Joined: 28-September 04
Member No.: 814
<Moved the thread from FMA Character Discussion forum to FMA Anime American Audience sub-forum. 02/19/07 ~Tombow>
Hello im new. Can't wait for the last one, its soo gonna be bittersweet.
But in Epsiode 49 during Lyra's/Dante's plot speech she revealed that the reason that she wanted to take Rose's body was that it was because Ed was in love with her (al too). Now, I did not hear Ed vehemently (sorry about the mispelling) deny that, in fact it looked like she hit the nail on the head.
Also in the begining when he saw her dancing and he began to dance with her the was some blushing on ed part.
So where did this idea come from...Not that i don't like it. I think that its a brilliant idea.
Joined: 19-September 04
Member No.: 721
Well it's not Scar it's actually more like...
Spoiler: (Click here to Display)
One of the soldiers in the military, it's never outrightly said, but it's implied. I can't remember which episode, but Scar says something like this 'The reason she has that baby is because the military...' and Ed get's a shocked look on his face.
Joined: 12-July 04
Member No.: 199
Ed x Roze love will last forevar!!! Oh now, look what you made me do.
But more seriously and more rationally, I think Roze will die. It would be really strange for them to get together and this will probably be the dramatic way out of their budding relationship... but more surprising twists have taken place.
And Ed never showed signs that he liked her. The blushing was obviously caused by embarassment because Roze was about to confess her drug induced undying love to him.
Joined: 10-July 04
Member No.: 186
Nothing annoys me more than Rozes character. Could someone please explain her current position is she : Catatonic, Doped up to her eyes balls, the worlds biggest forking retard, an incredibly neglectful mother? what the hell is this womans problem
Joined: 17-September 04
Member No.: 711
yeah... the Ed/Al and Rose thing made absolutely NO sense AT ALL! It just sorta... happened??? and yes, it WAS mentioned how she got the baby... in episode 40 I believe
*note: I really don't consider this to be a spoiler
when Ed and Rose and Scar and them were in this house and Ed was wondering about how Rose lost her voice or something... and Scar said "Rose was taken by the millitary and by the time she got back, she had lost her voice." The implications were probably lost on a younger audience but the older audience would have probably guessed that it meant Rose had lost her voice from the shock of being totured and/or raped. Rose's baby was fathered by some perv in the millitary who raped her.
in any case, Ed understood what had happened to Rose, he put two and two together which personally, I think this means he knows something about this type of stuff... I don't think Al would have figured it out by what Scar had said.
later the dance scene with Ed blushing was probably embarressment. Rose was acting REALLY wierd. and Don't you think that Ed vehemently denying that he liked Rose would have made a difference to Dante? Ed: "What? I don't like Rose... What gave you THAT idea?" Dante: "Um... wild guess? Either way I'm still going to take her body cuz mine is rotting anyways! And everyone KNOWS that when a guy denies he likes someone then he does! I've lived for 400 years and I know this stuff! And for all I know, you are denying it to save her life so this makes me want to take her body more!" Ed: "but...!"
yeah... so you see, this doesn't mean Ed is in love with Rose... it means he knows when to keep his mouth shut when saying something might do more harm than good.
Joined: 31-July 04
From: Europe, Netherlands
Member No.: 330
I thought it was General Hakuro who raped Rose. But than I could be mistaken since he was only talking to her at Lior... doesn't mean he actually did something. He's an almighty General, afterall. Oh well.
I'd blush if someone put words into my mouth like that. But maybe that's because I blush easily. Got very light skin. Bleh.
Hmmm, I thought there was already a thread going on about Rose/Ed... Please, let this not be another Rose-bashing thread. Civil conversation will get the point across as well.
:: King of Shonen-ai :: :: - Sister to Prinz_Zoisit ::
Joined: 17-September 04
Member No.: 711
argh... how I HATE the dance scene ==' -shudder-shudder-
agreed! when I first saw it, I was like AHHHH!!!!! MY EYES!!!! x.X nooo!!!! Rose CAN'T get with Ed! she just can't! noooo!!!!!
then I spent the rest of the day telling myself that "Rose was all possessed-like" and "Ed was looking uncomfortable" etc. X.x blargh! it's not that I 'hate' Rose... I just don't like the idea of her and Ed getting together... it's too wierd for me... but Rose and Al should work out fine... Rose and Ed seems to spell out disaster. of course that's IMO