QUOTE(Maes-Hughes @ Aug 30 2005, 02:53 AM)
well whoever made that list doesnt know fma well
Ed is able to make the water boil because he DID clap his hands if u watch it you would see it just takes him a few seconds after he claps
EDIT: after reading even more from that list, the person certainly hasnt watched fma alot or even likes the show, most of their accusations can be proven wrong, like where did all that "incomplete stone" in episode 22 come from. the military has been killing people and using them as ingredients
Episode 18- why is lust able to explode part of the library? NOTE: IT WAS SCAR NOT LUST
Episode 19- scar's arm can do more than just destroy things, he already knew the secret of the stone before he "read" the notes from marcoh
Episode 22- Envy said "no one created us, we were born"
Envy was correct in saying that, they were born but then died.http://www.ahboba.com/otros/bonesmistakes.pdf
i only read like 6 complaints and most of them are falseI will print out the sheet and go over "the mistakes" and correct each one.
Please, before stating what you are going to say, at least, read it well and then check for it.
I was the one who did the list and I like fma, what I don't like is what bones did to the second half.
Ed DOESN'T CLAP, he just puts his fist to his palm.
Please, whatch the episode again. Scar made the ENTIRE laboratory explode. Yeah, but why did Lust made explode some part of the shelfs? That's clearly shown. So please, whatch it again.
In later episodes it's said he can't. Just because he does it, doesn't mean he can. The tatoo of his arm is the part of the philosopher's stone's transmutation circle. 1)Scar doesn't know how to use alchemy (EVEN IF HE CREATES THE PHILOSOPHER'S STONE <--that's something bones used to create it and safe plot deepeners, animation etc. and rush the ending)
2)A transmutation circle is for what it is, even if it is the red stone itself, doesn't have the power to take all the letters, nor to descript nor anything besides transmutating.
There are LOTS of episodes besides this where not only envy but wrath and the others say "we weren't created, we were born!" and suddenly "we were created!" and even "we were created by THIS RED STONE!"
BTW, I wasn't complaining about that red stone, but about the red water from which it is supposed to come, from the invented episode where they find the false Elrics who have a whole mountain with this red water.
This should be discussed in "Do you hate what BONES did to FMA"? Since I posted the link there.
I will print out the sheet and go over "the mistakes" and correct each one.
whoa! At least someone is willing to discuss it! ^^ it's great, since I (well we) will be able to develope it before we send it to BONES.
Anyways, please, watch all the episodes, one by one, as soon as posible (so you won't forget things), maybe find some friend to help you, and note the most important things concerning to what I said in a notebook or something and then come into conclussions or statements, so we can safe time.
It took me a week, working 8-10 hours per day or so to find all that, watching some episodes and checking things more than once. So I hope you will take this seriously and watch and note all the facts in a notebook as I did and keep watching and checking befor saying anything.