Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Ed Or Roy? Which One Would You Rather....
Fullmetal Alchemist Discussion Board > Fullmetal Alchemist Discussions > FMA Character Discussions
Pages: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8
Ed's_Girl
Note: Two new polls are added on Oct. 20, 2009.
Anyone who voted on the first part of the poll before, and hence can't vote on the two new ones, just post your vote choices for these two new polls with a note saying you can't vote on them because you voted the first one before, and periodically I can add those votes to the poll tally manually. smile.gif ~Tombow









smile.gif Ed'll win this one!!
Edward.Elric
Ed is the coolest, but Im passing on this poll.
Major Armstrong
I'll pass on this one.
Udon
If I were gay, I'd choose Ed. laugh.gif
-Zhou Yu-
QUOTE(Udon @ Dec 6 2004, 02:13 PM)
If I were gay, I'd choose Ed.  laugh.gif

You mean if you were a girl?
Udon
QUOTE(-Zhou Yu- @ Dec 6 2004, 02:21 PM)
QUOTE(Udon @ Dec 6 2004, 02:13 PM)
If I were gay, I'd choose Ed.  laugh.gif

You mean if you were a girl?

If I were a girl, I'd wanna be a lesbian wink.gif
Hex-Sama
I voted for Edward because he's one of my favorite characters, plus I can relate to some of his feelings and views personally.
hagane_no_tokage
it's kind of a tough choice, actually... for me, anyway... roy definitely has my vote as far as primal physical attraction goes...but ed has a lot of the same views as i do, and seems to place a lot of value in a lot of things i believe in...

can i just be polygamous? i luff them both equally...

...er...as much as you can love something 2 dimensional... man, i gotta get working on that bishounen manifestation machine...
luciferownsme
I love Roy Mustang-sama(wow...he got promoted to -sama...most of my bisshies are just -dono or -san)

He reminded me of myself on that one episode that Roy was neglecting his paper work(I do my homework the period before it's due)
Elric
Ed mor than Mustang... cos ed likes to use swords and spears! laugh.gif
laugh.gif i like swords. the bigger da better. laugh.gif
still... Roy is rather ANNOYING! (no offence to roy luvers) mad.gif
Queen of the dammed
Arrrrg..... you guys wanna rip me apart don't you??? We'll you've succeded 'cos I CAN'T DECIDE WHO'S HOTTER!!!!!! TTTTTToTTTTTT
Ed angel
I chose Ed because I like him more than mustang . ( I think he is cuter too)
I think Roy is a little mean to Ed . I love it when someone calls Ed small . ( he's cute when he's angry)
my message to the world : I LOVE EDWARD ELRIC !!!!!!!!!!!!
Hedera
Ah, can't help it... I choose Ed again. laugh.gif Though Roy is also interesting... but Ed is cuter! ~_~
Udon
Beasty Mechanical arm? Or Firecracker gloves?

Decisions, decisions...
lenita
i always chosse Roy, iif his name is there biggrin.gif here i go babe!!! (except when the topic is about the most annoying, or something else you know... laugh.gif )

i love Ed to but Roy is Roy rolleyes.gif rolleyes.gif rolleyes.gif
Dark_ice
yeah,ed's cool,even though he doesnt have great alchemy like the state alchemists.Actually,I take ed's alchemy kinda funny sometimes.
Quistis88
It's complicated. But I chose Mustang anyway, even if he already belongs to Riza. And Ed I'd choose, only . . . I'm not a pedophile. biggrin.gif
Ed's_Girl
True my friend
Queen of the dammed
I shall become a two-timer and feel the wrath of Winry and Riza... Or perhaps I could just settle with Havock... (HE NEEDS A GIRL THAT POOR MAN!!!)
Ed angel
I would probably like Roy if he were a little bit nicer to Ed dry.gif
Nemu
Shit, tough choice, but I'll go for the Colonel. I usually go for total bastards that have some sort of secret soft side to them, so Roy fits that pattern.

Ed would be more like... I dunno, my best friend.

But they're both my all-time favorite characters. =3
Rena, Full Bronze Alchemist
I voted for Edward cause....HIS HOTT!!
Riza Babe
i'd pass this poll i love too many anime people
*Cough* I loved ed then it was james in treasure planet and im in love with HORO HORO NOW!!! smile.gif
Queen of the dammed
Can't I vote for Both??? I mean they're both so hot and sexhey!!!!
Hex-Sama
What the heck?! Why is it that everytime I come to check there is a tie?... It must mean they are equal in hotness... YEAH RIGHT! Edward's ganna win! tongue.gif lol
Queen of the dammed
Torrrrn..........tooooorrrrrnn...... TTOTT GO ED!!! GO ROY!!!
LadyDevi
Why do we have to choose? They're both hot. *drools all over the keyboard*
Gashole
How are they hot? I don't especially love Roy's look and Ed's too short. IPB Image
Izumimon
Ed's cuter but I'm not into dating fifteen-year-olds. XD
Queen of the dammed
QUOTE
How are they hot? I don't especially love Roy's look and Ed's too short. 
Well, I happen to be a pedo and a Pimp-lover.... laugh.gif;
BakaOnna
hmmm... do i even need to think about it... ED!!!! wub.gif
Ed's_Girl
Go Mustang!
Hedera
QUOTE
Ed's cuter but I'm not into dating fifteen-year-olds. XD

The same problem with me. ;_; Why should mangaka make him a teenager?! Could she at least give him 17-18 years?? sad.gif
Kihaku
I voted Ed because Roy belongs to Riza and is too old for me! tongue.gif
Of course... Ed is kind of young..but I'm thinking of the Ed in the film biggrin.gif .
Yeah, he'd be perfect, plus I really like long haired blondes tongue.gif .
Hedera
QUOTE
Yeah, he'd be perfect, plus I really like long haired blondes  .

Heh, the same with me. happy.gif Plus, such a cool hairstyle! laugh.gif
sasuki_604
ROY!!! wub.gif
Although Ed is beginning to worm his way into my heart. laugh.gif
Riza Babe
EDWARD!!!! YEAH!!! Legolas aswell and Horo Horo!!
Ninie
Aaa! I already voted! My memory sucks. But I voted for Roy, I know that! I would never betray him by voting for the shr... ha, Ed.
Gashole
Let's all vote for the underdog.
Quistis88
QUOTE(Gashole @ Dec 15 2004, 06:37 PM)
Let's all vote for the underdog.

And which would that be?
lialiakicks
QUOTE(Quistis88 @ Dec 16 2004, 01:50 AM)
QUOTE(Gashole @ Dec 15 2004, 06:37 PM)
Let's all vote for the underdog.

And which would that be?

Uh, Mustang's cuz he was in there longer...? O_O

Anyways, I voted for Mustang (in bold due to his goodness) because I love his secretively sweet yet cocky-ness!!!

...BUT, I cannot completely close my heart from Edward (in bold due to his awesome-ness) either...

>__< GAH!!! Mother and Father! Please forgive me for my heart belongs to 2 men!!!

...My innocence...my innocence has been plucked like a flower... ;__;
Quistis88
Actually, only one of them is a man.

No, I'm not saying the other is female. Just . . . age, you know?
Ailuro
Roy -> Man
Ed -> Boy
Both -> Male
lialiakicks
GASP! How can you say that in front of his presence?! ;____;

*protectively covers avatar*
Quistis88
It's the smirk. I like to wipe them off people's faces. biggrin.gif
GuestHole
Bush likes to smirk. *random fact*
Ailuro
...

I think some people are too obsessed..
Quistis88
Oh, excellent. Now I have a reason to claw at his face.

If only you said that HE is a smirk. Then I could wipe him off the face of the Earth.

Sorry, bad joke. Couldn't resist.
lialiakicks
;____; Phooey...

*looks for a different avatar to use*
Queen of the dammed
Ed looks cool and hot (you know what i mean...)when he smirks..... Bush looks stupid and ugly when he does..... *random Fact 2* When the SARS pandemic was stlll around (2003 remeber?), my sister was planning to catch SARS adn go all the way to america, spit on her hands and shake hands with Bush.(how she was going to get near he president in the first place, I have no idea....)
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.