'Buffy and Angel had gone out before and Buffy wasn't really comfortable talking to Spike and Angel at the same time, because now Spike and Buffy had been going out for 6 months and Buffy was afraid that Angel might tell Spike that him and Buffy went out, but it turns out that Angel had told Spike that they went out, Spike was heartbroken that Buffy never told him that they went out, so Spike broke up with Buffy to get back at her for not telling him that Angel and Buffy went out.'
Joined: 28-June 04
Member No.: 135
Is this referring to the anime or the manga? Because if it's the manga, it's no doubt Winry, but if it's the anime, then it'd be a close one for me.
Well, anyway, while I love Rose's personality (and hair ), I'm going to have to go with Winry. I love the way her character is portrayed, always silently waiting for Ed and Al. (Ok, maybe not so silent at times, but still...)
Joined: 13-July 05
Member No.: 16,922
QUOTE(SinLuxuria @ Jul 13 2005, 09:56 AM)
And I choose Roze!
bIG uP SinLuxuria! i CHOOSE ROSE too! Rose hasn't done anything wrong, so ED- fangirls shud hush their mouths.
Enough of ma "chav" impersanation. Seriously though, Rose has been through so much and she is still living. So i would choose Rose all the waY, and this be not in this duscussion but i so badly think Al x Rose or ED x ROse would work out. I see Winry n Ed too much like brother n sister.
*SIT DOWN N SHUT YA ED-FANGIRLS- HE'S NOT MINE- HE'S NOT URS- HE'S ROSES! (Or wirny im not quite sure yet... )
I don't like Rose that much. Her personality was okay in the beginning of her appearance, but then became She's weak in a way. Well she was in the episodes I saw. Her crying and whining will never help her past. She's just not my fav.
Winry and Ed are much more obvious. They can't be just family now. Winry's already realized her feelings...Ed...he's become a sucker at realizing that type of stuff.
There's no possible way for RosexEd. That's not much chemistry, no real clicks of real love like Ed/Win going on there, almost everybody can see it. Sorry people but I'm pretty sure that's not going to happen.
Ed claims Winry isn't a love interest, but he's usually blushing when he says it. And even Winry started to realize she was falling for Ed in the manga. Ed's clueless in the anime, Winry is more aware of her feelings.
Rose was only a minor character in the manga, I don't know why she suddenly needed to be so important in the anime like NightMistress said. EdxWinry are closer than EdxRose. No, Winry and Ed are practically together and I'm not just saying that becuz I like them together. Much more evidence than Ed/Rose.
AND ED IS MINE AND WINRY'S!!! But I'll share, not with Rose though. Maybe some fangirls just like him only for what he looks like but not me. *sigh* I don't care what he looks like! As long as he has that same determined soul and heart and that wonderful personality he's still that amazing Edward I fell in love with! He's inspired and actually helped me on a certain situation in my life to not give up living no matter what happens to you... you gotta be strong...(sounds weird, but true). *heart eyes* So strong-hearted and breath-taking!
Ed: *sweat drops*...You're scaring me....
Me: Still love and care about you no matter what! *hugs Ed* Thanks for everything Ed! I can't believe I was slowly falling for you!
Joined: 25-June 05
Member No.: 15,896
Fangirls They see an alternative love interest involving the main character and they go berserk.
In any case, I choose Rose. While I like Winry a lot in both the anime and the manga (more so in the manga), there's something about Rose that makes me prefer her over all other females in the anime. Maybe its episodes 1 and 2, maybe episodes 41-43, *shrug* maybe episode 49, but I really like her
Joined: 15-December 04
From: California, USA
Member No.: 3,783
Whoa, people, this isn't a "Who's better for Ed" thread. =_=
Anyway, I choose Roze. I really like both Winry and Roze (well, only anime Roze) but Roze, after losing her boyfriend, realizing she was following a twisted belief, and getting raped, which impregnated her, still manages to go on with her life and live it as best as she can. That's why I think she's a great character.
Joined: 2-May 05
From: Hong Kong
Member No.: 13,044
Well I think Winry isn't really a likeable character unless you like girls with showy clothes like *some fanboys*. I hate how she dresses. It upset me she wouldn't admit to Ed her mistake with the automail (A-08) that time. It disturbed me she believed and actually shamelessly told Sheska Hohenheim has a crush on her. I feel disgusted everytime I see her posing in the Motherland clip. Other than that she is an okay character.
About EdWin... Evidence doesn't always mean a good pairing.
Those people who call Rose a slut should bump their heads on a wall (that may make them a little more reasonable I guess). It was unfortunate Rose got raped and pregnant, she didn't want that.
She's weak in a way. Well she was in the episodes I saw. Her crying and whining will never help her past.
Rose did cry. But Winry cried much more. Then Winry should even be weaker if you say crying means weakness.
Urahara and Yoruichi Sorry if my coloring stinks and hurts your eyes or sth.