Joined: 20-September 04
Member No.: 735
I think the lyrics in all three of the songs are strong and very suitable for the characters; my vote goes to Hagane no Kokoro, mainly because it conveys the feelings of all three characters in a melancholy sort of way that's sadly fitting. T-T I love FMA characters so much...
Joined: 10-September 04
Member No.: 667
My vote when for Hagane no Kokoro. I just love all three of them singing together. Also, the first time I heard the Ed solo songs it reminded me of Ren from Shaman King. Romi Paku does his voice to. While when they speak I didn't get the connection, when she sings I did.
Joined: 19-September 04
Member No.: 726
Gender: Not Telling
Aww, everyone likes "Hagane no Kokoro" best... I guess it's because it's just too cute when Ed, Al and Winry all sing together... (I still like "Returnable Memories" the best, but I have to agree that "Hagane no Kokoro" is really catchy~)
I STILL wish I could figure out exactly what they're singing, but then I'd have to listen to every 10 seconds of the song like 50 times and romanize stuff by ear, which has a huge margin for errors...And then they'resthere's the online Japanese dictionaries I have to drag out...
Sigh...Why couldn't I have just been born into a Japanese family...Instead I'm stuck as a weird/insane "ABC" with horrible Japanese language skills...
(Note: Sorry for going off topic again...)
This post has been edited by Elderberry: Oct 21 2005, 09:10 PM
- Moderator Emeritus - Currently designated as Marvelous Mechanic of the P!MP Mobile for the GP. I've taken Foolmetal-kun under my wing as my GP Deshi-in training.
Joined: 28-May 04
Member No.: 19
I like Hagane no Kokoro, Winry sounds so cute in this song~! btw, Hagane isn't really "FullMetal" it's "Steel" so as you know "kokoro" is "heart", and you know what "no" means. So the name of the song is "Heart of Steel" or "Steel Heart", Title of Ep 23 and Ch. 15 ^^ ahhh old times~ Love them~
Joined: 11-March 05
From: inside The Gate
Member No.: 9,481
So many people liked Returnable Memories but it only got 5 votes(including me)? In Returnable Memories I liked how Paku Romi did Edo's voice deep and full of emotion. Even though you don't know what is being sung from just hearing it you can sort of "feel" it from the way she sings. Not to mention the music is sooo good in that one. And for some reason it reminds me of when Edo fights.
Personally I lovED Hagane No KoKoro which means Fullmetal Spirit I think, when I first heard the song. Then after about a billion times of putting it on repeat.....it was put away.
hahahah So I loved that song. Then came Asu He No Basho my second favey. I don't know why exactly it's just the sound. Then I loved Returnable Memories, but it's a little too sad for me. It's still really cool though. There are like certain parts of the song that I listen for and love.
hahah and the part whit Ed's Voice Actor struggling to make her voice deep is really cool. First off Ed is still a kid. So I really love the sorta hoarse and strangled voice-ness.
Joined: 8-April 05
Member No.: 11,397
I vote Asu he no Basho. That one had a really pretty melody that just got stuck in my head. I was humming it for days. I think my roommate even told me to shut up at one point. I love how she sings, but I feel bad for her having to try so hard to do Edward's voice while singing. It's so much harder for a woman to deepen her voice while singing than it is while speaking regularly. I'll bet she gave herself a nasty sore throat. I appreciate it, though. Those are some of my favorite songs!