Joined: 3-February 05
Member No.: 6,982
<Moving from FMA Anime American Audience sub-forum to FMA Anime Japanese Audience sun-forum where all plot hole/continuity argument related threads are being collected currently. 02/21/07 ~Tombow.>
1. Episode:"Philosopher's Stone" (Barry The Chopper) Mistake- During Winry's Capture Barry shoved the carcases of the pigs (to show winry to ed) making the rack move, winry appears stumbling with her feet. (hands tied to the rack). Then when Barry and Ed are fighting the rack is moved and winry is shown on a stool. 2. Episode: "Mother" Mistake- After having automail "installed" Ed + Al spar (to train the mind to its potential you must train the body). While Sparring Ed kicks Al into the lake with a flying round house. [spoiler] Alphonse cant get his blood seal wet. sort of a spolier in later episodes. [/spoiler] 3. Episode: "The Other Brothers Elric Part 1" Mistake??: I dont think this is a mistake but during Ed's first encounter with Russel they fight and Russel using the philosophers stone from his pocket. I dont know if this is possible or if it is. 4.Episode: "The Phantom Theif" Mistake: Once Ed + Al enter town Ed graps something to eat or drink, and then they start exploring the city of water, while walking Ed gets splashed and Al says "it is the city of water" then Ed cleans himself up with using alchemy (clapping his hands). What happened to the food/drink that he was carrying? It could have dropped but for some one to drop what they are doing and waste food doesnt seem likely 5. Episode: Will Find out Soon Mistake: This is a possible mistake, when the Fuhrer + all the State Alchemists from the east or west (i forgot) came to central they brought along their State Alchemist's. It shows a Cafertia FULL of State Alchemist. Is this possible since only 1-2 get accepted ever exam?
<span style='color:blue'>TheVileOne</span> "How about this.
Where does Ed get new clothes and red leather jackets after he is CONSTANTLY tearing them up and getting the damaged.
When they left Lior he had a brand new, untorn and damaged red jacket."
Well that really isnt a mistake since almost all anime shows do that.
<span style='color:red'>Note:</span>This is just a list of possible mistakes in Full Metal Alchemist, they might not even be mistakes, but if they are a list of them would be nice.
<span style='color:blue'>Alright im not good with the computers so i dont know how to upload a .doc file. to get you to download it, so just copy and paste this into a word document. </span>Mistakes Corrected
Joined: 27-June 05
Member No.: 16,004
first of all, if you are going to quote something, do it properly so we can understand what you say.
QUOTE(Maes-Hughes @ Sep 4 2005, 12:33 AM)
...you really are a b**** arnt you. and what did i get wrong in my therory? my therory was solid in the homunculi weakened part.
Who the hell do you think you are?! you f****** piece of f****! I really hate to came in this kind of conversation! but you ended pushing me hard with that post! Listen! ok? you are not BONEs, you are not the script writer, you are NOTHING and NOONE to say that there is no mistakes without a proof. If you can't stand the truth and you think you are some kind of super heroe just because you make up all the answer, that's no a reason for insult, you know? I really don't care if I recieve a warning 'cause of this, but I'm not going to stand and see how a 10 years mind-old boy is insulting me without reason. You can be WRONG, you know? we can too! but you haven't a proof for what you say, admit it and maybe we'll be able continue with our lifes!
bones probably just made a mistake since ALL the homunculi that were destroyed where infront of their OWN bones
EDIT: if Bones spent time answering ALL of the questions than it would add like another 20 episodes or so which would make the anime longer and 51 is a REALLY good number for episodes g2g brb soon
oh.. wow, so 51 is a magic number of something? if the series need 20 caps more, maybe it worth it. And... if they didn't had commited all the fails, in first place, they didn't have need 20 caps more to explain it.