Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Fullmetal Alchemist "Character Guide" Book
Fullmetal Alchemist Discussion Board > Fullmetal Alchemist Discussions > Fullmetal Alchemist Manga
Pages: 1, 2, 3
Tombow
QUOTE (AA battery @ Jun 12 2009, 04:03 AM) *
Actually, those names were in Perfect Guidebook 2 as well (which I bought). I mentioned them in the forum a long while ago but no one seemed to believe me. =P If you look at posts from over a year ago you may find them... xD

@AA battery - No, no, I do remember your saying that and I did believe you then that those were in the Perfect Guide, but since that publisher also had a history of making some bad translation mistakes on other FMA stuff (coughMustangas"Fire Alchemist"cough) I've been rather lax with my character name spellings. (Bad of me >.<) But yeah, I should start getting used to Mr. Who (it keeps reminding me of "Dr. Who," the sci-fi series XD) and Solf J Kimblee..

@Kale Mustang, or anyone with the Character Book - When you get around to it (please take your time with this one ^^) if you could make a list of character names (ALL the ones who has the English spelling included on the page) that would be very VERY much appreciated by me. happy.gif
Kale Mustang
Sure. Like I said, most of the major characters (though there are a few minor characters) have their names spelled out in English but a majority don't.

But I can probably get the list together pretty quickly once I get home from work.
crazyanimefan
QUOTE (Kirara @ Jun 12 2009, 06:35 AM) *
I am going to have to condition myself to spell the Xing characters' names like Lin, May, & RanFun it's going to be hard after so long spelling them like Ling, Mei, and Ranfan.

And is Fuu really spelled Who?


Same here. I feel weird just looking at them right now, as ridiculous as that sounds.
Full Metal Elf
T__T I hope they release another English edition of these books! We need a new one! lol
Tombow
^ @Full Metal Elf - I second that. ^^

QUOTE (Kale Mustang @ Jun 12 2009, 03:05 PM) *
Sure. Like I said, most of the major characters (though there are a few minor characters) have their names spelled out in English but a majority don't.

But I can probably get the list together pretty quickly once I get home from work.

@Kale Mustang - Huge "thank you" in advance!!!! happy.gif

And, I will try to get some of the scanned pages translated after I do some of the FMA:B "news" translations. ^^
kkg22104
Sorry for the delayed response, but thank you so much Kale for scanning all these pages! biggrin.gif (Now if only this stupid computer would load them faster...)

About the English spellings, that's really weird...how can Fuu = Who? That's the only one that seems more off than the others.

EDIT: I'm still confused about Ling/Lin. Check out this page: It clearly says "Ling Yao" on his nametag thing.

http://www.onemanga.com/Full_Metal_Alchemist/35/24/
Kale Mustang
Characters with English Spellings in the Character Guidebook:

Edward Elric
Alphonse Elric
Van Hohenheim
Izumi Curtis
Tim Marcoh
Winry Rockbell
Pinako Rockbell
Scar
Lin Yao (aka Ling Yao)
Ranfun (aka Ranfan)
Who (aka Fuu)
May Chang (aka Mei Chang)
Roy Mustang
Riza Hawkeye
Jean Havoc
Heymans Breda
Vato Falman
Kain Fuery
Maes Hughes
Maria Ross
Alex Louis Armstrong
Olivier Mira Armstrong
Father
Pride/Selim Bradley
Lust
Greed
Envy
Sloth
Gluttony
Wrath/King Bradley
Solf J Kimblee
No. 48/Slicer Brothers
No. 66/Barry The Chopper
Tombow
Thank you so much, Kale Mustang!! biggrin.gif
*saves the list for the reference*

QUOTE (kkg22104 @ Jun 13 2009, 12:56 AM) *
.. I'm still confused about Ling/Lin. Check out this page: It clearly says "Ling Yao" on his nametag thing.
http://www.onemanga.com/Full_Metal_Alchemist/35/24/

@kkg22104 - Good memory!! ^^ Haha, I remember that scene!
Yeah, it's confusing, isn't it? tongue.gif These spellings for Xing characters look as if some English speaking person who had no knowledge on Chinese names was consulted for the English spelling of these names, over the phone, and then just randomly assigned some English words that do sound similar to the phonetic sounding of these names. >.<
Kale Mustang
@Tombow

Not a problem. Like I said, the list is pretty small especially considering how many people are actually listed in the book.

As for the names...I just copied them down, but some of them (particularly the Xing characters) just seem completely off... mellow.gif
reef
There is 3 chapters in the guide book.
download here :

chap 2 : chap 2

chap 3 : chap 3
kkg22104
QUOTE (Tombow @ Jun 13 2009, 02:50 AM) *
@kkg22104 - Good memory!! ^^ Haha, I remember that scene!
Yeah, it's confusing, isn't it? tongue.gif These spellings for Xing characters look as if some English speaking person who had no knowledge on Chinese names was consulted for the English spelling of these names, over the phone, and then just randomly assigned some English words that do sound similar to the phonetic sounding of these names. >.<


Yeah, ever since I read that chapter, I always spelled his name "Ling" because I assumed that Arakawa knew how to spell her character's name. tongue.gif Inconsistencies really bother me...and now I'm debating about if I should spell it with the "g" or not XD
rainbowcatgirl
biggrin.gif Can't wait till this gets translated in English and sent to USA !
reef
and this is the chapter 1 : Chap 1
black~hayate
well... that's just nice, Thx, Reef...
mellulah
QUOTE (reef @ Jun 13 2009, 03:43 AM) *
There is 3 chapters in the guide book.
download here :

chap 2 : chap 2

chap 3 : chap 3


thanks reef your a star
Michiyo-
Thanks reef! It's nice to see the whole guidebook scanned. I wish I could read it...
Asagi
Woah!!!!I don't have too much time to post but THANKS reef!!!!...I really want to read it...I wish I knew japanese T__T!!!
AA battery
Hi! Just wanted to give you guys a heads-up. Since I'm back, I'll do the omake translations in a few days, so please check the Hagaren Omake Thread later for the scans happy.gif (Any volunteer for editing? If there is any, please PM me. I'm a little picky with editors, though! *shot*)
Sensenic
Ah, the names issue all over again...

QUOTE (Tombow @ Jun 13 2009, 08:50 AM) *
QUOTE (kkg22104 @ Jun 13 2009, 12:56 AM) *
.. I'm still confused about Ling/Lin. Check out this page: It clearly says "Ling Yao" on his nametag thing.
http://www.onemanga.com/Full_Metal_Alchemist/35/24/

@kkg22104 - Good memory!! ^^ Haha, I remember that scene!
Yeah, it's confusing, isn't it? tongue.gif These spellings for Xing characters look as if some English speaking person who had no knowledge on Chinese names was consulted for the English spelling of these names, over the phone, and then just randomly assigned some English words that do sound similar to the phonetic sounding of these names. >.<


Yup, that's why I'll keep going with the Chinese-looking names anyway.
I mean, May, Who, Ranfun... just no. Those are clearly transcribed so English people pronounce them right.

As for Lin/g... I guess either one's fine. Personally, I'll keep going with what the manga said.
(then again, the manga has "Selim Bladley" once or twice on it. And the 'l' came from "Lebecca" XD Clearly a spelling misstake)

EDIT:
Oh, and thanks Kale and reef for those scans!

Fairy tale omakes are laugh.gif

Also
QUOTE (AA battery @ Jun 15 2009, 10:38 AM) *
Hi! Just wanted to give you guys a heads-up. Since I'm back, I'll do the omake translations in a few days, so please check the Hagaren Omake Thread later for the scans happy.gif (Any volunteer for editing? If there is any, please PM me. I'm a little picky with editors, though! *shot*)


Yay! \o/

Double post (will get merged, I guess?) for flipping over scans...

Me comments:

- Three chapters: 1- Elrics and other good guys/civilians, first Amestrians, then Xings. 2- Mustang and the military. 3- Bad guys.
In the first one characters are ordered by chronological appearance, importance and relatedness, in that order: So, for example, Rose is the third and Cornello, technically the fourth, only appears as a minor related character. XD (The bartender is the fifth XD )

- I find the Best Scene selections very well chosen in general.

- Western transcriptions are given only for the most important (main) characters. sad.gif

Chapter 1:
- Jude the Blind Alchemist has his own little spot too. The unknown-by-the-bad-guys confirmed human sacrifice! Nice.
Nina and Shou Tucker get only a minor mention (a quarter of page) in the same page. Screw Shou, but poor Nina. sad.gif

- Hohenheim appears quite early, though... perhaps because of Trisha (who appears as Hohenheim-related, since he's more important than her)

- Marcoh and Scar's "get naked" is one of Marcoh's Best Scenes. xD

- Dominic is called a tsundere XD

- The Rich Couple gets a page! happy.gif

- Scar's weakness to all things cute is pointed out too. happy.gif

- Whole 4 pages for Yoki sama! Including his cameos (Yoki Circus... XD )

- 2 pages for Mobuo Mobuta, several (if not all) appearances. At the end, Arakawa says there are other non-introduced recurring characters?! ohmy.gif

- Brother Clay/Cray does not get no name. He was named so in the first anime, but no official name here. Too minor, I guess. tongue.gif
- Yoki's minions when he was the Feudal Lord at Youswell appear working as bartenders for Kayal's father later!! (on Mei's arrival) Nice one there!
- Ishvalan kid from the slums isn't named either, again unlike anime 1.
- Guardian A who gets killed by Barry (and thus gets volume 3's inner spine) gets a mention as such. happy.gif

- Resembool station master and wife count as recurring chars too. Cute. happy.gif
(Ekio san and Ekiko san XDDD )


Chapter 2:

- To Be Continued... (or not, go figure. tongue.gif )
Tombow
@AA battery - Thank you for the heads-up!! ^^

@Sensenic - Thank you for these very informative comments!! Just reading your comments makes me smile!! biggrin.gif
(BTW, I'm adding the post here so that your next one ..if your post after this one.. wouldn't get merged to the one above, as your post above is already exceeding the limit for the use of emoticons in one post. XDD)
Cece
Thank you sooooo much Kale Mustang for honoring my request! I wub.gif you!
Kale Mustang
QUOTE (Cece @ Jun 16 2009, 02:22 PM) *
Thank you sooooo much Kale Mustang for honoring my request! I wub.gif you!


Not a problem and glad I could help. happy.gif
AA battery
Still no volunteers for editing? xD;

Edit: Someone PM-ed me. smile.gif
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.