the
scene. But it ended up getting cut out due to time.


4.) Roy calls Winry, she is fine with this. Making it seem like they have come to some form of reconciliation.


This is all silly stuff and just my opinions by the way, and I believe everyone has the right to like whatever pairing they want!
Kale Mustang
Definitely Roy & Olivier...

They have chemistry, though volatile as it is - probably what makes this pairing interesting to begin with.
Miss MP
Since I would have chosen Riza had she been on the poll, my choice [and in my view, the next best relationship for Roy] would be HughesRoy. However, since Hughes died, it's a tie between RoyLust and RoyOlivier. RoyLust would be interesting; I could see a storyline in which Lust aids Roy in his search for Hughes' killer, because honestly, Lust had plenty of emotion in comparison to Envy; of course, Roy would have to assist her in exchange, and the tension would be interesting. As for RoyOlivier, well, their interactions are interesting and speak for themselves. wink.gif

Though I also wouldn't say no to a little RoyHavoc.
FMA-Girl
No RoyAi.

But then Again I vote for RoyWin.
I love the idea of Roy with Winry.
It seems so.. angsty.

THEY WERE GOING TO MEET IN THE MOVIE! but it was CUT OUT. ;;
So close...
I'm still awaiting a confrontation!
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.