Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Ed X Who? Who Should Ed Be Paired With?
Fullmetal Alchemist Discussion Board > Fullmetal Alchemist Discussions > FMA Character Discussions
Pages: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11
Omakase Shimasu
I see, the chanting here has an adverse effect because Ed is in every pairing. ph34r.gif This is not good. We will have to turn to alternative measures.

I am robot.
Kihaku
Alternative measures? What? Go Russell! Go Roy! Yes. That.
People, make this more interesting and vote for anyone else except Ed&Winry(and Ed&Rose tongue.gif ) oh, someone voted for him with Riza! The world is wierd tongue.gif
You're robot? Huh?
telepika
So Kihaku, you think I'll go all shonen-ai because I think shonen-ai pairings are interesting? Got to be careful about that. *Suspiciously looks left and right* Oh no, I might turn into a shonen-ai fan. AHHHHHH!!!!!! Oh well, better than RosexEd!

Looks like Kase's going to propose another bet...
Blade42
I'm just curious....Who voted EdxHawkeye?
darkangelslayer
in which volume is russell is?
Ninie
He isn't in any manga volume, but I think he's in a novel, or something, because I saw pictures of him drawn "manga style", so he isn't a anime original character.
Hex-Sama
OH YEAH! biggrin.gif Go EdxWinryxEd! So much for that brother sister thing. lol *throws a party because EdxWinryxEd is winning in the poll* laugh.gif I see someone voted for EdxAlphonsexEd...Who did that? dry.gif
l|Kouga|l-Youkai
I think before i said rose but it'd be pretty funny if he was with hawk eye laugh.gif
Omakase Shimasu
@Kihaku: I was talking about my way of talking in my post. tongue.gif Seemed robot-ish.

*eyes results of poll* Dear God... ph34r.gif I agree with Kihaku, think: interesting!

Despite what I said in one of my earlier posts (HawkxEd), I'm not laughing. tongue.gif I'm freaked. laugh.gif I'm curious too, though. But I'm sure nobody's going to answer. tongue.gif
Kihaku
telepika: WoW! You're showing signs already!(Although I have no idea how far it will go...) But, being a shonen-ai fan is good. Really! biggrin.gif I'm definitely more open minded now. biggrin.gif

Hey, people are making this more interesting by voting for other pairings! Ah, Envy&Ed has got votes too! Roy&Ed seems to be leading in the "shonen-ai category"... But I'd really like to know the reasons behind the Ed&Riza pairing...
Stinki
Ed X Winry!!!!! And it's winning too!
DarkWarrior
EdXWinry are so cute! OK rose only showed up in the beginning of the manga right?!?! You dont see her afterwards.... why are ppl talking about her like she's some big characters. o.O
Udon
Ed and Winly seem most appropriate, but Ed and Rose would be a close second, imo. Then, maybe, Izumi, even though she's married, and about 15-20 years older. happy.gif Other than that...well, Ed just doesn't seem like the kinda guy to attach himself to someone.
Ninie
QUOTE(DarkWarrior @ Dec 4 2004, 10:17 PM)
EdXWinry are so cute!  OK rose only showed up in the beginning of the manga right?!?!  You dont see her afterwards.... why are ppl talking about her like she's some big characters. o.O

You haven't seen the anime, have you?
hitokiri
sorry guys i went with ed x roze, i don't know why but that coupling just grows on me more and more everytime i watch the series, as for non-het pairings i would go with ed x havok....i mean havok deserves someone..... biggrin.gif

i just plain hate the ed x winry idea its too idealistically midwestern 50's girl next door dribble crap for my taste, but hey to each his own
hagane_no_tokage
QUOTE(hitokiri @ Dec 4 2004, 10:37 PM)
sorry guys i went with ed x roze, i don't know why but that coupling just grows on me more and more everytime i watch the series, as for non-het pairings i would go with ed x havok....i mean havok deserves someone..... biggrin.gif

*raises hand and waves it around* havoc deserves me! MEEE! XD wub.gif
Queen of the dammed
I HAVE PROOF THAT ED REALLY LIKES WINRY!!!!! XXXDDDDDD There was once which he said that WInry was cute, and there was this other time which he got all edgy and tense when Roy was flirting with her.... tongue.gif
telepika
I'm not that much of an EdxWinry fan, but how about that time when Winry says she'll braid Ed's hair and he blushes. Doesn't that show some more than friendship affection?

As for EdxRose, that still disgusts me. I stick to what I said before!!
Hex-Sama
@Queen of the dammed and Telepika: ohmy.gif YES! biggrin.gif Solid evidence of Edward/Winry! I agree. Some people say they're just friends... I say they're friends... with benefits. laugh.gif
Kihaku
Oh yes.. there seem to be hints. I never really notice those tongue.gif It seems though that the most plausible person Ed would pair up with is Winry..but to me it seems just so "well let's pair him with someone". I don't know..
Interesting...Ed& Rose is getting popular as is Ed&Roy....
DarkWarrior
QUOTE(Ninie @ Dec 4 2004, 10:02 PM)

You haven't seen the anime, have you?

No... No i haven't sleep.gif;

QUOTE
I'm not that much of an EdxWinry fan, but how about that time when Winry says she'll braid Ed's hair and he blushes. Doesn't that show some more than friendship affection?


When was that? in the manga i hope biggrin.gif
Udon
In the anime, Ed and Al are reminiscing about their childhoods, and one of the things mentioned is them debating over who gets to marry Winly...So...yeah, it may just be childhood banter, but if ever there was supposed to be a pairing, that would be it.

Plus, Winly's no one to be snuffed at, looks-wise tongue.gif
Ailuro
Sorry, Kase, EdxRussellxEd got only 2 votes.
Next time, eh? wink.gif
Omakase Shimasu
Oh well, didn't really think it would happen since the poll does have the EdxWinry pairing in it.... Hey, you actually did this because I was curious? *__* Wow, thank you~
Kihaku
There's still hope! biggrin.gif To think that EdxRussellxEd would have only got 1 if you hadn't decided to go over to my side biggrin.gif I'm happy for even those two votes!
Ailuro
QUOTE(Omakase Shimasu @ Dec 21 2004, 02:17 PM)
Oh well, didn't really think it would happen since the poll does have the EdxWinry pairing in it.... Hey, you actually did this because I was curious? *__* Wow, thank you~

It was no problem! Really! xD

I was also curious. Since you mentioned it, the curiosity was eating away at me. But yeah, I was in a nice mood I guess.. happy.gif;
Omakase Shimasu
biggrin.gif It's appreciated. Well, who knows? Maybe this will get the shonen-ai pairings more votes, although I doubt that... Most AS viewer would of course vote for EdxWinry. There's still a chance.
Shaman_Girl88
EdxHavoc! EdxHavoc! Pardon me while I go throw up at the thought of that. I voted for EdxWinry.
Kihaku
You shouldn't have... Noo... EdxHavoc would have been a good option! Wait. EdxHavoc?
Omakase Shimasu
Squick! ph34r.gif Surely you meant HavocxEd.

That reminds me of a gorgeous fanart/doujinshi I saw of these two. *__* Well, actually it was a twisted kind of threesome between these two and Roy. ^.^ Sweet.

Russell still only got two votes though... And Roy four. T.T How disappointing.
Kihaku
Even Envy&Ed get more votes than Ed&Russell... no fair! tongue.gif Roy&Ed are in the lead of the shonen-ai pairings
Huh? Where did you read the doujinshi? *eyes start gleaming*
xrninja
QUOTE(Omakase Shimasu @ Dec 22 2004, 06:39 AM)
Squick! ph34r.gif Surely you meant HavocxEd.

That reminds me of a gorgeous fanart/doujinshi I saw of these two. *__* Well, actually it was a twisted kind of threesome between these two and Roy. ^.^ Sweet.

Russell still only got two votes though... And Roy four. T.T How disappointing.

pardon me while i get the straitjacke--i mean, uniforms for the crack-pairing rehab school i'm shipping you to.


i may have to ship kihaku off too. rolleyes.gif
Kihaku
Oh, I'm perfectly sane rolleyes.gif .
Crack-pairing? laugh.gif Huh, what do you mean by that? *innocent stare*
hakai-kun
l0l. at least everyone got at least 1 vote? XD

ew... EdxRoze is in 2nd place! dry.gif
tongue.gif Yes, Kase. we need more RussellxEd love, ne?
suger_snake
1.edxenvy
2.edxrose
3.edxwirny



got to love em all
Omakase Shimasu
QUOTE(hakai-kun @ Dec 22 2004, 11:31 PM)
l0l. at least everyone got at least 1 vote? XD

ew... EdxRoze is in 2nd place! dry.gif
tongue.gif Yes, Kase. we need more RussellxEd love, ne?

Oooooh, are you implying delicious RussellxEd fanfics there~? X3 Did you, did you?

@xrninja: ph34r.gif I thought we were friends despite my bad habits. Traitor~ tongue.gif (Actually, I didn't know it was that much of a crack-pairing ^^;;)
telepika
At least it wasn't EdxChimera Tucker... biggrin.gif *Hides* Don't start endorsing that now ok. Kihaku? Kase? Don't ok. Don't.

Why the hey did I bring it up in the first place...
Omakase Shimasu
Even though I barely get squicked by anything anymore, that really did it. ph34r.gif No way am I open-minded enough to brave that particular pairing. So no worries, telepika, you won't be hearing anything from me about "it". ^^v
telepika
Glad to hear it Kase! My my, I can't even imagine that pairing... *Tries to imagine* Date, kissing... AHHHH!!!

I think I need a break. And to anyone who threw up, I'm sorry... sorry... I should go.
Kasumi
And to think I read the post at 11:46PM... Don't worry, telepika, I didn't throw up, I'm just terribly scarred, that's all. =P

tongue.gif
Kihaku
telepika: You're asking for it.... tongue.gif No just kidding... I don't particulary like that pairing. Tucker will anyway end up transmuting Ed with something tongue.gif
Although let's say...I'm not against it if anyone likes that pairing..
Apperently no-one here does...tongue.gif
Omakase Shimasu
Oh, yes, sorry if I've offended anyone by my earlier comment. (Although that's probably very unlikely ^^;;) I won't be "bashing" anyone who has any interest in that particular pairing. ^^v

Although I once thought about human!Tucker and Edward... That was in the manga, by the way. tongue.gif
telepika
Kase... Kihaku... I shouldn't have brought it up. ph34r.gif
xrninja
QUOTE(Omakase Shimasu @ Dec 28 2004, 12:14 PM)
Although I once thought about human!Tucker and Edward... That was in the manga, by the way. tongue.gif

i saw a multi-chaptered fic somewhere on the fm_alchemist lj community awhile back where tucker and ed switched bodies....i didn't last through it long enough to find out if there was any tucker/ed, though, because the tucker-in-ed's-body/envy scene scared me away XP i think it was called "changed for good"?
Omakase Shimasu
ph34r.gif Those two switching bodies is flat-out creepy. And Envy mixed up in it all = not good. Envy mixed up in anything generally isn't good. tongue.gif (Is everybody a part of the LJ community or what??)

I couldn't help myself regarding the official manga though. Tucker and his shady eyes... ph34r.gif
Kihaku
telepika: Now worries biggrin.gif At least we can't be blamed now wink.gif (just kidding)

ooh.. Tucker and Ed switching bodies.. now I don't really know what to think. No wait, I do, but I'm not sharing it tongue.gif
telepika
blink.gif;; (I want to say something even though I have nothing to say... To raise my post count you ask? No, although that would be nice. laugh.gif I'm a newbie at heart. Anyway, I wanted to respond to Kihaku's post but I have nothing to say so I thought I would leave this message to confuse you people instead. wink.gif I know I'm so cruel... and weird).
Kihaku
telepika: I know how to be so "final" that I leave people speechless tongue.gif
heh, and you're not wierd.. I mean...if we're talking about wierd, I'd be a good example.. tongue.gif

LJ community? I just remember that now tongue.gif What is that?
Queen of the dammed
Brr..... the people over there think of these wierd crack pairings.... some of them crack me up but.... some just freak me out.... blink.gif e.g GluttonyXHuges????? Com'on, I know how lovable they are but.... I'm just a stalker there....
Omakase Shimasu
QUOTE(Kihaku @ Dec 31 2004, 12:29 PM)
LJ community? I just remember that now tongue.gif What is that?

Live Journal. wink.gif Kinda like a diary + forum mix. tongue.gif Sorry, don't know how to explain this one.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.