Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning Project! (link Index To Discussion Threads And Other Info On The First Post!) First Time Readers Welcome Also!
Fullmetal Alchemist Discussion Board > Fullmetal Alchemist Discussions > Fullmetal Alchemist Manga > Re-reading FMA manga
Pages: 1, 2
Tombow
* "Reading reference" for chapter 108 is now ready!
Please send a PM to A Pierrot's Aria and ask for "Reading Reference Assistance for chapter 108."

(For the explanation on the use of STANDARD reading reference for our sessions, please read here. ^^)

The FMA manga re-reading project officially kicked off on July 11, 2010. The chapter discussion threads will be opened every Sunday.
Each week we’ll be discussing 1 chapter per week.
Additionally, we may have some reading sessions for related "gaiden" also. smile.gif


>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

The reading sessions are open to any FMA fans, those who have read FMA manga through chapter 108 (series final chapter) AND including those who are reading FMA manga first time. (We'll have separate discussion threads to avoid spoiling first time readers about the "future" storyline. ^^)

However, we will have separate discussion threads for those who had already read FMA manga through chapter 108, and those who have not, to prevent spoilers. (Anyone who is interested in reading my long-winded explanation on how we handle this, please read my post here. ^^)

Hope you'll all join our reading-sessions, and see your posts on those threads!! biggrin.gif

This week's discussion threads are:
FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 103, Chapter 108 discussion thread *Current session
Chapter 108 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) *Current session

>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

You can also add your posts on "past" discussion threads ANYTIME! Please feel free to add your posts on these following threads anytime. biggrin.gif

Please join us on these re-reading session discussion threads!
Volume 27.
FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 103, Chapter 108 discussion thread *Current session

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 102, Chapter 107 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)


Volume 26.
FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 101, Chapter 106 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)


FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 100, Chapter 105 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 99, Chapter 104 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Volume 25.
FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 98, Chapter 103 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)


FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 97, Chapter 102 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 96, Chapter 101 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 95, Chapter 100 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Volume 24.
FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 94, Chapter 99 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 93, Chapter 98 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 92, Chapter 97 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 91, Chapter 96 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Volume 23.
FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 90, Chapter 95 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)


FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 89, Chapter 94 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 88, Chapter 93 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 87, Chapter 92 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Volume 22.
FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 86, Chapter 91 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)


FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 85, Chapter 90 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 84, Chapter 89 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 83, Chapter 88 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Volume 21.
FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 82, Chapter 87 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 81, Chapter 86 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 80, Chapter 85 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 79, Chapter 84 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Volume 20.
FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 78, Chapter 83 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)


FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 77, Chapter 82 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 76, Chapter 81 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 75, Chapter 80 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 74, Chapter 79 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Volume 19.
FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 73, Chapter 78 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 72, Chapter 77 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 71, Chapter 76 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 70, Chapter 75 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 69, Chapter 74 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Volume 18.
FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 68, Chapter 73 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 67, Chapter 72 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 66, Chapter 71 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 65, Chapter 70 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Volume 17.
FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 64, Chapter 69 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 63, Chapter 68 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 62, Chapter 67 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 61, Chapter 66 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Volume 16.
FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 60, Chapter 65 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)


FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 59, Chapter 64 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 58, Chapter 63 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 57, Chapter 62 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Volume 15.
FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 56, Chapter 61 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 55, Chapter 60 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 54, Chapter 59 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 53, Chapter 58 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Volume 14.
FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 52, Chapter 57 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 51, Chapter 56 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 50, Chapter 55 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 49, Chapter 54 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Volume 13.
FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 48, Chapter 53 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 47, Chapter 52 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 46, Chapter 51 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 45, Chapter 50 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Volume 12.
FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 44, Chapter 49 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 43, Chapter 48 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 42, Chapter 47 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 41, Chapter 46 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Volume 11.
FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 40, Chapter 45 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 39, Chapter 44 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 38, Chapter 43 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 37, Chapter 42 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Volume 10.
FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 36, Chapter 41 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 35, Chapter 40 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 34, Chapter 39 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 33, Chapter 38 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Volume 9.
FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 32, Chapter 37 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 31, Chapter 36 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 30, Chapter 35 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 29, Chapter 34 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Volume 8.
FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 28, Chapter 33 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 27, Chapter 32 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 26, Chapter 31 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 25, Chapter 30 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Volume 7.
FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 24, Chapter 29 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 23, Chapter 28 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 22, Chapter 27 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add yor posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 21, Chapter 26 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Volume 6.
FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 20, Chapter 25 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 19, Chapter 24 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 18, Chapter 23 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 17, Chapter 22 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Volume 5.
FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 16, Chapter 21 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 15, Chapter 20 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 14, Chapter 19 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 13, Chapter 18 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 12, Chapter 17 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Volume 4.
FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 11, Chapter 16 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 10, Chapter 15 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 9, Chapter 14 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 8, Chapter 13 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Volume 3.
FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 7, Chapter 12 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 6, Chapter 11 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 5, Chapter 10 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)
FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 5, Chapter 9 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Volume 2.
FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 4, Chapter 8 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)
FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 4, Chapter 7 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 3, Chapter 6 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)
FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 3, Chapter 5 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Volume 1.
FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 2, Chapter 4 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 2, Chapter 3 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 1, Chapter 2 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)
FMA Manga Re-read It From The Beginning, Session 1, Chapter 1 discussion thread (Re-readers, please feel free to add your posts here also!)

==============


For those who are reading the chapter first time, please join our discussions on the following thread:
Volume 27.
Chapter 108 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) *Current session

Chapter 107 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)


Volume 26.
Chapter 106 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)


Chapter 105 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 104 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Volume 25.
Chapter 103 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)


Chapter 102 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 101 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 100 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Volume 24.
Chapter 99 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 98 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 97 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 96 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Volume 23.
Chapter 95 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)


Chapter 94 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 93 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 92 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Volume 22.
Chapter 91 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)


Chapter 90 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 89 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 88 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Volume 21.
Chapter 87 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 86 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 85 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 84 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Volume 20.
Chapter 83 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)


Chapter 81 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 80 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 79 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Volume 19.
Chapter 78 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 77 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 76 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 75 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 74 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Volume 18.
Chapter 73 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 72 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 71 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 70 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Volume 17.
Chapter 69 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 68 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 67 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 66 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Volume 16.
Chapter 65 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)


Chapter 64 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 63 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 62 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Volume 15.
Chapter 61 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 60 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 59 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 58 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Volume 14.
Chapter 57 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 56 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 55 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 54 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Volume 13.
Chapter 53 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 52 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 51 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 50 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Volume 12.
Chapter 49 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 48 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 47 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 46 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Volume 11.
Chapter 45 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 44 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 43 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 42 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Volume 10.
Chapter 41 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 40 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 39 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 38 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Volume 9.
Chapter 37 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 36 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 35 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 34 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Volume 8.
Chapter 33 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 32 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 31 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 30 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Volume 7.
Chapter 29 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 28 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 27 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 26 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Volume 6.
Chapter 25 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 24 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 23 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 22 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Volume 5.
Chapter 21 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 20 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 19 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 18 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 17 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Volume 4.
Chapter 16 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 15 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 14 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 13 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Volume 3.
Chapter 12 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 11 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 10 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)
Chapter 9 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Volume 2.
Chapter 8 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)
Chapter 7 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 6 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)
Chapter 5 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Volume 1.
Chapter 4 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 3 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

Chapter 2 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)
Chapter 1 discussion thread (For First Time Readers) (Please feel free to add your posts here also!)

>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>



-------
Reading schedule for July and August, 2011:

Session 52 (July 3 – July 9): Vol. 14 – Chapter 57: "Scars of Ishbal"
Session 53 (July 10 – July 16): Vol. 15 – Chapter 58: "The Footsteps of Ruin"
Session 54 (July 17 – July 23): Vol. 15 – Chapter 59: "The Immoral Alchemist"
Session 55 (July 24 – July 30): Vol. 15 – Chapter 60: "In the Absence of God"
Session 56 (July 31 – Aug. 6): Vol. 15 – Chapter 61: "The Hero of Ishbal"
Session 57 (Aug. 7 – Aug. 13): Vol. 16 – Chapter 62: "Beyond the Dream"
Session 58 (Aug. 14 – Aug. 20): Vol. 16 – Chapter 63: "The Promise Made for 520 Cenz"
Session 59 (Aug. 21 – Aug. 27): Vol. 16 – Chapter 64: "The Northern Wall of Briggs"
Session 60 (Aug. 28 – Sept. 3): Vol. 16 – Chapter 65: "The Ironclad Rule"


Reading schedule for July

Week 1: July 11 – July 17.
Vol1-Chapter 1 “The Two Alchemists”
Vol1-Chapter 2 “The Price of Life”

Week 2: July 18 – July 24.
Vol 1-Chapter 3 “The Mining Town”
Vol 1-Chapter 4 “Battle on the Train”

Week 3: July 25 – July 31.
Vol 2-Chapter 5 “The Alchemist's Suffering”
Vol 2-Chapter 6 “The Right Hand of Destruction”

-----------------------------

Reading schedule for August

Week 4: Aug. 1 – Aug. 7.
Vol 2-Chapter 7 “After the Rain”
Vol 2-Chapter 8 “The Road of Hope”

Week 5: Aug. 8 – Aug. 14.
Vol 3-Chapter 9 “A Home with a Family Waiting”
Vol 3-Chapter 10 “The Philosopher’s Stone”

Week 6: Aug 15 – Aug. 21.
Vol 3-Chapter 11 “The Two Guardians”
Vol 3-Chapter 12 “The Definition of Human”

Week 7: Aug. 22 – Aug 28.
Vol 4-Chapter 13 “Fullmetal Body”
Vol 4-Chapter 14 “An Only Child’s Feelings”

Week 8: Aug. 29 – Sept. 4.
Vol 4-Chapter 15 “Fullmetal Heart”
Vol 4-Chapter 16 “Separate Paths”


---

ETA: Aug. 15, 2010 by Michiyo-
Some small changes regarding the Re-reading Project:

Starting from this Sunday for the following 4 weeks there’ll be only one chapter per week to discuss. Many members of the board are on vacation or simply don’t have time to participate in the project. By slowing down there’ll be time for them to re-read the chapters and catch up with the discussions.

So here’s the schedule for the following 4 weeks:
Session 6 (Aug. 15 – Aug. 21): Vol. 3 – Chapter 11 “The Two Guardians”
Session 7 (Aug. 22 – Aug. 28.): Vol. 3 - Chapter 12 “The Definition of Human”
Session 8 (Aug. 29. – Sept. 4): Vol. 4 - Chapter 13. “Fullmetal Body”
Session 9 (Sept. 5. – Sept. 11): Vol. 4 - Chapter 14: “An Only Child’s Feelings”


We hope to see more members participating in the project and posting their thoughts, opinions about the chapters. ^^
Causmicfire
Mangahelpers has the raws for the volumes(up to 25 atm) over on their site, available for download/online reading.
AA battery
I guess I can revive the links in my RAW thread once the series is over... *cries*
Vlyse
Would each discussion be a spoiler party for all 108 chapters, or just the chapter being discussed at the time?
Broken Chouchou
It's been a LONG time since I reread FMA. This sounds like fun :P

But ONE chapter per week? That's so slow! Couldn't it be one... per day? XD

Ok, I realize that wouldn't work, obviously. But how about designating 2 - 3 days or something like that for each chapter, to keep waiting to a minimum, but still give people time to discuss? Still too little? ^^
Flamez_Freak
I agree wit broken chouchou . . His idea is more , fan friendly smile.gif smile.gif i still can't believe fma is ending for good . . Its been such a long journey sad.gif . Sad to see it end like that sad.gif
Thalogens
I like the idea of 1 per week. 7 days is a nice number happy.gif
Plus, 1/week is better than 1/month.
RoyxRizaFan
I like one per week, just because...well...I don't want this to eeend T_T I cannot let go! I cannot move on with my life! I will miss not only the best manga ever written, but all the awesome people on this forum who make it so fun to discuss it!

So yeah, I'm definitely going to do this, because because I can never let it sink in that FMA's ending XD
Edamame
I think that this sounds like a wonderful idea! I have had to sorely neglect posting on this forum for a while now, due to graduate school hunting. Now that I am finally in graduate school (yes, I am going to be living in a box for eternity), I would really love to participate in the re-reading of FMA; I can not let go of a good thing too soon. I agree with everybody that one chapter per week sounds more than manageable. I have tried to read other manga to fill the dark void that FMA is going to leave, but nothing quite strikes the same way as FMA has done. It will certainly be fun to reread it again, and pick up on all the plot points and hidden clues that I missed before.
Chiyo
I think one per week is perfectly reasonable for those of us who have lives outside of manga (children/jobs/educational commitments). Just one a day, or even a couple of days, simply would not leave enough time for people to discuss thoroughly, which is what we are trying to encourage.

I for one look forward to it. Not only does it make our dear FMA last a little longer, like Tombow said we might also miss clues we never spotted the first time round. Arakawa is a clever writer and has sneaked things in before that have gone missed by many.
sidekick.kep37
Yeah, I'm with the one per week thing. Granted, that means it would take us a bit over two years to get through the whole thing, but hey, it'll get us through the withdrawal. And I'll be done with high school by the time we're finished and going through my upperclassmen years in high school without FMA will not be fun ._.

I have official English translations from VIZ we could use for reference. I only have volumes 2-18, with the exception of 14 and 15 (ironically they were my two favorites that went missing two years ago) but I've gotta scrounge around the house for a bit to find some of them, since there was a time when I carried my favorite volumes with me everywhere. tongue.gif
redfirelily
That's a great idea! I've always wanted to re-read the series to make clear some chapters that I don't remember much at the moment and to spot the foreshadowings!It'd be more fun to discuss it here! ^^
Kasumisty
I like the idea. Will participate, however I cannot gurantee I will be there to the end.
Broken Chouchou
I can cover those volumes missing from sidekick's collection, should it be needed. Got vol. 1 - 22 so far. Will get 23 in August.

And yes, that was sort of my point, that it will take two years to finish this thing. That, and that a chapter takes 10 minutes to read and a week is 10. 080 minutes. But I guess that about withdrawal is a good point. As little pain in the process as possible would the preferred choice tongue.gif
Chiyo
Okay, perhaps you are right about how long it would take to read them all one by one.

As my own personal suggestion, to be discussed with Tombow and other mods later, what if we tried covering two chapters per week? The chapters are shorter to begin with so this may be feasible to start with, maybe changing to one per week as they become longer.

What do people think of that?
Michiyo-
I thought about it too, that we can discuss 2 chapters per week, and maybe when we'll get to the final arc of the story (from Vol. 21, the chapters after the timeskip) we can do one chapter per week.

My other idea is that chapters which belong together, for example the Lior arc (chapter 1-2) , or the Rush Valley arc (chapters 17-19) can be discussed on the same week.
Flamez_Freak
I agree wit chiyo . 2 per week works best .
1st discussion of the week on sunday (because we're used to discussing stuff on sunday because of brotherhood)
we'll decide about the 2nd one later smile.gif
how does that sound ppl smile.gif
Thalogens
^I think its better we start when its finished, it just makes sense... it would be like a circle (I like circles); we finish the last chapter and then start with the first. Like an ouroborus tattoo.

I like the idea of grouped discussions, though it might not work near the end where it's just one long arc that moulds into itself blah blah... I suppose by then we could resort back to a 1/2 a week thingy.
Flamez_Freak
^Oh yes , i know that (tombow has already mentioned that these discussions will start from july) . I just gave a suggestion , that we have one of the 2 discussions on sunday . Cause we're all used to having a discussion on sunday smile.gif
Thalogens
Ahh, I see what you mean. Misunderstanding on my part :S
Flamez_Freak
My apologies though . I should have been a tad more clear . I was just a bit excited . So didn't know what i was typing smile.gif
deet-tastic
Can I do both XP
Read it up to 107 and then 108. And then go back and read them all? HAHA!!
FailToImpress
I'm definitely up for this.

I think the suggestion about 2 chapters a week for starters, then one a week as they become longer/deeper is a good idea. If we only did one a week we'd be here for 2 years and I can't say for definite if I'll last that long! I'd just end up impatient and reading them all consecutively over a very short time. tongue.gif
hand-made-city
Count me in! I'd love to re-read the whole manga and discuss it entirely... that's something I wasn't able to do, since I came into the fandom when we were around chapter 80-something.
FMAobsessed
Oooh discussing the manga from the beginning sounds fun. Because even though I have been following FMA since like 2004, I didn't read the chapters online, I only bought the manga volumes.
Dark_Fishie
I (seem to) remember a re-read project on LJ from ages ago (3 yr ago, maybe?) that is no longer active. Will anyone be offended if the LJ re-read project's info and data are used here, or is this re-read project going to be a pure, fresh project?
BirdieNumNum
^I think I know which LJ community you're talking about. I really enjoyed reading through their thoughts on the chapters, even if I didn't participate in it.

As for a re-read of the whole manga, you can count me in. I didn't get into the manga until fairly late in the game (around the time of the Pride reveal) so I'd love to discuss some of the early chapters with the people here. Besides, with no more chapters coming out, I'm going to be suffering serious withdrawals, so having this to look forward to will help wean me off gradually. laugh.gif

Doing two chapters a week to start with sounds like a good idea, otherwise, as people have said, we'd be here for over two years.

One question: Will we be doing the gaidens too, or just sticking to the main chapters?
AA battery
QUOTE (Dark_Fishie @ Jun 9 2010, 04:44 PM) *
I (seem to) remember a re-read project on LJ from ages ago (3 yr ago, maybe?) that is no longer active. Will anyone be offended if the LJ re-read project's info and data are used here, or is this re-read project going to be a pure, fresh project?


I think it is better to re-read from the start, as this is meant to be done AFTER everyone has read 108. For the old project, people didn't re-read the FMA story in its completion, so the previous re-read project and this new re-read project is totally different.



I agree with starting at 2 chapters per week and then eventually switching over to 1 chapter per week idea.
hawkflame
Sounds like a fun idea. I'm marathoning the entire series through 107 right now before getting to 108 (just started chapter 29) so a lot of the earlier chapters will still be fresh in my head by the time this project starts. I too got into the FMA fandom relatively late, first watching it maybe a little more than a year ago and only caught up with everyone on the manga come chapter 101.
Animeoldtimer
I like the idea of two chapters per week. It will keep the discussion lively and give time for those of us with other commitments. I look forward to it especially since I didn't start here when chapter 1 when it first came out.


OT:
I'm curious to know what chapter the manga was on when everyone first came to this site. smile.gif
(Please post the answer on Your Reflections/thoughts On The Fma Manga Series Being Concluded thread. smile.gif )
Dark_Fishie
As it seems my previous post with both "on-topic" and "off-topic" content was moved to another thread, I'm posting the "on-topic" content again:

On-Topic: regarding "FMA manga re-reding from beginning" project.
I think 2 chapters per week is good time wise. However, I think there should be flexibility with the schedule to allow weeks with one chapter discussions so that we are not splitting up two episode arcs into two separate weeks.
Tombow
^ @Dark_Fishie - Yeah, I was posting "moved-posts note" when my Net connection went down. The connection is still bad and I can't do copy-pasting of destination thread where the moved post went, etc. at the moment, so I'll finish that post later. Sorry about that. ^^

And, along with it I lost my almost-done-composing reply post for the project related discussions when my Net connection went down.
I will re-write it later when my Net connection improves. smile.gif
Kasumisty
When the re-reading will start?
RoyxRizaFan
Maybe we can start it after the next two episodes are aired, so we don't have to worry about spoilers...??? And that way we can drag out the FMA experience just a little bit longer tongue.gif
Tombow
Quick response so that my computer wouldn't eat my post...>.<

QUOTE (Kasumisty @ Jun 23 2010, 06:39 AM) *
When the re-reading will start?

QUOTE (RoyxRizaFan @ Jun 23 2010, 10:30 AM) *
Maybe we can start it after the next two episodes are aired, so we don't have to worry about spoilers...??? And that way we can drag out the FMA experience just a little bit longer tongue.gif

First off, I apologize for my tardiness and the late late reply! So sorry.... sad.gif
I read the thread, and would like to thank you everyone for great inputs!!
I agree with others that it will be a good idea that we will basically proceed with 2 chapters per week, but also maintain the flexibility... that sounds reasonable to me also. ^^

As for the starting date, I agree with RoyxRizaFan's opinion above and considering that we'll have the final episode of FMA:Brotherhood (Japanese) on Sunday July 4 in Japan, followed by the official English subbed final episode of FMA:B being uploaded on Funimation website on Thursday, July 8, and hence I would like to suggest the starting date to be the week of July 11th. This will give us the first week of July (week of June 27) and week of July 4 to concentrate on the discussions for the final 2 episodes of FMA:Brotherhood anime series. smile.gif

I will address Vlyse's question later and explain how we may proceed with the discussions.
Also, Broken Chouchou and a few others, please wait for my PM. ^^
Animeoldtimer
Thanks, Tombow. The 11th sounds good. Sorry for going off topic there.
Tombow
^ No problem, Animeoldtimer! ^^ (Actually, that was a nice topic, and if you'd like to open a separate discussion thread for that, I think that night work. ^^)

QUOTE (Dark_Fishie @ Jun 9 2010, 07:44 PM) *
I (seem to) remember a re-read project on LJ from ages ago (3 yr ago, maybe?) that is no longer active. Will anyone be offended if the LJ re-read project's info and data are used here, or is this re-read project going to be a pure, fresh project?

@Dark_Fishie - Yeah, I really wanted to join that one, but never got around to it. ^^
I think we'd like to do fresh, but anyone was participating in that LJ re-reading project, and wouldn't mind sharing info and inputs from that project, please do, and such sharing would be appreciated. happy.gif


QUOTE (Vlyse @ Jun 5 2010, 06:29 AM) *
Would each discussion be a spoiler party for all 108 chapters, or just the chapter being discussed at the time?

@Vlyse - Excellent question! ^^ And, here is my current idea on this.
"Read it from chapter 1" project will be open to all FMA fans, including those who have not read FMA manga yet and this is their first time reading it. However...

We'll have SEPARATE discussion threads for those who have already read later chapters, and for those who are reading it first time.

For those who are reading FMA manga first time, we'll bring up our regular Chapter discussion thread for that chapter. Yes, we'll dust up and bring up old chapter discussion threads XD (if any.. because in the early days in this forum we did not have discussion threads for every chapter. In those cases, we'll create a new chapter discussion thread for that chapter.)
For those who have read later chapters and participating in the re-reading of the chapter CAN post and join the regular chapter discussion thread for that chapter also, such as, "I love how Ed talks to Roy here..." etc., etc., but NO REVEALING of later chapter content such as "You see a couple in that train station? Wait till you get to chapter so and so..." or "Pay attention to what Ed says in page 27 because later on... " and so on. Making those type of SPOILING postings on regular chapter discussion threads will be absolutely prohibited. Period.

Besides that, each week, we'll open "Now I know! re-reading chapter xxx" (this thread title is tentative XD) discussion thread for each chapter we re-visit. Those who haven't read later chapters and willingly wish to be spoiled can read and join the discussions there also, but these threads are geared for those who have already read FMA at least once and hence, while we are discussing that week's chapter content on that thread it is all right to bring up related incidents etc. from the later chapter on that thread, as long as the main focus of the discussion is still the content of that chapter we are reading that week. The thread will be "Spoiler Party" as far as the use of Spoiler tags for the content for any chapters, meaning if you refer events from later chapters you don't have to use Spoiler tags, except for the content from chapter 108, the final chapter, and we ask you to use SPOILER TAGs if you bring up the content from chapter 108, at least for now.

We'll probably open separate such thread for each chapter we read, for example, if we read chapter 1 and chapter 2 in the first week, we will open "Now I know! re-reading chapter 1" discussion thread and "Now I know! re-reading chapter 2" discussion thread at the beginning of the project week. And everyone is free to post on these threads whole week, and later on also if anyone wishes. Eventually, tho, we might bunch/merge these discussion threads later... undecided on this yet. ^^

In addition, you CAN revisit the regular chapter discussion thread (as in, not "Now I know" threads) for later chapters and point out events in the earlier chapter that may be connected to the events in that later chapter, and if you wish, you can delve into further discussions on those later happening on those later chapter discussion thread as we "discover" new twist/hints/clues/additional info etc. in the earlier chapters.

EXAMPLE: let's say, if we are doing "Re-reading" for chapter 15, in addition to "Re-reading chapter 15" discussion thread, we can bring up what happened in chapter 15 such as, newly discovered "connection" to the later events, etc. on relevant regular chapter discussion threads for chapters 16 - 108, IF that event has any relevance to the content in that later chapter. But, you can NOT bring that event and post that on regular chapter discussion threads for chapters 1 - 14.

...

Sorry for the lengthy/wordy explanation. Hope this clears up some questions and not making everyone confused even more. xp

Any questions and/or if you have more thoughts and inputs, that would be appreciated. ^^

ETA: Anyone who has Viz' s official English volumes for vol 14, 15, 21, 22 (any part of these) please post here or PM me and let me know. ^^
Nacchan
*__* This is great, I can't wait it for the start ;_;! (even if this should mean fma is really ended.T_T)
Michiyo-
I’m posting the reading schedules for July and August. As Tombow suggested, the re-reading project will start on July 11, and the chapter discussion threads will be opened every Sunday. Each week we’ll be discussing 2 chapters. When we get to the longer chapters (maybe starting from chapter 100 or 104), we can discuss 1 chapter per week.

Reading schedule for July

Week 1: July 11 – July 17.
Chapter 1 “The Two Alchemists”
Chapter 2 “The Price of Life”

Week 2: July 18 – July 24.
Chapter 3 “The Mining Town”
Chapter 4 “Battle on the Train”

Week 3: July 25 – July 31.
Chapter 5 “The Alchemist's Suffering”
Chapter 6 “The Right Hand of Destruction”


Reading schedule for August

Week 4: Aug. 1 – Aug. 7.
Chapter 7 “After the Rain”
Chapter 8 “The Road of Hope”

Week 5: Aug. 8 – Aug. 14.
Chapter 9 “A Home with a Family Waiting”
Chapter 10 “The Philosopher’s Stone”

Week 6: Aug 15 – Aug. 21.
Chapter 11 “The Two Guardians”
Chapter 12 “The Definition of Human”

Week 7: Aug. 22 – Aug 28.
Chapter 13 “Fullmetal Body”
Chapter 14 “An Only Child’s Feelings”

Week 8: Aug. 29 – Sept. 4.
Chapter 15 “Fullmetal Heart”
Chapter 16 “Separate Paths”

The Stubborn Alchemist
Omg this really is the best idea ever! These forums make me so happy! I don't know anyone in my area who reads FMA so... It's kind of hard beacause I want to talk about every FMA thing, but I just can't ohmy.gif
Sorry for going off topic ... I needed to say this smile.gif
amestris_star
@Michiyo: That sounds awesome, and I love the idea actually - will keep me busy tongue.gif
animegirl95
COUNT ME IN!!! I knew it was a good idea to buy every volume so far!
StormGoddess
guess I'll join the re-reading to keep me busy. Sad thing that only a few volumes are available here so I'm gonna read scanlations, Viz, and CY volumes. unsure.gif
Edamame
I do not know if we are still in need of official volumes, but I have volumes one and nineteen on hand. (Yeah, odd combo there. I will have to search my room and see if I can find some of the other English volumes that I bought.)

*Σαβριvα~Λεα*
A re-reading is just what the doctor ordered now that the fabulous series is, regretfully, coming to and end! *sobs*
Hiromu Arakawa is right up there with the greatest writers of all time! Count me in for the re-reading session!
Shandorian
For all who needs copies, OneManga has them all.Please try to avoid using fan-made scanlations for the Re-reading sessions on our board. If you need assistance, please watch out for further notice for such assistance. smile.gif

Can't wait!
Rentanjutsushi
Count me in! It sounds like fun - I've been meaning to re-read the series.
mellulah
Count me in. I normally reread them all the time anyway but it'll be great to have a group to discuss it with.
Causmicfire
Ooh, it's getting close to re-read time!

I'll make sure to pop in for that.
Hagaren-Shiroi
Count me In wink.gif
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.