full metal alchemist
full metal alchemist

Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

"Genre" discussions: categorizing Silver Spoon, is it "slice of life"? "school drama"?, Is Silver Spoon considered as Shounen? Or...?
post Apr 13 2011, 10:04 PM
Post #1


Group: Members
Posts: 151
Joined: 31-October 06
From: Los Angeles
Member No.: 42,571
Gender: Female

QUOTE (RoyxRizaFan @ Apr 13 2011, 04:33 PM) *
Did anyone notice the PE teacher looks exactly like Armstrong? lol

And the three main characters remind me of Watanuki, Himawari, and Doemeki from xxxHolic a little bit laugh.gif I'm sure that as these characters develop these similiarities will lessen but my first impression was of this - I mean, the nonathletic boy with glasses has a crush on the sweet, inviting girl, who has a relationship he doesn't fully understand with the dark, athletic other-guy (for lack of a better noun).

I also thought the kid seated behind Hachiken in the homeroom looked a bit like Mustang. happy.gif

Likewise with the xxxHolic similarity. And the vet kid reminded me a bit of Fai from Tsubasa, or possibly Rurouni Kenshin.

As for my overall impression, if Arakawa was trying to do something as different from FMA as possible, well, this would be it, lol! If someone told me that there was a manga about kids who attend an agricultural high school, odds are my initial reaction would be to ignore it (I'm not much for the slice of life and/or school genres, especially if they feature some hokey sport or skill), but since this was Arakawa, I'm willing to give it a chance. Thanks to FMA, I've developed a love for her art and story-telling styles, not to mention her characterization skills. Time will tell if I truly come to enjoy this one, but it's off to a decent start.

<Mod note: Topic below was split into a separate thread. Anyone who would like to reply on this topic, please add your post on "Genre" discussions: categorizing Silver Spoon thread. smile.gif >
On a side note, is this really going to be considered a "shonen" series? XD It hardly seems that way so far to me! Unless the high school turns out to be a front for something epic! wink.gif Doubtful, hah.
Go to the top of the page
+Quote Post
Start new topic
post Apr 14 2011, 08:44 AM
Post #2

Special Ops (Piratical Gallery Enforcement)

Group: Gallery Moderators
Posts: 2,038
Joined: 23-July 07
From: Western U.S.
Member No.: 48,158
Gender: Female

<Note: This topic was split from Silver Spoon chapter One discussion thread. smile.gif ~ Tombow>

QUOTE (allykatty1 @ Apr 13 2011, 10:04 PM) *
On a side note, is this really going to be considered a "shonen" series? XD It hardly seems that way so far to me! Unless the high school turns out to be a front for something epic! wink.gif Doubtful, hah.

This could very well be a shonen manga. "Shonen" simply means that the target audience younger males, about 10-18. Beyond that, there don't seem to be any other real "requirements", least of all for being epic, even if a lot of shonen has that tendency.

On that note, I'd argue that this series very much has the potential to be epic in its own way. Clearly, you can't say much from a first chapter, but it looks like Hachiken's got some sort of inner struggle going about his dreams, and he's going to have to overcome/somehow deal with that. This, in fact, was a lot of what made FMA so epic for me. Also, it looks like it's going to be pretty hilarious as Hachiken tries (and, I'm going to guess, succeeds to some degree) to adjust to the culture of the school.

Really, when all's said and done, does it matter that much if it's shonen or shojo or seinen or josei, or if it's not the common contemporary definition of epic? I'd wager that Arakawa doesn't draw because it's shonen or because it's epic, but that what she draws what she wants to, and that (mostly, at least--I'm no aficionado of her works!) happens to be labeled shonen. (And epic, I think.) I can speak only for myself, but I'll read it as long as I like it, shonen or otherwise. smile.gif


Credit goes to Causmicfire for my avatar

The Royai Day party might be over, but the fun never stops!
Royai Day 2011 Album
Thank you to all those who contributed!

Go to the top of the page
+Quote Post
post Apr 16 2011, 10:32 PM
Post #3

State Alchemist (Major)

Group: Members
Posts: 718
Joined: 18-June 08
From: A little corner of my mind
Member No.: 60,395
Gender: Female

Actually, I've always thought the idea of labeling mangas as "shounen" or "seinen" or "shoujo" something impressively limiting and definitely not very intuitive.
At least not in terms of determining whether a manga should be put on this or that magazine or if it's suitable for this or that audience, or as in labeling an author as a "shounen writter".

If you think about it, it comes a lot more down to the 'mission' of a particular manga magazine than anything else: GanGan is completely different in terms of definition than Shounen Sunday, that, on it's turn, is also completely different than Shounen Jump... They have different views, different goals, different interests... And they're all put under the definition of "Shounen Magazines".

And we could say Arawaka has never been a "shounen writer" in the true sense of the world, since she has raged from Imperial China to Early 20th Century Europe inspired mangas and, though all of them happened to fall under the category of "fantasy" and "shounen" are all very different among themselves and different from your "regular" shounen series (which is traditionally connected, mostly, to the series portrayed in Shounen Jump and magazines that follow a similar approach).

Shounen Sunday is a more 'quotidian' oriented sort of magazine and that's their aim... always has been. And I believe that is a true challenge for Arakawa to pick up a genre where she's not really comfortable with (or better putted "acquainted" with) and it actually shows, in my opinion, that she's reaching a more mature level of writing, by taking bigger risks and "stepping out of her comfort zone", which is more than we can say from most mangakás around.

So, it's not something only about "Arakawa's Work" but a lack of genres in Manga/Anime in general, since the industry has built itself in a VERY different way than our normal "Western arts industry". The definition of a "genre" in mangas, for example, are a lot more defined by who it's producing that manga (meaning the printing company, the editor, the sponsors...) than an actual 'genre' in and for itself.

So, in sum, yes, Gin no Saji is a very different series from what we've seen so far by Arakawa. But I also think it's rather pointless to actually try to 'label' it as anything aside that it's a "Shounen Sunday series" with a "realistic/quotidian" sort of approach. Whether is seinen, shounen, shoujo or anything else, it makes little difference, since these categories mean very little. (they have very little in terms of real meaning to add to an understanding of "what a series is" or what to expect of it)
For me, these terms are as generic as if saying "Asian Movie industry" (where you can put something like Bollywood, chinese kung fu movies and Akira Kurosawa as "the same" O.o)


Vi Veri Veniversum Vivus Vici
"By the power of truth I, while living, have conquered the universe"
Faust, Göethe
Go to the top of the page
+Quote Post

Posts in this topic

Reply to this topicStart new topic
1 User(s) are reading this topic (1 Guests and 0 Anonymous Users)
0 Members:


Lo-Fi Version Time is now: 29th August 2016 - 07:47 AM

Copyright ©2003-2004 PhoenixNetworks, LLC. All rights reserved.
Copyright Notice. Privacy policy. Acceptable Use Policy. Terms of Service.
Page Generation Time: 0.0655 seconds.
Currently Selected Stylesheet: css/default.css