Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: What Are The Saddest Songs Ever Written?
Fullmetal Alchemist Discussion Board > General Discussions > General Music
Pages: 1, 2, 3
Leeroy to the Jenkins
Mad World by Gary Jules
RoyxRizaFan
Evanescense - My Immortal, Like You, Breathe No More
Within Temptation - Our Farewell, Bittersweet, and Forgiven
Faith Hill - There You'll Be
Martina McBride - Concrete Angel
I don't know who sings this song, but its called something like Dance with My Father Again. It's SO sad.
Mat-Mat
I Don't Wanna Miss a Thing by Aerosmith (To me if you've seen Armagedon, saddest song ever!!)
God's Will by Martina McBride
Tears in Heaven by Eric Clapton sad.gif
jacksparrow589
Mine are pretty typical, but I thought I'd throw in my two bits. Some of these songs aren't neccesarily "sad" in the typical sense, but to me, they evoke a feeling of sadness.

"Dance With My Father" by Luther Vandross (This is the one that RoyxRizaFan was looking for, and I agree.)
"Tears in Heaven" by Eric Clapton
"Angel" by Sarah McLachlan (This one tops my list. Everytime I hear it, I tear up.)
"Concrete Angel" by Martina McBride
"Field of Innocence" and "My Immortal" by Evanescence
"Broken" by Seether featuring Amy Lee
"Dear Mr. President" and "Family Portrait" by Pink
"Forgiven" and "Somewhere" by Within Temptation
"Ghost of You and Me" by BBMak (I didn't want to include a separate post for just this, although this was not one of the initial ones.)

And (Since it's almost exactly 6 months 'til Christmas...) "Ornament" by Trans-Siberian Orchestra
Mat-Mat
I want to add some new sad songs to my list. sad.gif

"Who Knew?" by Pink (if you see the video, it's pretty sad.)
"The Ghost of You" by My Chemical Romance
"My Immortal" by Evanescence
"While My Guitar Gently Weeps" by The Beatles
"Life is Beautiful" by Sixx A.M.
"Van Nuys" by Sixx A.M.
Well, most of The Heroin Diaries Soundtrack by Sixx A.M. is pretty sad too.
Omamori
I have a few more to add...

Who is This Child? - Trans-Siberian Orchestra,
Better Days - Thrice,
THUNDERBIRD (piano redux) - TM Revolution,
Winter - Tori Amos,
Northern Star - Hole.
Mat-Mat
I'm going to add a few to my list.

"Cancer" by My Chemical Romance
"Golden" by Fall Out Boy
"The Christmas Shoes" by....I don't know.
"When You're Gone" by Avril Lavigne
"Never Too Late" by Three Days Grace
Little Washu
Annie by Vanessa Carlton

Now that's one depressing song...
Mat-Mat
"Seize the Day" by Avenged Sevenfold
"Candle in the Wind" by Elton John
"I'll Be" by Edwin McCain
"Sleep" by My Chemical Romance.

From all of these, "Candle in the Wind" is the saddest to me. sad.gif
Little Washu
"Dear God" and "Time For Me to Fly" by Nick Jonas

He's definitely my favorite of the three. I just learned that he has type 1 diabetes...awww D:
Omamori
American Pie - Don McLean
Little Washu
Uninstall by Chiaki Ishikawa
Mat-Mat
Dear God by Avenged Sevenfold
Emily_BrokenAngel
My Immortal and Breath no More by Evanesence
Forgiven by Within Tempation
Aozora by Lia
Inori wa by Lena Park
You are beautiful by James Blunt

Those for the moment o.o
Artixte
To me, some of the saddest songs to me would be..
Glass Skin by Dir En Grey
Ghost of You by MCR
Centrefolds, Protege Moi by Placebo
Rainshine
We got some good ones! biggrin.gif

I don't think I've listened to many sad songs, and I've probably forgot most of the ones that I have heard... *head/desk*
But... for now, I'd say "Bratja", because it's soooo pretty, and everytime I listen to it I feel like tearing up a bit. rolleyes.gif
Blysse
Endless Dream by Conjure One. Every time I hear it, it makes me want to cry so much.
Saving_Grace
Hallelujah - Jeff Buckley cover.
Knockin' On Heaven's Door - Bob Dylan
Someone else said Iris by The Goo Goo Dolls, and I just wanted to second that.
Transatlanticism and Lack of Colour by Death Cab for Cutie (okay, pretty much anything by Death Cab is depressing).
Several Ways to Die Trying - Dashboard Confessional
Forever Young - Youth Group cover.
Wynter Myth
With Eyes Wide Shut - Blessthefall

Things Left Unsaid - Disciple (<------ MEGA SAD SONG!!!! T___T)
Mat-Mat
The Scientist and Violet Hill by Coldplay
Prayer of the Refugee and Hero of War by Rise Against
Killing Loneliness and In Joy and Sorrow by H.I.M.

(In Joy and Sorrow isn't totally sad, it's just that it has the slow sad song melody.)
GREEDisGOOD
This was probably already mentioned, but "Tears in Heaven" by Eric Clapton is easily one of, if not the, saddest songs ever. A lament for his four-year-old son's death.

I'd also consider some songs off of the Pink Floyd's the Wall - "Is There Anybody Out There?" A wonderfully delicate acoustic guitar solo, as well as "Vera" and my favorite Floyd song "Comfortably Numb" - also "Wish You Were".

"You're a Big Girl, Now" by Bob Dylan is also good.
Metastasis
GREEDisGOOD, I fail to see how Comfortably Numb is a 'sad' song, unless you knew someone who was an addict. That song is about herion.

In my current situation, "One" by Metallica is the saddest song. If you haven't heard it, it is about a soldier who steps on a landmine, and lives through it. He 'wakes' up, unable to tell if he is alive or dead. None of his senses work, he's hooked up to a bunch of machines that keep him alive, and he just wants to die.

A buddy of mine recently died in a very similar way over here in Iraq. A lot of war songs have similar effects on me right now.
dion-fortune
I think there are many very sad songs but the only one stuck in my head is Queen and the Soldier by Suzanne Vega. I am crying every time I´m listening that song.
Omamori
I think I have more...

Breathe No More - Evanescence,
Why or Why Not? - Higurashi no Naku Koro Ni ED theme,
In the End (piano) - Linkin Park,
Dear You -Hope- - Hotarubi Kakeru
Rainshine
"My Immortal" - Evanescence
"The Scientist" - Coldplay
FullMetalFist
"Seize the Day"- Avenged Sevenfold
"I Won't See you Tonight Part 1 and 2"- Avenged Sevenfold
Emily_BrokenAngel
Forgiven and Memories by Within Temptation

My inmortal and Angel of Mine by Evanescense

Slipped away and When you´re Gone by Avril Lavigne

For the moment only those songs u.u
FullMetalFist
"Snuff" and "Dead Memories" by Slipknot
Nzm
Some sad songs from different genres of music:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6vS5KL3Sqg0 My Dying Bride - She is the dark
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O9beA88_66c Venetian Snares - Hajnal
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zc7uT6K2Eok Arcana - Source of light
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d-4FunzcDPE Kat - Legenda wyśniona
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z3C35wWBq1w Deine Lakaien - The game
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jXjxnzObnjw Kaliber 44 - Moja obawa
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YBfkDH3F1GA Summoning - Long lost to where no pathway goes

And ofcourse legendary
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8Kkxbw3s2pM Rezso Seress - Gloomy Sunday

EDIT: I've forgotten some awesome stuff:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1VCjAZuKoIw All my faith lost ... - Disclose your eyes
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1y_LOxZEC5g Sopor Aeternus & The ensemble of shadows - The house is empty now
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L0ajYUhAHOI Artesia - L'hiver Est Lá
Forgiven
Don't wake me-Skillet
Say Goodbye-Skillet
Let it all out-Reliant K
Tragedy Bound The Bravery
Never Too Late-Three Days Grace
Benjamin-Sanctus Real
The Ocean-The Bravery

That's all I can think of right now.
EniviD EiraM
White Horse by Taylor Swift
My Happy Ending by Avril Lavigne
Stay in Love by Mariah Carey
the other side of the door by Taylor Swift
you Belong With me by Taylor Swift

and..........


My heart will go on by Celine Dion


=(
Disasterpiece
Vermilion Pt 2

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yiGtN-dplYk

The Last Day On Earth. this one made me think of Edward and Alphonse's struggle to get their bodies back, and I almost cried listening to this one =|

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2YfZiVogQ1U

i felt dead inside and blank after this song http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I2cDiC5Aiz8

lunneth
snuff by slipknot
Katya Martin
Bach's "Komm Susser Tod" (trans. "Come Sweet Death")
Army of Me-- "Going Through the Changes"
Globus-- "Orchard of Mines"

...my memory escapes me, there's more classical stuff I wanted to put down...
Luved Kesenai Tsumi
QUOTE (Toby-Chan @ Feb 15 2007, 11:08 PM) *
Okay, let me be completely and utterly cliche' right now as I say- "Brat'ya" by Michiru Ooshima.

Shut up. I cry sometimes...

I agree with you

QUOTE (Emily_BrokenAngel @ Aug 24 2009, 07:47 PM) *
Forgiven and Memories by Within Temptation

My inmortal and Angel of Mine by Evanescense

Slipped away and When you´re Gone by Avril Lavigne

For the moment only those songs u.u

Slipped Away sometimes makes me cry and so does naked

The sad songs that I love are
Lala no Komoriuta - Wada Kaoru (It helps to see the scene from D. Gray Man)
Bratja - Oshima Michiru (of course)
Tsuioku - Oshima Michiru
Tsumi - Oshima Michiru (it is also uplifting)
Slipped Away - Avril Lavigne
Naked - Avril Lavigne
Adagio in G minor - Albinoni
Adagio for Strings
Ghost of You - My Chemical Romance ( Moved from CA to London)
Otherside - Red Hot Chili Peppers
Stadium Arcadium - Red Hot Chili Peppers
Californication - Red Hot Chili Peppers (the lyrics are so sad)
Almost Seems (Too Late to Turn) - Clannad
The Reason - Hoobastank (sad and uplifting for me)
Iris - Goo Goo Dolls
Gomenasai - t.a.t.u.
most songs from Miyazaki films

and to top it of with my favorite

One is All, All is One - Akira Senju (it made me cry)

A good place to look is at lovers of sadness
the website has a good list of sad songs
KoolCat
These are the Days of our Lives Queen

Too Much Love will Kill You Queen

Crossroads Bones Thugs N Harmony (I can't listen to this without crying)

No One but You (Only the Good Die Young) Brain May

Here Without You Three Door Down

Tears in Heaven Eric Clapton

Say Hello 2 Heaven Temple of the Dog

Knockin on Heaven's Door GNR Cover (original is Bob Dylan)

Tell me a Lie WWE (its supposed to be about a wrestler's retirement, but its written from the prespective of someone who is going through the end of a relationship, and doesn't want to admit that its over. "Maybe we could stay together, maybe it could last forever, maybe if you just, tell me a lie. Maybe then we'll never say goodbye.."
KwiatekAlchemist
-Hello by Evanescence. It's dedicated to her little sister that passed away.

-Tired of You by The Exies. This song reminds me of Ed and Al and it makes me cry.

- You are my Love by Yui Makino. Link if you want to listen: link
sidekick.kep37
Snuff- Slipknot
Remembering Sunday - All Time Low
The Greatest Fall (of all time)- Matchbook Romance
Disenchanted- My Chemical Romance
Cancer- My Chemical Romance
Red Sky- Thrice
Nearer My God to Thee -IDK who composed it, but it's off the Titanic soundtrack
Seize the Day- Avenged Sevenfold (RIP The Rev... I'm still not over that... :'( )
The Quiet Things No One Ever Knows- Brand New
Existentialism on Prom Night- Straylight Run
Your Guardian Angel- Red Jumpsuit Apparatus
FMAobsessed
Happy Birthday by Flipsyde
Fast Car by Tracy Chapman
Serb Alchemist
Toma Zdravković - Dotak'o sam dno života ("I Touched the Bottom of Life")
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bXDfsa24GXM...feature=related

Toma Zdravković (1938 - 1991). He did not sing, but he put his life in every song. These sincere emotion the audience breathlessly recognized and absorbed, with him, mourned and suffered, cheered him to persevere. Every song was part of his biography, a part of life that he knew only love, restaurant, society and music. But with all of this, life of the last bohemian is still secret.

Toma Zdravković - Dotak'o sam dno života ("I Touched the Bottom of Life")

Dotako' sam dno života, i pakao i ponore.
I touched the bottom of life, Hell, and Holes
Ali ti mi dušu uze, hej prokleti ženski stvore.
But you took my soul, you cursed woman.
Pa zbog tebe nemam mira u snovima i na javi.
And because of you I do not have peace in my dreams nor reality.

Kako da te muko moja? Kako da te tugo moja?
How will my soul? How can my sadness?
Kako da te srce moje, na trenutak zaboravi?
How can my heart, forget you only for a moment?/x2

Duboko je - daleko je, ja osetih svu goorčinu.
It is deep - It is far, I feel bitterness.
Dotako' sam dno života, sad verujem u sudbinu.
I touched the bottom of life, now I believe in destiny.
Ali tebe više nema u snovima i na javi.
But you no longer exist in my dreams nor reality.

Kako da te muko moja? Kako da te tugo moja?
How will my soul? How can my sadness?
Kako da te srce moje, na trenutak zaboravi?
How can my heart, forget you only for a moment?/x2

Šibali su moju dušu i orkani i tornada.
My soul was destroyed by hurricanes and tornados.
Ali ti mi dušu uze, hej prokleta ženo mlada.
But you took my soul cursed young woman.
Pa zbog tebe nemam mira u snovima i na javi.
And because of you I do not have peace in my dreams nor reality.

Kako da te muko moja? Kako da te tugo moja?
How will my soul? How can my sadness?
Kako da te srce moje, na trenutak zaboravi?
How can my heart, forget you only for a moment?/x2
Razzy
Final Distance - Utada Hikaru
Fantasies Come True - Avenue Q OST
Through the Years and Far Away - Ai Miyoko
Slipping Through my Fingers - ABBA
Living in Your Eyes - L`Arc~En~Ciel
First Love - Utada Hikaru
One More Time, One More Chance - Masayoshi Yamazaki

Any of those songs usually make me cry. D:
Luxuria-Cat
QUOTE (Rosicrucian @ Jul 10 2008, 11:32 PM) *

Winter - Tori Amos,
Northern Star - Hole.


I agree with these...
also "Original Sin" by Hole-so powerful-; "Black Dove" by Tori Amos always brings familiar feelings; "Top Of The World" by the Dixie Chicks; "UR A WMN NOW" by OT3P...
FMAobsessed
@Razzy: Final Distance is such a sad song, considering it is written for a girl that was killed in a school shooting in Japan, I believe.

I also find the song Mockingbird by Eminem quite sad.
Fairy of Darkness
My Immortal by Evanescence
Breath No More by Evanescence
Hello by Evanescence
Like You by Evanescence
Missing by Evanescence
The Interview by AFI

Thats all I can think of....... :\
Emily_BrokenAngel
Forgiven - Within Temptation
My Inmortal - Evanescence
First Love - Utada Hikaru
Breath No More - Evanescence
You´re Beautiful - James Blunt
Winter Love - BoA

*sob*
zinadinpeterson
The Rose by Bette Midler, this is the death and dying. But then he tells you there is hope. My late husband and I met more than a rose and my friend sang it at his funeral because he knew he was dying, but I wanted me to be happy when he disappeared.
A Pierrot's Aria
Bright Eyes by Art Garfunkel

Seriously, as soon as he sings "how can a light that burned so brightly, suddenly burn so pale?" I burst into tears. But I do love the song!

Hurt by (whoever it was originally by, but I'm going by the Johnny Cash version)

These Are the Days of Our Lives and Who Want to Live Forever by Queen

and Bratja from FMA.
Neurotripsy
For me it's 'Twenty-Four Hours' by Joy Division... sad.gif
Lucky Lucy
The Fray-How to Save a Life
Yui-Love and Truth
Three Days Grace-Here Without You
Kelly Clarkson-Because of You
SID-Rain
Hamasaki Ayumi-Kanariya/Powder Snow
Red-Already Over
Big Bang-Haru Haru
Tane Tomoko-Broken Wings
Kitamura Eri-Beautiful Wish
Pink-Family Portrait
Crystal Kay-Motherland
Noto Mamiko-Karinui
Utada Hikaru-First Love/Prisoner of Love
Changin' My Life-Eternal Snow
Steve Conte-Heaven's Not Enough
Cool Whispers(from Tatta Hitotsu No Koi)
Within Temptation-Memories
Savage Genius-Itsuka Tokeru Namida
Eurythmics-Here Comes The Rain Again
S Club 7-Never Had a Dream Come True
KAT-TUN-Bokura no Machi De/Crazy Love/White Xmas
Hysteric Blue-Cocktail
EdokunEdo
Fall at your feet by boy and Bear - its slow and sadish
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.