Joined: 11-April 08
Member No.: 58,548
I'll comment later regarding my reactions (I'm still in shock).
Regarding Mustang - Maybe the storyboard said "This photograph shows Mustang-tachi" and for some weird reason it was written in English and the 'i' looked a little funky and the animator thought it looked like an 'e'...
If someone types L337 SP34K in a forest and no one else is around, are they still a noob?
Joined: 22-August 09
Member No.: 70,732
SAMKFHAKKAJHFDASJHFOASHDO (ok better now )
I am not a manga purist, but (in my opinion) it was clear the manga was superior in FMA from the get go. But this episode...the additions didn't make it worse (except the Musta-ch) it made them infinitely better. I love it, I love you BONES, and GODDAMN it this episode is completely amazing!!!!!!!!! (EdxWin blushes...SO CUUUTTTTTTE)
Joined: 8-June 10
Member No.: 74,365
First I'll get my complaints out of the way.
I REALLY wish they hadn't been forced to use storyboards for these last two episodes because I liked the manga panels. And the art in this episode was pretty awful for the first half. Mustang's arms, Olivier's face, Scar's... everything. So much QUALITY. And Mustang's 'stache? Gross. First hot!Father's voice and now this, BONES must be actively trying to subvert all the estrogen brigade bait.
Now, that that's out of my system, the second half of the episode had great artwork. I loved the use of "RAY OF LIGHT" during the scene with the chimeras. Also, I know I go out of my way to let everyone know I hate EdWin and always will, but that scene at the end was just too adorable. Finally, I loved how they closed the series with such an upbeat song.
Joined: 24-February 06
Member No.: 31,830
Changes from the manga bugged the hell out of me. Lack of humour, dodgy writing changes, total change of stuff with Mustang and co. that bothered me. Havoc getting Philosophers Stone'd bugs me. I did kinda like Knox showing up again, I can't believe I forgot about him. (although his last appearance in the manga was a nice conclusion for him)
Winry scenes were dragged out and kind of excruciating to watch. A shame, since I loved those parts of the manga. (although the addition of her walking past the photos was a nice touch - if it was done with more subtlety and speed it could've been goodness)
Overly 'grand' music bothered me as well.
Al looks like Mustang, down to the age appearance.
Good that Ed narrates the last part.
No idea what to make of the movie thing.
The episode sums up a lot of my problems with the adaptation, really. :\
Joined: 3-April 09
Member No.: 67,576
Hmm. Well, I liked it. I read the manga too.
One thing is bothering me, though. Nothing major, only a detail. The anime says Ed and Al spent 2 years in Risenbool before going on their travels. Ok."EdxWin" confession happens when Ed is boarding the train. Eh... So, they spent 2 years together without, you know, confessing? I mean, haha, Winry already liked Ed, and they spent 2 years with nothing happening? That's just... weird. If it were like, 2 months... maybe... I know anime characters like to keep their feelings for themselves forever (which bothers me sometimes and can be incredibly annoying. I mean, geez, grow a pair. -.-), but 2 years is just too much. O_o
Joined: 10-January 06
Member No.: 28,876
QUOTE (BlackSwordsman @ Jul 5 2010, 08:41 AM)
The anime says Ed and Al spent 2 years in Risenbool before going on their travels. Ok."EdxWin" confession happens when Ed is boarding the train. Eh... So, they spent 2 years together without, you know, confessing?
Same in the manga, the two year skip starts with Grumman there. Besides, Ed may have been too young to legally propose before or such.
Joined: 27-January 05
From: a land called Honah Lee
Member No.: 6,466
Gender: Not Telling
Okay, my thoughts on the EdxWin, or more specifically what 64 adds.
The 2 year gap, now what's to say there wasn't anything going on? Even Gracier states that they are like a married couple. Emotionally they settled in to living together comfortably. As I stated before, she is wearing Ed's jumper on the day he leaves, and to me that is a symbol of...something. It takes us back to the incident with Scar when he wraps her coat around her and she grips it tightly. It is his protection and warmth.
I think we are lead to believe Ed always planned to "propose" to Winry. As they are approaching the house Al asks Ed if he is sure about Winry. Perhaps Edward isn't sure and rather than rush anything at the age of 16 he waited until it felt right to make Winry officially his.
Joined: 3-April 09
Member No.: 67,576
Hmm, I wasn't sure if it was a confession or a proposal. So I wasn't sure if they were already dating or something like that, or not.
Heh, I wish anime characters would kiss sometimes. I know it's cultural differences, a kiss is something more intimate and when they want to show something from solely the romantic point of view, they show a hug. But I'm not so sure about that, because I've seen kisses in shoujo anime. Do japanese guys don't like kisses or something? =p
Well, grown up Ed with that coat looks incredibly like Hoeinhemen (sp?). I hope life doesn't repeat itself all over again. XD
Joined: 25-August 09
Member No.: 70,773
Well, there's a lot o be said, but only one thing's for sure: the series has ended ;___;
I LOVED the EdWin moment. I agree, they should have kissed, ofcourse, but once I saw it wasn't happening in the manga I got over it. I don't like Roys moustache. It's like a caterpillar fell on his face. Get it off, Roy. You didn't have it in the manga. Please BONES, I love you, but don't try and be creative on your own. I actuall liked te fact that Riza cut her hair again. I loved long hair on her, but th fact she just cut it off again is so Riza. Badass. I know I'll always carry this in my heart with me, for FMA has changed my view on things a lot. I love you, FMA, andI will never forget you.
I really can't wait for the movie. I wder what'llbe about.
Joined: 21-November 09
Member No.: 71,965
Great episode. I'm a bit of a manga purist so I tend to look unfavorably on anime when they change things but this episode was done brilliantly. Easily 10/10, if not better.
My only real complaint is that Riza had no lines. Once I realized they were changing stuff up I was hoping they would add in another Roy/Riza scene but they didn't. Just a couple still shots of her in the background.